The URL can be used to link to this page

6230 SW 70 ST_EB-05-081_001 a' r S•O U�� o � A4 U ., INCORPORATED 1927 �ORt� January 18, 2006 Attn: Mr. Arthur Colsky 6280 SW 72 Street #611 South Miami, FL 33143 Re: Environmental Review& Preservation Board No. 05-081 EXTERIOR RENOVATION 6230 SW 70 Street South Miami, FL On the ERPB meeting of Tuesday, January 17, 2006 the motion was approved as presented. Staffs conditions: 1. Applicant must comply with the valet parking and conditions. 2. Applicant must comply with the tree removal conditions. Your next process is to submit for a building permit by contacting the Building Department at (305) 663-6358. If you have any further questions regarding this application, please contact Ms. Lourdes Cabrera-Hernandez at (305) 663-6347 at the Planning Department. Note: Pursuant to Section 20-5.11(L) Expiration. Final approval by ERPB shall lapse after six (6) months if no permit is issued, except as may be extended by the ERPB for a period not to exceed six (6) months. Sincerely, Don O'Donniley, AICP Planning Director Planning Department An appeal of an ERPB decision or recommendation may be filed at any time before a building permit is issued by filing same with the city clerk upon a form prescribed therefore. Appeals may be taken by the applicant, interested citizens, or the city administration [per § 20-6.2 (A) of the City's Land Development Code]. If you have any questions concerning this matter, please contact Ms. Lourdes Cabrera-Hernandez,of the Planning Department, between the hours of 8:00 AM and 5:00 PM, Monday through Friday at 305-663- 6347. .l Part 1 n City of SoutlyMi mi PLANNING DEPARTMENT APPLICATION FEES 9 DATE: CHECK NO: NAME: /L- . ADDRESS: h7, Sto S PHONE NO: 03.41.300 ERPB HEARING FEES ° dC> (Total) Applications for new construction in the RS and RT.zoning districts Single unit ($500) All other applications for: New construction($600);Renovati $300); igns, fences,walls, etc. ($150) For each additional appearance befor - bard($100) CA VARIANCE 02.19.161 Advertisement and Notice Fees ............................($1,000) 03.41.200 Admin Fee.......................................................($1000) (TOTAL$2000) o EACH ADDITIONAL VARIANCE............................($750) SPECIAL USE/SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS 02.19.161 Advertisement and Notice Fees............................($1,000) 03.41.200 Admin Fee.......................................................($1000) (TOTAL$2000) 02.19.161 REZONING APPLICATION (less than 10 acres).........($4000) 02.19.161 REZONING APPLICATION (more than 10 acres).....($13,500) LDC TEXT AMENDMENT I(General standards,misc..provisions) 02.19.161 Advertisement and Notice Fees................................. ($1,000) 03.41.200 Admin Fee............... .......................................... ($1000) (TOTAL$2000) LDC TEXT AMENDMENT II(Change Permitted use Schedule) 02.19.161 Advertisement and Notice Fees................................. ($3,000) 03.41.200 Admin Fee............... .......................................... ($1000) TOTAL($4000) 02.19.161 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMEND AD FEE............$15,000) 03.41.200 COMPREHENSIVE PLAN ADMIN FEE..................($5,000) (Total$20,000) 02.19.161 ADMINISTRATIVE WAIVER AD FEE.......................($250) 03.41.200 ADMINISTRATIVE WAIVER FEE...........................($ 500) (Total$750) 02.19.161 PUD/MAJOR CHANGE LEGAL ADS($1,000) 03.41.200 PUD/MAJOR CHANGE ADMIN FEE($2,500) (Total $3500) 03.41.200 PUD MINOR CHANGE ADMIN FEE($1,000) 03.41.200 WAIVER-OF-PLAT APPLICATION($3,000) TOTA E:\Forms\Receipt forms\Receipt form UPDATED-REV 12-21-04.doc CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI Excellence, Integrity, Inclusion \ ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW& PRESERVATION BOARD To: Chair& Members, Environmental Date: January 17, 2006 - Review& Preservation Board Tuesday 8:30 a.m. Via: Don O'Donniley Dam Planning Director From: Lourdes Cabrera- ernandez Re: ERPB-05-081 Planner Applicant: Arthur Colsky Location: 6230 SW 70th Street, South Miami Request: Exterior Renovation APPLICANT'S REQUEST: The applicant is requesting final approval from the ERPB for the renovation of the site plan, located at the above address. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Attached sketch survey. Background & STAFF ANALYSIS: At the ERPB meeting of December 6, 2005, applicant received preliminary approval with conditions refer to the attached letter dated December 7, 2006. Previous staff report dated December 6, 2005 enclosed for reference. At this time, the applicant has submitted a landscape plan that reflects one tree to be removed. The attached Tree removal permit dated January 12, 2006, refers to the conditions. Upon final approval of the site plan from the ERPB, the applicant will proceed with valet parking conditions, tree removal conditions, and an occupational license. The property may continue to be used as an RO "Residential-Office zoning district; which is permitted by right. However, it must meet the parking requirements and the dimensional non-conformity is not increased. At this time the applicant is requesting final approval of the site renovation from the ERPB. RECOMMENDATION: Final Approval, with the following conditions: 1) Applicant must comply with the valet parking and conditions; and, 2) Applicant must comply with the tree removal conditions; and, 3) Any comments and/or concerns from the Board. Attachments: ERPB letter dated 12/07/05, ERPB Report 12/06/05, Tree Permit Application, Application, Survey, Photos and Landscape plan. LCH K:\ERPB\ERPB Agendas\2006 ERPB AGENDAS\ERPB Jan. 17, 2006\ERPB 05-081 F.doc oul, 0t_ ."v UO Rt December 7, 2005 Mr. Arthur Colsky 6280 SW 72 Street #611 South Miami, FL 33143 Re: Environmental Review& Preservation Board No. 05-081 EXTERIOR RENOVATION 6230 SW 70 Street South Miami, FL On the ERPB meeting of Tuesday, December 6, 2005 the motion was preliminary approval with the following conditions to be met by applicant: Board: 1. Applicant returns for final approval with a landscape plan done by a landscape architect with the actual size,position and correct location of the ramp. 2. Applicant complies with six (6) parking spaces and removal of one oak tree (center tree) in front yard of property. Staff: 3. Applicant must comply with valet parking and conditions. 4. Applicant must comply with the tree removal conditions. The next deadline date is Monday at noon, December 12, 2005, for the upcoming ERPB meeting of Tuesday, December 20, 2005 at 8:30 AM. If you have any further questions regarding this application, please contact Lourdes Cabrera-Hernandez at (305) 663- 6347 at the Planning Department. Note: Pursuant to Section 20-5.11(L) Expiration. Final approval by ERPB shall lapse after six (6) months if no permit is issued, except as may be extended by the ERPB for a period not to exceed six (6) months. Sincerely, Don O'Donniley, AICP / Planning Director Planning Department An appeal of an ERPB decision or recommendation may be filed at any time before a building permit is issued by filing same with the city clerk upon a form prescribed therefore. Appeals may be taken by the applicant, interested.citizens, or the city administration [per § 20-6.2 (A) of the City's Land Development Code]. If you have any questions concerning this matter, please contact Ms. Lourdes Cabrera-Hernandez, of the Planning Department, between the hours of 8:00 AM and 5:00 PM, Monday through Friday at 305-663- 6347. CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI Excellence, Integrity, Inclusion ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW& PRESERVATION BOARD To: Chair& Members, Environmental Date: December 6, 2005 Review& Preservation Board Tuesday 8:30 a.m. Via: Don O'Donniley Planning Director From: Lourdes Cab_rer ernandez Re: ERPB-05-081 Planner Applicant: Arthur Colsky Location: 6230 SW 70th Street, South Miami Request: Exterior Renovation APPLICANT'S REQUEST: The applicant is requesting preliminary approval from the ERPB for the renovation of the site plan, located at the above address. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Attached sketch survey. Background & STAFF ANALYSIS: Currently the subject property is a single-family residential building, which is a legal nonconforming structure (dimensional substandard). The property may continue to be used as an RO "Residential-Office zoning district; which is permitted by right. However, it must meet the parking requirements and the dimensional non-conformity is not increased. For zoning history please refer to the tabbed page on the package. Applicant applied for a Variance to allow four off-street parking spaces where the required off-street parking is five spaces; and to allow required parking to be located in the front setback area which is prohibited in the RO zoning use district and was denied on January 4, 2005. At this time, the valet parking is contingent of the applicant obtaining an occupational license for the valet operation and for occupying the subject property and the applicant receive approval of the site plan from the ERPB. Refer to Valet parking, dated 9/13/05 and the proposed parking layout. Plan proposes six parking spaces and removal of one tree. Although, the tree removal permit has been approved applicant needs to address the conditions and submit a landscape plan. Refer to tree removal permit attached. At this time the applicant is requesting preliminary approval of the site renovation from the ERPB. RECOMMENDATION: Prliminary Approval, with the following conditions: 1) Applicant must comply with the valet parking and conditions; and, 2) Applicant must comply with the tree removal conditions; and, 3) Applicant return to the ERPB with a proposed landscape plan; and 7039 SW t Avenue —" Exterior Renovation ERPB - December 6, 2005 Page 2 of 2 4) Any comments and/or concerns from the Board. Attachments: A) Application B) Survey C) Parking Layout D) Photos E) Valet Parking with conditions, dated 9/13/05 F) Application for Tree Removal w/conditions dated 7/15/05 G) City Commission Variance Package LCH K:\ERPB\ERPB Agendas\2005 AGENDAS\ERPB December 6, 2005\ERPB 05-081.doc x � South Miami o FIor, i d 2001 CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI PLANNING DEPARTMENT Tree Removal Permit Conditions January 12,2006 Applicant: Skin Source Inc. Project address: 6230 SW 70 Street South Miami, F133143 APPLICANT'S REQUEST: The applicant has filed for a tree removal permit for the removal of 1 specimen Live Oak. The permit is approved with the following conditions: 1. Applicant replaces canopy with 2 Live Oaks 2" DBH and 12' in height or, 2. Applicant replaces canopy with 1 Live Oak 4" DBH and 16' in height and, 3. All newly-planted plant material shall be watered by temporary or permanent irrigation system until such time as they are established and, 4. All plants installed shall conform to, or exceed, the minimum standards for Florida Number One as provided in the most current edition of:Grades and Standards for Nursery Plants, Part I and II," prepared by the State of Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services and, 5. Failure to plant, preserve, or maintain each individual tree shall be considered a separate violation of this Code and, 6. The trees are not removed until the ERPB has issued its final approval for the site plan. I the legal owner/agent of the above referenced project agree with the conditions placed on this tree removal permit. Signature Date Sworn to me and subscribed to me this day of , 2006 Public Notary My commission expires: CADocuments and Settings\Lkruger\Desktop\Planning\Tree Conditions\6230sw70st\tree6230sw70st(2).doc 6130 SUNSET DRIVE SOUTH MIAMI,FL 33143 TEL: 305-663-6358 ♦ FAX:305-666-4591 CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI PLANNING &ZONING DEPARTMENT ® ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW AND PRESERVATION BOARD APPLICATION VffF2-Or, STREET ADDRESS OF JOB: � �� o SOUTH MIAMI,FL PROPERTY OWNER: G�� C��S TEL.NO. 3 a ; �� (� ADDRESS: o swio� A �� l/I _/' az 3� 7 STREET CITY STATE ZIP WHAT IS THE PRESENT USE OF THE PROPERTY? SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE BUSINESS OFFICE RETAIL STORE OTHER: APARTMENT OR TOWNHOUSE MEDICAL OFFICE AUTO REPAIR PLEASE,BRIEFLY SUMMARIZE THE WORK TO BE PERFORMED: � AAMPP_ WHAT WILL THE TOTAL COST BE TO COMPLETE THIS PROJECT? APPLICANT'S NAME: �iG /G� TEL NO. ADDRESS: p Z 0(1 �7 (�D //7( � � /// �F ✓ STREET CITY STATE ZIP 7 FAX NUMBER: / D (,9 ( I AS THE APPLICANT,PLEASE,INDICATE YOUR RELATIONSHIP TO THIS PROJECT ,y OWNER OF THE PROPERTY TENANT/LESSEE CONTRACTOR OTHER: OWNER OF THE BUSINESS ARCHITECT ENGINEER PLEASE,INDICATE CONTACT PERSON(ERPB's decision will be mailed to the contact ESTson indicated below): PROPERTY OWNER APPLICANT Lo �i�►L� �/V S G T" J G� '1 OTHER(provide name and address) 4 r E _ NOV 2 3 2005 PLEASE SIGN YOUR NAME ON THE LINE ABOVE DATE fj/P { SKETcH of SURVE Y SCALE l' - 12©.Utz/ -ro w.R �A 6 a fc-'.V4,c4=-z'r wc004C14&9 ja,SD / a ' 1 /"70 THE '6kS7V-A(.Y lit :9c)} twro -rq gib• �. � .,r"- F r� 54,0 O Z NG�G -6d �' w (P-)cm) 3) A, pGAjp8 alG► A��'='S 2-001 - 90169�//!'D pifc^ �dTHEfZGY eC�0'7�: ,h� T"brJ�v� 3� v'iSS>'dL� cr��d=%f�1�sr✓'FS. 4 .7;YE sxr Y f7 S 70''`� A ODC*MJG TO IF E NATlEPNAL Fi-QC1D MkMM P�TF�s T t'F�. . 1r F�cU�S�1 Fi O.: ZpNC- X77 tdca= PANEL Mx: EDS= DATE OF'Mh FFM ZoNe. WED ROOD a-E1, f.��9� v 2��. 3" T�7"�mss" �r�r �I/ J�• LOCATION MAP CN.T.S.) Nc I ' PROPERTY ADDRESS: . 6230 S-W. 70th Street, Miami, Florida 33143 . LEGAL DESCRIPTION: The West 54 .00 feet of the North 88 :OE3 feet on the East 137 .00 feet of the North '150 . 00 feet o'f the West of the Southeast 1, of the Southeast 4 of the Southwest of Section 25, Township 54 South, Range 40 East, lying and being in Dade County, Florida. FOR: MARTA MILLIAN GONZALEZ. CERTIFY TO: MARTA MILLIAN GONZALEZ.- I UNION TITLE SERVICES, INC. STEWART TITLE GUARANTY COMPANY, INC. j i SURVEYDRS NDTE6: PAE�AF�BT. T)Thi1 evvey vraa conducted for the pupoee of a-amoidwy Survey my antl a not ntenoetl to dNmet&the nary��o, ��T-•� GROUP 1 d wN f�dareL stave.mpbrmf Or loom along.hoard.canvnk.s-m on ec7tNF. GUN V I CR W"I V UI- {�(i. LB 4507 ?!Trio acarxy obtak"a by nn&s&2ixr erne end cetaAmwe m tie,eunry.meets any exceeds tae NU*TRM Tntivn.al Stwr aroa L q�g( f�JQ-LAND F' C. LEi G raquFenaam2s for e.l4a3cerjen area(1 hot In 7.bpp leap ae epedAed N Cherner 61 CT 7-0,Fbeye°dnTtrfaa'ar-e GSde. 3)ATQ nmt nsism or dererrra -v Ine onwor9p' 9350 S.W. Z2nd TERRACE 4)LepoLdeacdPkxa suboct to and madbeftm.hT*8%Wm,reevl=dorm n3swva hne or eaaerT M d nroorcL ktiAMl, FLORIDA 33765 a B=ntTSeen of tae AbStI iot or T Ze wfR h3wv m ba made Io delenmhp-doomed hsv+rr+ana a any rnraamq a a p Qparty sea crT & see a WY ran olFtbb RD=Xde not parkI mild by Sao r oirea. (305) 220-OD73 a)t`I?ef7Oef was mado bf hers oTOD to loam:eery taTdeto ound MUG wr3.4r avu=w ea w,te in or aouelp vv e:.�b„-t pra�ery, .toy a A==- 6)TI+It sev vy hea beRr P ePmed for the&rrca-ah a uee Of fie a v%m"a a hereon orf y end fns=912fcWtims hrJaon do nOf ro muo m rR eratendta et*,.uvamTTad onto- rXII m "Mx 9f LJ9ly fioltles--thin UMY t:osarnerda not noted e9 rddffiOns e r ;a sar°aOire ea� tnjt - yp ce P7b=m tmmof witm poedwvyv not rTOmd rn-rowbom or ena•oaoi wns a rt a�smm ta�F�eaTd` df r hob Lrxsw?wdh the Wound wx*Lcs fret mry coed bayonq a or bau�Oary Maa of the heratn dammed IAm ON=Lot tIl dw 74 AM son Mom or Re bw roes and eno..m on e e aYmtr of air-'y hers m r:ftm r ewes orrerwix�tnme L is uL 't?q.faatr.�r O-.natsFo deteRrane tN vaxrat mews only f4 any-Leger ownorshlp nOl Oedtrrnv,sd. M o+omaa T4)le.Tai^erLir LL nVt or area made r vvt i be beelye rT!re.�rd cn rTereto•.&we tlO rot Rr,py Q a�7i raeDO'.raeatRf her and v Eseaat7®FL Daylskan or lJrrra&ton fof vrhlJr IntarTTastoii was rxar lurntahey, 14�001h*V VT&&APUPnme Wtmf%exMor O ary d&Wjrl Ma'%m the herear_oeeorpetl v o>v>�a rat 181 Prj%mwonat txw Burveyor end Mapper M reepmaCla Perrff for�rmt-entl Zmvx3 vx-—OT»rr r t eat w+wrn rYTBtlfle:Fbtwwtlo Cry L$43t2,$late o<FltlrLli N KUP MUM A u- X11 t 7)TTYS evvef 6 not%n"w1b"ry MOn"I"+m"I'd tm raked 94191 Of a Fbnde Loensml Larly Swve K r w d Mapp, I.P. ua�er� BY: R� D URT1Z L$ <35 2 I tattabl' A'b tae eb*m nwnad eml arrd,or Pwswa thw the 9a�h of rc! 2oartrR-area.o-r M. RICAR.DO ORM LS 5629 Btavey o<t+e tleaOrltaod Property k tnm weo=xrV=to t ra s aenar . r+e t»st d ttTy+c,aw3pc w!I xeet.a naC'QTty frcaKfed end prayed reader coy drsraort om fhat e+eeta the MlnhT Tftchn_-w r'"t1Oa PROFFSSIOtiAL L�GfO SURVEYOR !,T weir b Tu¢rLT sue dards set In Chapter 6T of 7-A Flo to Admtftmhe code.Pursaaart to Secmn e,72.OZ7 weld&abft me k ►CAPPER,--STATE OF-FLORIDA. E?ATe- JOB Flo f 7�-,/ Naf t Dr�At+f�!SYt F 04 SOUTH � F � � INCORPORATED DRAFT � 1927 �0Ri0P' CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW & PRESERVATION BOARD REGULAR MEETING SUMMARY MINUTES Tuesday,December 6,2005 8:30 AM I. CALL TO ORDER Action: Mr. Trautman, Chairman, called the meeting to order at 8:34 A.M. II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Action: The Pledge of Allegiance was recited in unison. III. ROLL CALL Action: Mr. Trautman performed roll call. Board members present constituting a quorum: Mr. Trautman, Ms. Mark, Mr. Balli, Mr. Jude and Mr. Vitalini. Board members absent: Ms. Morales-Fernandez City staff present: Lourdes Cabrera-Hernandez(Planner), and Patricia E. Lauderman (Secretary). City staff absent: R. Don O'Donniley(Planning Director). IV. REQUESTS 1)EXTERIOR RENOVATION [ERPB-05-081] Applicant: Arthur S. Colsky Location: 6230 SW 70 Street Request: The applicant is requesting preliminary approval from the ERPB for the renovation of the site plan, located at the above address Applicant present: Arthur Colsky Action. At today's meeting the Board, staff and applicant discussed the request. Currently, the subject property is a single-family residential building, which is a legal nonconforming structure (dimensional substandard). The property may continue to be used as an RO "Residential-Office zoning district; which is permitted by right. The Board addressed the issue of providing adequate space for parking and requested a landscape plan from applicant. Motion: Mr. Trautman moved for preliminary approval with the following conditions: Board: 1. Applicant returns for final approval with a landscape plan done by a landscape architect with the actual size,position, and correct location of the ramp. 2. Applicant complies with six(6)parking spaces and removal of one oak tree(center tree) in front yard of property. Staff: 3. Applicant must comply with valet parking and conditions. 4. Applicant must comply with the tree removal conditions. Mr. Jude seconded the motion. Vote: Approved 5 Opposed 0 2) SIGNAGE INSTALLATION [ERPB-05-083] Applicant: Daniel Biendido Location: 7301 SW 57 Court Request: The applicant is requesting approval for the tenant signage on the west facade of the building, located at the above referenced location. Applicant present: Daniel Biendido Action: At today's meeting, the Board, staff and applicant discussed the request. The proposed sign will read "Marble Slab Creamery" and on the left side, a logo of an ice cream cone. The Board addressed the ice cream cone logo and noted that the ice cream cone was to remain and to be installed. The proposed sign will be located on the wall space designated for the tenants (west elevation) and facing SW 57 Court. The proposed exterior signage is located in the"SR" Specialty Retail district. Motion: Ms. Mark moved for approval as presented with the following conditions: 1. Submittal of the approval letter from the property owner. 2. That the wording"Marble Slab"and Creamery"all be centered in the center field. Mr. Trautman seconded the motion. Vote: Approved 5 Opposed 0 ERPB MINUTES 12-6-05 Page 2 of 4 4 SOUT$ � r • INCORPORATED • 1927 CQR1 December 7, 2005 Mr. Arthur Colsky 6280 SW 72 Street #611 South Miami, FL 33143 Re: Environmental Review & Preservation Board No. 05-081 EXTERIOR RENOVATION 6230 SW 70 Street South Miami, FL On the ERPB meeting of Tuesday, December 6, 2005 the motion was preliminary approval with the following conditions to be met by applicant: Board: 1. Applicant returns for final approval with a landscape plan done by a landscape architect with the actual size,position and correct location of the ramp. 2. Applicant complies with six (6) parking spaces and removal of one oak tree (center tree) in front yard of property. Staff: 3. Applicant must comply with valet parking and conditions. 4. Applicant must comply with the tree removal conditions. The next deadline date is Monday at noon, December 12, 2005, for the upcoming ERPB meeting of Tuesday, December 20, 2005 at 8:30 AM. If you have any further questions regarding this application, please contact Lourdes Cabrera-Hernandez at (305) 663- 6347 at the Planning Department. Note: Pursuant to Section 20-5.11(L) Expiration. Final approval by ERPB shall lapse after six (6) months if no permit is issued, except as may be extended by the ERPB for a period not to exceed six (6) months. Sincerely, Don O'Donniley, AICP / Planning Director Planning Department An appeal of an ERPB decision or recommendation may be filed at any time before a building permit is issued by filing same with the city clerk upon a form prescribed therefore. Appeals may be taken by the applicant, interested citizens, or the city administration [per § 20-6.2 (A) of the City's Land Development Code]. If you have any questions concerning this matter, please contact Ms. Lourdes Cabrera-Hernandez, of the Planning Department, between the hours of 8:00 AM and 5:00 PM, Monday through Friday at 305-663- 6347. 4 CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI Excellence, Integrity, Inclusion ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW& PRESERVATION BOARD To: Chair& Members, Environmental Date: December 6, 2005 Review& Preservation Board Tuesday 8:30 a.m. Via: Don O'Donniley ,Q(9� Planning Director From: Lourdes Cabrer ernandez . Re: ERPB-05-081 Planner Applicant: Arthur Colsky Location: 6230 SW 70th Street, South Miami Request: Exterior Renovation APPLICANT'S REQUEST: The applicant is requesting preliminary approval from the ERPB for the renovation of the site plan, located at the above address. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Attached sketch survey. Background & STAFF ANALYSIS: Currently the subject property is a single-family residential building, which is a legal nonconforming structure (dimensional substandard). The property may continue to be used as an RO "Residential-Office zoning district; which is permitted by right. However, it must meet the parking requirements and the dimensional non-conformity is not increased. For zoning history please refer to the tabbed page on the package. Applicant applied for a Variance to allow four off-street parking spaces where the required off-street parking is five spaces; and to allow required parking to be located in the front setback area which is prohibited in the RO zoning use district and was denied on January 4, 2005. At this time, the valet parking is contingent of the applicant obtaining an occupational license for the valet operation and for occupying the subject property and the applicant receive approval of the site plan from the ERPB. Refer to Valet parking, dated 9/13/05 and the proposed parking layout. Plan proposes six parking spaces and removal of one tree. Although, the tree removal permit has been approved applicant needs to address the conditions and submit a landscape plan. Refer to tree removal permit attached. At this time the applicant is requesting preliminary approval of the site renovation from the ERPB. RECOMMENDATION: Pdliminary Approval, with the following conditions: 1) Applicant must comply with the valet parking and conditions; and, 2) Applicant must comply with the tree removal conditions; and, 3) Applicant return to the ERPB with a proposed landscape plan; and 7039 SW 61St Avenue Exterior Renovation ERPB - December 6, 2005 Page 2 of 2 4) Any comments and/or concerns from the Board. Attachments: A) Application B) Survey C) Parking Layout D) Photos E) Valet Parking with conditions, dated 9/13/05 F) Application for Tree Removal w/conditions dated 7/15/05 G) City Commission Variance Package LCH K:\ERPB\ERPB Agendas\2005 AGENDAS\ERPB December 6, 2005\ERPB 05-081.doc CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI PLANNING &ZONING DEPARTMENT ® ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW AND PRESERVATION BOARD APPLICATION we?-or, 'C�6 STREET ADDRESS OF JOB: �� 70 5- _ SOUTH MIAMI,FL —m PROPERTY OWNER: �� C�-l.�/s TEL.NO. 3P S_ WO 1 . ADDRESS: l'1 (s-5 0 _ UAACI STREET CITY STATE ZIP WHAT IS THE PRESENT USE OF THE PROPERTY? SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE BUSINESS OFFICE RETAIL STORE OTHER: APARTMENT OR TOWNHOUSE MEDICAL OFFICE AUTO REPAIR PLEASE,BRIEFLY SUMMARIZE THE WORK TO BE PERFORMED: Adewux7k �11)6 _ -4� Mr4l&l� (&A WHAT WILL THE TOTAL COST BE TO COMPLETE THIS PROJECT? APPLICANT 4RIkul-S NAME: � TEL NO. .ADDRESS: // 5(!f C4 iy o a/ ,�Am/ fL 3 �q 3 STREET/�//�� CITY STATE ZIP FAX NUMBER: Y� / (1 CD � AS THE APPLICANT,PLEASE,INDICATE YOUR RELATIONSHIP TO THIS PROJECT OWNER OF THE PROPERTY TENANT/LESSEE CONTRACTOR OTHER: OWNER OF THE BUSINESS ARCHITECT ENGINEER PLEASE,INDICATE CONTACT PERSON(ERPB's decision will be mailed to the contact erson indicated below): PROPERTY OWNER VIL APPLICANT `" OTHER(provide name and address) -3 �, + -.r.Mn l ( f� j NOV 2 3 2005 PLEASE SIGN YOUR NAME ON THE LINE ABOVE DATE SKETCH OF SURVE Y SCALE 1" _ 12©.ool . ,/^ /�i'iA�,f� /!�1d.yT r3ii rx1,CY G/i✓ 6t b l 7 a • • dD E�s/c�A��S la,r5r9 � � r 1 �coy^, `� t �. �-N f. z) wau0 FEr�C � t3 r-iO -N r W:! ET�ST�L�2 T 3} A uaooj � k-8n JC r?�A Cr►':5 .Z,O� � 1J:b8'/n�PD y'ylc^ �dPHE32LY O A) 4 .T./� x�r/�.Sr o •Tr,� ,P/SNT-t�i�-u�t1 Y 70''`� A£ kJG TO'iE NATMAL R.0W g TF T PPaPE FITY F`AU.S W R.C?OD 2EN j C T7 MQ.- PANS-No.= 8lJF�iX= ��OF'F F tf�A ZED aqsED FLOM EtEy; �.�'69� a 2�G S 7f7-/995' "�' �J/'rT• LOCATION MAP OU.S.) N PROPERTY ADDRESS: . 6230 S_W. 70th Street, Miami, Florida 33143 . LEGAL DESCRIPTION: The West 54 .00 feet of the North 88 :OG feet on the East 137 .00 feet of the North 150 .00 feet o•f the West 2 of the Southeast 1, of the Southeast 4 of the Southwest 4 of Section 25 , Township 54 South, Range 40 East, lying and being in Dade County, Florida. FOR: MARTA MILLIAN GONZALEZ. CERTIFY TO: MARTA MILLIAN GONZALEZ - UNION TITLE SERVICES, INC_ STEWART TITLE GUARANTY COMPANY, INC. SURVEYOR'S NOTES: PREPM ED g^{: 1)Thi acavey was for the puriomm at a•Baa+7ery s4-/ony and is nrn vaended to dair.ain Cie r ainjory pnwcbar. d arty taowat oa=raoiaw g baw a7nn,coarb.mr v,4=m or other arm}. GUN I�R GROUI� INC. LB 4 50 7 4 7tw acmeracy PD%k"o fly ameazerr=m arxf cwct a bona on Cia et r vyr,rneem any e=eeds the N&r&ly rn Tecnr a=I Standarch LAND StiF�YEf�JQ-LAND PLAh1N IG a iukurr nta Rx a BubLetaan area(1 trot In 7.50.1 is"86&PGCned In Chenar 61 C17-0.Ftodda^dm'ntaeative Cade. 31 Ttaa SMvey,do=pat mnsC9 or deler-0 off. 8350 S.W. 22nd TERRACE 44 Leget.dmcdp*P ertyac t to xy dodha9ana,tbntsuOnw,rsawkSms rew vetldna a eaaemarm d rammd, 60��1$ WAfA1, FLORIDA 33165 6}$efmtttatlan d the AmSda d Tnk M4 tgerv6 is 1>B made b deletrlltrge rtlmrtted Ctewungentg a orH 7?ga�npery;wend= t Penn a gar dRbib71ecrd.rctpxfxmedbyLtoott' (305) 220—OD71 tsfT k?eQOri was mans h Ink ottt�tb Iocaea ear golds Tynund WCf{ec arteybc mu mores mom un ar eo�p the s�Zt pn2p" t-i cNa a rs¢ 6)7)ik eared ogee t>e�prapatW for the aresah a um tx the enC9ee Hamad hereon orgy and Ere aar>Resawn heraan do nut rasn W,•a a wdsnd•ta err.,ur almd Per9ae. rode Paso tau aot •U9 firC7C46 vaThin-LM3ey,Eatrerrg0rtp nag noted ore ydetmrG rFA a e=-.ra'"� r.Lh. mr�Ea each Pet &i savor ic11L'2ivttymya a porborgs eeted ni$wg Roedwerye not Pored m vratebpng or OrrobsLlvrganp cA CYllt use Tor}Fmc dulorm andbr botUtpa urdemean ne wmnd surface nee may I==baybnq ere botndary ilnbe o+the hwain dw=rb d I�*P7 ��tort I aw(we rot w own atsuane ut 1ZT M ftn F+Pae or Rebw low-1 end sn,> r m ea sloich o1 s.vvey nave no eam unties aetsrvdae auma M. twau e7T 't 3j.Fat>crov.neahb dewmtou Uy v"ue!rases W*M."t.Lava&*riwlsttp Hal oewininal do olamwl 14)4119 a"0 at ramrC%was rase*try"tlnfl beside It*re=rd WsC therstam we do nor trn;*or m=edt rewc neealC,ler arty EnssrroM Doclbaean or Ltnaeeorg tar v4*:h Infdrmeedn was Hat ftrraIs?vxt cot aGdeE TS 0=44d"aPRnP+teea atC'+ortwesprlor td yA'das1�1 work m ne nwaun oeecrPxd pw=w tor Man"and c►. t 1<Pat ts(pcdfalebrm tend Surveyor and Meppa to r0nonrable charow Rotardo Ordz LS 4512 Stara of Florida. 2me>j r sryrrr*son ee,FU�,4e, t 7)Thy.simY h not va9d.vtettxetlr daneture and Pte shad seat at a Florde Lcera�l Ltvg,9 Sln`rear emd Mapper. v. u mi rv, uadrvi BY: R 0 ORTIZ LS 4312 1 hereby cwVy,b ne ab"named&M and br Pareena thait the Stmtch 1X Survey of ee*warbed 'u �' Oi°a rOwr RICiIRDD ORTTZ LS 5629 rt rb.rtvwrmataror OFEMOFFAL LOO SURVEYOR prgberty h true ere ddr*act to as wNr tr ts� PR age best d my b•r wa!>aed.a receney eurveY?d ergd Ptawd under rty ditCaart olro nord nw to tie h&V7 n T-=hm=l r.t .vve w r,.mer k 4f APPE(t -STATE OF F LCRIDA_ Sur+darde wet in c hapw 61017-Q Florida Adminkorahe Code.purmimt to Se eb 472.027 FWIda abMmdL .DATE I JOB Not I SU=1 (NM- t I DAkm BY- n YYY CJ- t l L-� OT ol r� ,.S I I f: L--�-C4 al i. C TO: Maria V. Davis, City Manager FROM: Don O'Donniley, Planning Directory DATE: 9/13/05 RE: Valet Parking, 6230 SW 70th Street(Colsky ,dba Live Oak Valet, LLC.) Generally, valet permits are not required except where the applicant proposes to meet 50%of the required parking off site (requires four affirmative votes by the City Commission) and where the applicant is ramping the valet service on public property. Neither applies in this case. The City Attorney has reviewed the application and approved the indemnity aspects. Staff has discussed with counsel if valet parking can be used on site and the response is it can provided there is sufficient space to stack cars and maintain drive aisles After reviewing the application, staff can only support a conditional approval based on the following being provided prior to the permit becoming effective: 1. Applicant obtain a City of South Miami occupational license for the valet operation and for the use occupying the structure in question. 2. The applicant receive approval of a site plan from the Environmental Review and Preservation Board that demonstrates parking can be accommodated on site in compliance with setbacks, landscaping and spacing requirements. 10/30/2004 23:36 3056664591 PAGE 02 CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI �> Planning &Zoning Department City Hall, 6130 Sunset Drive, South Miami, Florida 33143 Phone: 305.663.6326 or 6347; Fax: 305.666.4591 APPLICATION FOR TREE REMOVAL Project Address: 02-30 54-,/ 7e S7 1t-- South Miami,Florida Property Owner: Phone: Address: 37,7—o 57e al .sz A(45- FL -331 3 Work To.Be Performed By(check one): Contractor Owner/Builder Contractor: Phone: Address: This applic 'on is or the.removal of(be specific): 7l y-ee O a� '-��'�S i h f �f a 0 V 11 Use of property(check one): Commercial V- sidenti Signature of Contractor/Qualifier 6ignatur-e of Pro 4M'-' % ALICE JEANCkAFr MY COMMISSION# 175300 Notary: Notary: ry 1,2007 Bonded Thru Notary Pudic Underwriters Two copies of a site plan and/or tree survey must be included. Depending on the type of tree(s),the fee for a tree removal permit is$40.00. This permit may be approved with conditions, limitations, and/or restrictions. O L Tree survey or site plan must be attacked(2 copies). PLANNING &ZONING DEPARTMENTAL APPROVAL YES NO Does this application involve a Natural Forest Community? Does this application involve protected and/or specimen trees? Has this application been incomplete for 120 days or more? Effective Expiration Approved? Date: I dT Date: If yes, by: ep Conditions, limitations, restrictions, if any: 4`16'44 61-ow a South Miami o i_ # � F l o r i d a AWAmerlea Clot 9-7 T ,i�g cr =< 2001 CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI PLANNING DEPARTMENT Tree Removal Permit Conditions September 14, 2005 Applicant: Skin Source Inc. Project address: 6230 SW 70 Street South Miami, F133143 APPLICANT'S REQUEST: The applicant has filed for a tree removal permit for the removal of 3 specimen Live Oaks. The permit is approved with the following conditions: C11 Applicant replaces canopy with 8 Live Oaks 2" DBH and 12' in height be planted or, Applicant replaces canopy with 4 Live Oaks 4" DBH and 16' in height be planted or, L it Applicant replaces canopy with a $2,000.00 contribution to the Tree Trust Fund and, 4. All newly-planted plant material shall be watered by temporary or permanent irrigation system until such time as they are established and, 5. All plants installed shall conform to, or exceed, the minimum standards for Florida Number One as provided in the most current edition of:Grades and Standards for Nursery Plants, Part I and II," prepared by the State of Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services and, 6. Failure to plant, preserve, or maintain each individual tree shall be considered a separate violation of this Code and, 7. The trees are not removed until the ERPB has issued its final approval for the site plan. I the legal owner/agent of the above referenced project agree with the conditions placed on this tree removal permit. Signature Date Sworn to me and subscribed to me this day of , 2005 Public Notary My commission expires: CADocuments and Settings\Lkruger\Desktop\Planning\Tree Conditions\tree8325sw58ave(2).doc 6130 SUNSET DRIVE SOUTH MIAMI,FL 33143 TEL: 305-663-6358 ♦ FAX:305-666-4591 -A- South Miami F I o r i d a �Fl AI �m �. A �, :�� AII•AaiaricaClry 2001 CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI MEMORANDUM To: Don O'Donniley,AICP Date: September 13, 2005 Planning Director From: Luis Kruger Re: Tree Removal Permit Permit Facilit 6230 SW 70 Street In regards to the above referenced Tree Removal Permit, through conversations with Michael Sprovero and input from D.ERM the canopy replacement for the 3 Live Oaks are as follows: South Miami, Fl Quantit Species *Specimen tree Replacement Canopy 3 Live Oak Yes (option 1) 8 Native trees with 12' minimum height and 2"DBH minimum. (option 2) 4 Native trees with 16' minimum height and 4"DBH minimum. (option 3) $2000.00 contribution to the Tree Trust Fund in accordance with standards of 20-4.5(3)(f) so u T� South Miami All-America City � INCORPORATED � 1927 2001 CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI To: Honorable Mayor,Vice Mayor& Date: January 4,2005 Commission Members ITEM No. 9 From: Maria Davis Re: Variance Request City Manager L S 6230 SW 70th Street Reconsideration RESOLUTION A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR & CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA, RELATING TO A REQUEST FOR APPROVAL OF THE FOLLOWING TWO PARKING VARIANCES IN ORDER TO PERMIT PROPERTY LOCATED AT 6230 SW 70TH STREET IN AN "RO" RESIDENTIAL OFFICE ZONING USE DISTRICT TO BE USED AS A COMMERCIAL OFFICE BUILDING: (1) VARIANCE FROM SECTION 20-4.4(B)(10) OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE TO ALLOW FOUR OFF-STREET PARKING SPACES WHERE THE REQUIRED OFF- STREET PARKING IS FIVE SPACES; (2) VARIANCE FROM SECTION 20-4.4(F) (3) OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE TO ALLOW REQUIRED PARKING TO BE LOCATED IN THE FRONT SETBACK AREA WHICH IS PROHIBITED IN THE RO ZONING USE DISTRICT: AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE RECONSIDERATION The City Commission at its November 16, 2004 meeting approved a motion to reconsider its vote on the above described variance application. The application was denied by the Commission on September 21, 2004. The Land Development Code provides the following regulations pertaining to the Commission's reconsideration of an item which was subject to a public hearing: Section 20-6.1(3)(e) "When any request requiring a public hearing before the planning board has been acted upon by the commission and denied or failed to pass, such proposed change, in the same or similar form shall not be reconsidered by the commission for a period of at least one (1) year following the date of such action (removed: when denied without prejudice) except in which case reconsideration is possible after six (6) months for the date established for the prior hearing at the request of the majority of the commission" (2) The Planning Director's interpretation of the above section is that a reconsideration of a denied application can be considered if the majority of the City Commission approves. However the actual reconsideration of the case must be scheduled no earlier than six months after the denial, which would be in April, 2005. This type of regulation requiring a one year or six month delay is very common in most zoning codes. Its purpose is primarily to protect neighborhoods from having to return meeting after meeting to oppose or support a particular application. Independent of this regulation the City Commission may have authority to reconsider its vote. REPORT ATTACHED The Administration is concerned about the precedent set if a reconsideration of a denied zoning application is permitted without the proper time span as specified in the Land Development Code. This could be used as a tactic to wear down opposition. If the Commission proceeds with reconsidering the item, the Administration's report from the September 21, 2004 meeting is attached. It is important to note that the Planning Board and the Planning Department both recommended approval of the variances with conditions. That recommendation still stands. Staff will support the variance if heard on April 5, 2004. Attachments Copy of 9-21-04 Report Copy of Public Notices MD/DOD/SAY E:\Comm Items\2005\1-4-05\Variance 6230 SW 70 Reconsideration Report.doc so U r� South Miami All-America City UV INCORPORATED • 1927 m P O R t 0 2001 CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI To: Honorable Mayor,Vice Mayor & Date: September 21, 2004 Commission Members ITEM No. From: Maria Davis �� Re: Variance Request . City Manager 6230 SW 70th Street RESOLUTION A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR& CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA, RELATING' TO A REQUEST FOR APPROVAL OF THE FOLLOWING TWO PARKING VARIANCES IN ORDER TO PERMIT PROPERTY LOCATED AT 6230 SW 70TH STREET IN AN "Roll RESIDENTIAL OFFICE ZONING USE DISTRICT TO BE USED AS A COMMERCIAL OFFICE BUILDING: (1) VARIANCE FROM SECTION 20-4.4(B)(10) OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE TO ALLOW FOUR OFF-STREET PARKING SPACES WHERE THE REQUIRED OFF- STREET PARKING IS FIVE SPACES; (2) VARIANCE FROM SECTION 20-4.4(F) (3) OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE°r0 ALLOW REQUIRED PARKING TO BE LOCATED IN THE FRONT SETBACK AREA WHICH IS PROHIBITED IN THE RO ZONING USE DISTRICT: AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE SUMMARY OF REQUEST The applicant, Dr. Arthur Colsky is requesting approval of two parking variances from the provisions of the Land Development Code to allow a single family residential building at 6230 SW 70th Street to be used for office use. The property is located in a small isolated "RO"Residential Office Zoning Use District. The City Commission at its August 3, 2004 meeting deferred action on the request. The staff was requested to provide a more detailed history of the property's Comprehensive Plan land use category assignment and zoning. That information is contained below in a new section entitled Zoning History. The City Commission at its August 17, 2004 granted a deferral of the item until the next Commission meeting. APPLICABLE REGULATIONS (SeeATTACHMENT) • Land Development Code Section 20-4.4(B) "Parking Requirements" • Land Development Code Section 20-4.4 (F)(3) "Location/Ownership of Spaces" • Land Development Code Section 20-5.9 "Variances Approvals" • Land Development Code Section 20-6.1(B)(3)(h) "Planning Board Duty" (2) ZONING HISTORY In 1982, as part of an overall updating to the Comprehensive Plan sponsored by the City, the future land use category covering this property was changed from Public/ Semi- Public to Office. In 1988, as part of the preparation of a new Comprehensive Plan, the City re-designated the subject property with the future land use category: Residential Office. The zoning classification.remained RM-24, High Density Residential. In order to use the existing single family residence as a real estate office and to make the property conform to the new Comprehensive Plan future land use category the owner, Mr. Robert Strickland, filed an application to change the zoning district from RM-24 to RO, Residential Office. The City Commission, at its July 8, 1988 meeting, granted approval of the request. The issues related to preserving trees and parking spaces were discussed prior to approving the zone change request. In December 1988, the applicant applied for a series of variances in order to permit use of the building as an office. Theses variances included waiving of parking requirements, variances needed due to the specific site plan submitted at that time, and variances needed to waive requirements in the Code which are no longer applicable. The variances were recommended for denial by the Planning Board. The City Commission at its January 3, 1989 meeting denied all of the variances requested. BACKGROUND (1) The subject property is a single family residential building, which is a legal non- conforming structure (dimensions are substandard). The property may continue to be used for a permitted use in the RO district as long as the parking requirements are met and the dimensional non-conformity is not increased. (2) The property is located on a narrow street with opposing one way traffic,just west of the subject site.North of the property (RS-3) are single family homes; east of the site (RO) is the parking lot of a large office building; west / south of the site (RM-24) is an apartment building and a tennis court. (3) The parking variances are being requested so that the number of off-street parking spaces provided would be sufficient to permit the structure to be used for general offices. The type of offices in an RO district is very limited and at this site would be further limited by the number of off-street spaces provided. Based upon the size of the structure (1162 sq. ft.) a total of five parking spaces would be required for most professional and business offices at a formula of one space for each 250 sq. ft of gross floor area. Offices such as medical, dental, or other health related uses would not be able to locate in this building due to a higher number of spaces required. (3) The applicant is proposing to save several of the large oak trees currently located in the front yard of the property. This action will limit the number of spaces on the site to four,resulting in the first variance request to waive one required parking space. The configuration of the site and the location of the structure will require parking spaces to be placed in the front yard including the front setback area. Parking in the required front setback is allowed in all but one zoning district. The RO zoning district does not permit required parking to be located in the front setback area, thereby resulting in the second variance request. STAFF OBSERVATIONS /RECOMMENDATION • The applicant's claim of hardship states that the size and shape of the property prohibits its use for commercial offices as permitted in an RO zoning district. • The applicant states that in order to use the property, the small size of the property's frontage requires the variance requested to provide a more effective parking layout. • The applicant also points out the requested variances will allow for the protection of two mature oak trees. • The applicant's site plan shows preservation of the large oak trees and the addition of landscaping materials which will improve the appearance of the property and reduce the visual impact of the front yard parking spaces. • The variances requested are necessary to relieve a particular condition relating to a specific property, and the strict application of the City's parking requirements would result in peculiar hardship upon the owner of the subject property. . • The proposed variance, if granted, would not confer on the applicant a special status; there are no other properties in the immediate vicinity which have this hardship. • The approval of the variances should recognize that certain type of office uses will not be permitted due to their increased parking requirement. It is recommended that the two requested variances for 6230 SW 70th Street be approved subject to the following condition: commercial offices including but not limited to medical, dental, health related uses and any other similar use which has the same required parking are prohibited from locating in the subject building. (4) PLANNING BOARD ACTION The Planning Board at its July 13, 2004 meeting adopted a motion by a vote of 4 aye 1 nay to approve the requested variances with the following conditions: (1) Commercial offices including but not limited to medical, dental, health related uses, day care centers, and any other similar use which has the same required parking are prohibited from locating in the subject building. (2) The parking surface shall be constructed of a pervious material. RECOMMENDATION It is recommended that the variances requested be approved with the conditions recommended by the Planning Board: (1) Commercial offices including but not limited to medical, dental, health related uses, day care centers, and any other similar use which has the same required parking are prohibited from locating in the subject building. (2) The parking surface shall be constructed of a pervious material. Attachments. Draft Resolution LDC Applicable Regulations Location Map Application Letter of Intent I Justification Survey, Proposed Site Plan Planning Board Minutes 7-13-04 Excerpt Copy of Public Notices MD/DO D/SAY.1Z�-J-, `e E:\Comm Items\2004\917-04\Variance-6230 SW 70 Str Report.doc 1 2 RESOLUTION NO. 3 4 A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR& CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI, 5 FLORIDA, RELATING TO A REQUEST FOR APPROVAL OF THE FOLLOWING TWO 6 PARKING VARIANCES IN ORDER TO PERMIT PROPERTY LOCATED AT 6230 SW 70TH 7 STREET IN A "RO" RESIDENTIAL OFFICE ZONING USE DISTRICT TO BE USED AS A 8 OFFICE BUILDING: (1) VARIANCE FROM SECTION 20-4.4(B)(10) OF THE LAND 9 DEVELOPMENT CODE TO ALLOW FOUR OFF-STREET PARKING SPACES WHERE THE 10 REQUIRED OFF-STREET PARKING IS FIVE SPACES; (2) VARIANCE FROM SECTION 20- 11 4.4(F) (3) OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE TO ALLOW REQUIRED PARKING TO BE 12 LOCATED IN THE FRONT SETBACK AREA WHICH IS PROHIBITED IN THE RO ZONING 13 USE DISTRICT: AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE 14 15 16 WHEREAS, Application No. PB-04-011 was submitted to the Planning Board by the 17 applicant Dr. Arthur Colsky, said application requesting approval for : (1) a variance from 18 Section 20-4.4(b)(10) of the Land Development Code to allow four off-street parking spaces 19 where the required off-street parking is five spaces and: (2) a variance from Section 20-4.4(f) (3) 20 of the Land Development Code to allow required parking to be located in the front setback area 21 which is prohibited in the RO zoning use district; and 22 23 WHEREAS, the approval of a variance requires a recommendation from the Planning 24 Board and the approval of the City Commission after a public hearing; and 25 26 WHEREAS, on July 13, 2004 the Planning Board, after public hearing, adopted a motion 27 by a vote of 4 ayes 1 nays to recommend approval of the variances with conditions; 28 29 NOW,THEREFORE,BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF 30 THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI,FLORIDA: 31 32 33 Section 1: That the subject application submitted to the Planning Board by the applicant 34 Dr. Arthur Colsky requesting approval for : (1) a variance from Section 20-4.4(b)(10) of the Land 35 Development Code to allow four off-street parking spaces where the required off-street parking is 36 five spaces and: (2) a variance from Section 20-4.4(f) (3) of the Land Development Code to 37 allow required parking to be located in the front setback area which is prohibited in the RO 38 zoning use district is hereby approved with the following conditions: 39 40 (1) Offices including but not limited to medical, dental, health related uses, day care centers, and 41 any other similar use which has the same required parking are prohibited from locating in the 42 subject building. 43 44 (2) The parking surface shall be constructed of a pervious material 45 46 47 1 (2) 2 3 4 Section 2. That resolution shall be effective immediately after the adoption hereof. 5 6 7 PASSED AND ADOPTED this , day of ,2005 8 9 10 11 ATTEST: APPROVED: 12 13 14 CITY CLERK MAYOR 15 16 Commission Vote: 17 READ AND APPROVED AS TO FORM: Mayor Russell: 18 Vice Mayor Palmer: 19 Commissioner Wiscombe: 20 Commissioner Birts-Cooper: . 21 Commissioner Sherar: 22 CITY ATTORNEY 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 EAComm Items\2005\1-4-05\623 0 SW 70 Variance Resol.doc ATTACHMENT LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE APPLICABLE REGULATIONS • Land Development Code Section 20-4.4 (B)Parking Requirements Space Requirements. The minimum number of off-street parking spaces required for each permitted or special use shall be as set forth below and referenced in Section 20-3.31). Where fractional spaces result, the number of spaces required shall be the next highest whole number. (1) Two (2) spaces per dwelling unit. (2) Two (2) spaces per dwelling unit, provided that at least one(1) space per unit shall be enclosed. (3) One and one-half(1.5) spaces per efficiency or studio unit and two (2) spaces per unit with one or more bedrooms,plus an additional visitor space for every ten(10)units. (4) One(1) space per guest room,plus two (2) spaces for the reception office. (5) One and three-quarters (1.75) spaces per bed. (6) One(1) space per three(3) seating spaces in the main assembly room. (7) One (1) space per one hundred(100) square feet of gross floor area. (g) One (1) space per one hundred fifty (150) square feet of gross floor area. (9) One (1) space per two hundred(200) square feet of gross floor area. (10) One (1) space per two hundred fifty (250) square feet of gross floor area. (11) One(1) space per three hundred (300) square feet of gross floor area_ (12) One (1) space per four hundred(400) square feet of gross floor area. (13) One(1) space per five hundred(500) square feet of gross floor area. (14) One (1) space per one thousand(1,000) square feet of gross floor area. (15) One (1) space per four(4) seats or seating places. (16) . Five(5) spaces per alley or five hundred(500) square feet of rink area. • Land Development Code Section 20-4.4 (F)(3)Location/Ownership of Spaces (F) Location and Ownership of Spaces. (3) Parking shall be permitted in yard setback areas except in required front yard setbacks in the RO district. (4) Parking of commercial vehicles of one (1)ton or greater capacity shall not [be] permitted in all RS,RT or RM districts. (5) Parking structures shall not be located within required yard setback areas. (6) No off-street parking space shall be located within ten(10) feet of any street curb or so as to permit any portion of a parked vehicle to extend across a property line. • Land Development Code Section 20-5.9 Variances Approvals (A) Expiration of Variance Approvals. A variance approved pursuant to Section 20-5.5 shall lapse after six (6) month if no substantial construction or change of use has taken place in accordance with the request for such variance and if the city commission has not specified a longer approval period for good cause shown. (B) Extension of Variance Approvals. Four (4) affirmative votes of the city commission may grant an extension to a previously approved variance if a proper and timely request is made by the applicant prior to the expiration of the six (6) month period. (C) Hardship Statement. All applications for a variance shall include a letter of intent indicating the specific nature of the hardship upon which the request is based. (D) Property Survey Required. All applications for a variance shall include a current property survey prepared by a registered surveyor. (E) Neighborhood Concurrence. All applications for a variance shall be accompanied by a map which reflects all properties and the names of all property owners within a five hundred (500) foot radius of the subject property. The applicant shall obtain and (F) submit the signatures of at least twenty (20) percent of such property owners, indicating their awareness of the proposed variance request. (F) Proposed Site Plan Required. A site plan shall be required showing all proposed buildings and setbacks and any other features relating to the variance request. (G) Permitted Variance Requests. Applications for variances shall be restricted to only the following: (1) Yard setbacks (2) Lot size (3) Lot coverage (4) Building height (5) Fences and walls (6) Impervious coverage (7) off-street parking (g) open space (9) Signs (10) Landscaping • Land Development Code Section M-6 1 B) Planninz Board Duties (B) Planning Board. (3) Powers and Duties. (h) The board shall review and make recommendations on all applications for variances from the requirements of this Code for yard setbacks, lot size, lot coverage, building height, fences and walls, impervious coverage, off-street parking, open space, signs and landscaping. Recommendations for a variance shall be made only when necessary to relieve particular hardships or extraordinary conditions relating to a specific property, and when the strict application of a particular regulation would result in peculiar and exceptional hardship upon the owner of such property as distinzuished from reasons of convenience profit or caprice. City of South Miami PB-04-011 Special Use Approval 6230 SW 70th Street 6 6611 6610 6611 6610 6611 6610 BB21 0 6616 6621 6621 6620 U 6631 0 0 6620 6621 6620 6632 Q 6631 6630 6640 6631 6630 0 6701 6� 6631 0 = 6641 0 6700 670D 6701 6700 6701 6700 CAD 6711 D N co 6701 6710 6711 6710 6721 6718 `D 6711 6710 6711 ao � 6720 6721 6720 6721 6720 U) 0 N 6721 6731 0 w 6731 6730 6731 6730 6731 6730 SW 68TH ST 0 0 630D 6801 6800 68DI 6800 6802 �g�� 6370 6350 - a 6812 M 1 6840 6815 6810 6825 6820_ 5950 Co � 0 6303 6825 6820 CD 6841 N y° g�� ro'� ro `° 6 0 6901 O o v o 0 0 0 6910 rn ,� ° 6917 `t 0 v o 0 0 N N 6912 62,40 6230 o in cD m 6930 6925 0 0 0 6929 rn 6931 r CD 0 rn 0 1 0. r �t N o 0 0 6950 1 0,° Co N 6941 0 co co Co 0 y m cD 694 0 6941 cD co 94 6970 70TH ST 0 7000 r� 0 7p0g � 7020 7001 7000 7001 N 000 o 7040 7011 7020 7021 0 7010 7015 10 ~ . (j 7021 7101' F- 10 7030 7641 7030 7105 °' 7051 (n 7090 ° o 7031 7040 0 7040 71°7 SUBJECT � > 7171 7110 7101 7110 7111 7110 PROPERTY ° F- 7115 7114 7111 Q 6161 0 7111 7120 M sLP 712� 6201 N 6�0 ~ 6101 0 c� 0 ED 6341 Lnn m U) ED CD CD SW 72ND ST 0 6180 tD cD C, �° O 633 32 6310 Co co"�� 7223 a J Co' D- N 7231 ° 7231 tD N N _M 7230 7243 7240 0 CId s 7251 N 7311 7240 7301 7246 N cD 7311 7340 7310 7313 7320 7300 7321 7320 7321 7331 7330 7333 7330 w �� ch w 7341 LD 7340 6331 7340 ° 0 300 640 90D 1,200 1,500 Feet ® City of South Miami Planning & Zoning Department City Hall,6130 Sunset Drive,South Miami, Florida 33143 Telephone: (305)663-6326; Fax:(305)666-4591 Application For Public Hearing Before Planning Board & City Commission Address of Subject Property: (92� S0 -)t) S+ Lot(s) _ Block Subdivision PB -- Meets & Bounds: j Applicant: Iq OLU a o A — Phone: f /� organization: SIQV Representative: Phone: 3f /��-t Address: i. Property Owner /j(f A V/L S _ (� r, S� Signature: !'1 t rl� Phone:- Mailing Address: !•� �7� 3(� 40 Phone30 S V O �y ArchitectlEngineer: / .r {� 1 �ri AS THE APPLICANT, PLEASE INDICATE YOUR RELATIONSHIP TO THIS PROJECT: IV—Owner _Owner's Representative •—Contractlo purchase —Option to purchase —Tenant/Lessee APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE FOR THE FOLLOWING: PLEASE SUBMITTED M ALL RHAL APPLY: PLEASE CHECK THE APPROPRIATE ITEM: Variance _Letter of intent Text Amendment to LDC — Special Use $�Justifications for change —Zoning Map Amendment — p tatement of hardship _PUD Approval —Special Exception �Plroof P PUD Major Change —Other of ownership or letter from owner _Power of attorney Briefly explain application and cite specific Code sections: _Contract to purchase t/Current survey(1 original sealed and 0 A•�/ _•r. , �d ' C(, n �� i�� signed/1 reduced copy @ 11"x 17") (�W _ i Vl,�' { /� 5 copies of Site Plan and Floor Plans 1 A* Y� reduced copy @ 11"x 17" —20%Property owner signatures1/ Z1 Amended Date: Mailing labels (3 sets)and map Section:2U Subsection: Page#: —Required Feels) The undersigned has read this c .. pleted a plication and represents that the information and all submitted materials are true and ;Corre the st of the a lica.tJs kfroW ge and belief. •�7 cX 2Z � App kcant's Signature and title Date Upon receipt, application and all submitted materials will be reviewed for corn liance with the Land Development Code and other applicable regulations. Applications found not in compliance will be rejected andpreturned to the applicant. OFFICE USE ONLY: A-7-4-3-O Date of Commission Date Filed A��`f Date of PB Hearing Petition Required �- Petition Accepted t.-/ Method of Payment 8/2/00 Skin Source Inc. 8220 SW 52 Ave S. Miami, FL 33143 305-740-6181 Application for Zoning Variance Date: May 23, 2004 Location: 6230 S.W. 70th Street, South Miami, Florida 33143 Legal Description: 25 54 40 .10 AC W54FT OF N88FT OF E137FT OF N150FT OF W1/2 OF SE '/4 OF SE '/4 OF SW '/,LOT SIZE 4750 SQUARE FEET OR 10160-2164 0600 1 Variance Requests for the above referenced property: 1. to allow for parking in the front set back zone. 2. to allow for-one less parking space than currently designated Hardships: Whereas: 1. The inherent lay of the land and existing improvements directly interfere with available space for off street parking. a. The configuration of the footprint of the preexisting structure does not accommodate sufficient space for parking in the rear or on either side of the improvement. b. The presence of old growth oak trees centrally located within the perimeter of the property directly interferes with available grounds available for parking space construction. c. The size and shape of the land presents a peculiar hardship by interfering with the design necessary to accommodate parking space requirements. d. The resultant lack of available off street parking directly interferes with the allowed use of the property in its current R-O zoning classification as a commercial office. Justification: Whereas the subject property: 1. contains a preexisting structure; 2. is subject to zoning requirements that do not allow for parking within the front set back; 3. occupies a unique configuration that presents a peculiar hardship; 4. will necessitate demolition of the existing structure in order to achieve sufficient set back for parking space design; 5. contains old growth oak trees which occupy coordinates critical for parking space design And whereas: 1. preservation of the existing structure would maintain the residential character of the property; 2. use of the front set back for off street parking is in keeping with similar use of the front set back zones of the neighboring residential properties; 3. preservation of the existing old growth oak trees would be accomplished 4. the requested modification in the number of parking spaces only represents a fractional reduction in the currently designated five spaces per 250 f 2 to the fractional difference of one space for every 279 ft2. Granting of the above requests for variances will cure the existing hardships and allow for use of the property in its current R-O zoning classification as a commercial office. For these considerations, 1, any claim to use the property for a more intensive commercial use, such as a medical office, will be relinquished; 2. a comprehensive landscaping plan presented herewith will provide enhancement of the current vegetation and natural beauty of the property; 3. such landscaping would further camouflage the proposed parking spaces in the front set back. Thank you for your co idera ' n of the above requests for variance. Arthur S. Colsky EX• L7VE;"OAKS"------.. _ ._._. � I' ' � 6� ✓J �FEJJCF- C ' S-STL s - . ' S r 135 I j y �n2rj I' Irk+_ 14-TF 5 �; Ma 2400 _ is�'• � I i [ l/,• z _ I s-ci M t Cam. E 2r„ 5 S,W. TO STREET, lf5- PAVEMENT LANDSCAk PLAN•i WERNER DIETEL AND ASSOCIATES 6230 SW 70 STREET LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS/PLAf'JNERS AS.LA e VpyT OrFlW➢OR H¢v4 Fawnq R�+iN Tafp TEL iOFe��-B�py I n6l'IBa�c 1- PLANT LIST, LEGEND SYMBOL QUANT.NAME NATIVE Y/N. SIZE BS 2 BURSERN SIMAROUBRA Y 7.2'X 6',6'C.TR. Gumbo Limbo CTM 5 CORDYLSNE TERMINAUS Me.ANDRE N 3'+TRANSPLANT . Red TI Plant I J DE 40 DURANTA ERECTA Y 2'h'X 2'BUSHY Golden bew Drop DM 3 DRACAENA MARGINATA N 3,3 HEADS+ Red Edge Dracaena-- MP 35 MURRAYA PANICULATA N 2'X 1'A,BUSHY Cliaicas,Orange Jasmine PSC 66 PDLYPODIUM SCOL.OPENDR•IA Y 6'POTS,FULL Wart Fern Qve 2 QUERCUS VIl2GINIANA Y. 24'CAMP.EXIST Live Oak QV* 1 QUE MS VIRGINIANA Y . 'a"CALIF.MOVE Live Oak SP 2 SABAL PALMETTO Y 12'&18'C.TR_ Florida Cabbage Palm. ST1 8 SANSEVIERIA TRIFASCIATA LAURENT.N 1 lk'-2,BUSHY Snake Plant 7F 14 TRIPSACLiM.FLORIDANUM. Y 1 w,BUSHY Gama Grass Stid-and Mulch as indicated ! FASTEN SATIEHS 111TH 2—3/4" 1 RI CARBON STEEL RAMOS.1 HO HAILS ALTO PALM. BIGHT OF BATI'ELIS. ACCOROIHC To R -UT OF 6AEE TO 614E PROPL'3 L*EHAGS. 1,AYERS OF BURLAP •��' f' •��t.�j� I�frte' HIH. b- 2x 4xt 16" • � �i' J 1': .r11(I}I�rLr � BA�dTf]t5 • � f t j !'�rl 'l•I-;,►111','1 �� _ .�• STEEL BAJWS. TOE NAIL BRACT: { TO BATTEII - J i' �1•I j J. 3- 2x'4 BRACES L1•120% HELI LIMBER HEAVY PAW OVER 25'"4 BRACES 0 g0' 3 MULCH IiLH. 4" BERM ' 2x 4 BRACE STOP.• 18" L.okc • - .. GRAVE fir+ • IY=_ It - •ir. _� I/� _� 1� PliamiNC SOIL. I 8':.• HIM. EXCAVATION ' .STAKING FOR PALMS AND TREE"S-, MI11. CLEAW AT TIME OF TLAHTIHG 4" BERM 2" MULCH 6'Y B""CONC. MDHIHG RRUB CROUNDWVER , STRIP c !fl Y DD _ .` :•... `, _ADJACENT PAVED AREA PLANTING SOIL AS SPECIFIED SHRUB AND GROUNDCOVER PLANTING LANDSCAPE PLAN i WERIVER DIETEL" AND ASSOCIATES m,.I 6230 SW 70 STREET LANDSCAPE ARCWIT6CTS/PLANNERS AS-LA. I� . 'vr"cnec•mt n evq um, .w T•..� .- • rneo"a ( : 9. 15 7 r CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI PLANNING BOARD Regular Meeting Action Summary Minutes Tuesday, July 13, 2004 City Commission Chambers 7:30 P.M. EXCERPT I. Call to Order and the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag Action: The meeting was called to order at 7:47 P.M. Action: The Pledge of Allegiance was recited in unison. II. Roll Call. Action: Mr. Morton, Chairperson,requested a roll call. Board members present constituting a quorum: Mr. Morton, Ms. Yates, Ms. Gibson, Mr. Comendeiro, Mr. Liddy,and Mr. Illas. Board members absent: Mr. Mann. City staff present: Don O'Donniley (Planning Director), Sanford A. Youkilis ( Planning Consultant), Gremaf Reyes (Video Support), and Patricia E. Lauderman (Planning Board Secretary). PB-04-011 Applicant: Dr. Arthur Colsky Location: 6230 SW 70t' Street Request: A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR & CITY COMM SSION OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI,FLORIDA,RELATING TO A REQUEST FOR APPROVAL OF THE FOLLOWING TWO PARKING VARIANCES IN ORDER TO PERMIT PROPERTY LOCATED AT 6230 SW 70TH STREET IN AN "RO" RESIDENTIAL OFFICE ZONING USE DISTRICT TO BE USED AS A COMMERCIAL OFFICE BUILDING: (1) VARIANCE FROM SECTION 20-4.4(B)(10) OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE TO ALLOW FOUR OFF-STREET PARKING SPACES WHERE THE REQUIRED OFF- STREET PARKING IS FIVE SPACES; (2) VARIANCE FROM SECTION 20-4.4(F) (3) OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE TO ALLOW REQUIRED PARKING TO BE SKETCH OF SURVEY SCALE T = �2o,Oo' TO IN i� - _ - - a.��- .' •:,ac`s". _ _.�•.jGv_. I d , aA'[E-L-rA4 n/-ran r t CQ ENC2QAG.I.1t�$ tb,�0 � � r J ro -rHE 6g5T&�R LY • 1�. -• ��PB�-f`T LICE_ • G t�AV�-�,,� r - -0 _ - 2124 .0 P vc--- - • � � FJCI C�01�c��5 e 1541 :z.os,- 1,33 S iirTo TW is asr�ey-r � � w 3� A• coo r, •p .a �c.►�A«'=5 '16W7-e-. .721-- AO// /2 c F 7Ng,g�6NT--QiG Y /z�,4 S w 70 ✓oT ,0Ep 1-A7—Fa 0^/ 7-,If--F :5tM,767 T. PROfEi-rY' A *JG TO THE NAT1)NAL FLOOD IM PF OGF.M. THE Bf JECT PP4PE'FLTY PAUZW FLOOD ZQhB COUWMfY N - PQ@8_Nov C- Of'`F€h FffA.Zf MkBR5 FLOOD i�w•: /. 69� a 2 G �" 717-/g9s" �/rA LOCATION CHAP au.s.) CA4 ..T4 �4 f s r 11 541 40 q v PROPERTY ADDRESS: . 6230 S.W. 70th Street, Miami, Florida 33143 . LEGAL DESCRIPTION: The West 54 .00 feet of the North 88 : 00 feet on the East 137 .00 feet of the North -150 . 00 feet of the West '-� of the Southeast 1, of the Southeast 4 of the Southwest 4 of Section 25, Township 54 South, Range 40 East, lying and being in Dade County, Florida. FOR: MARTA MILLIAN GONZALEZ. CERTIFY TO: MARTA MILLIAN GONZALEZ .- UNION TITLE SERVICES, INC. STEWART TITLE GUARANTY COMPANY, INC. SURVEYOR'S NOTES: PRE PAFr=D BY: u T,>f every wad the r of a•6a v+aer, su vcy�,,aria a not ti endetl b the�rnx�rr w+ad (D GUNMR GROUP, INC. LB 4507 oI any tcaw d.sgum raosormi or lace)47ency.basrd.carnry k—w other erllk. a9 The accuracy of tasWc by nneawrerneme and cate�Jahor»on die aunty,meem and exceeds Ne Ant*m=Tec hracal Standards LAND SUR'VEYM-LAND PLAWNG nequtrarrefft RX a BtAxxoen aria(1 loot in 7.500 feet)as aper311ed In l rom r 61017-6.FbAds Wrntdmatve Cade. 3)7Fde Sor,-tdoee rcA copra or nmwndne&&neretip. 9350 S.W. 22nd TERRACE a)Legetdescepoon mbJad to dry dadkstorta.ttrfitaone.reshttom rassrvsb ns or eeeerrwm of raco; AUAW. FLORIDA 33165 Q Emernk=6an of the Ab&V=Of Tore wR have ID be mode 10 determhE reoordad Inovurnen6 d any aileopnp tra p ro ov'rr..seam � Or-1 (305) Z20-DD7 3 offtblb lards n.Y pedormad by tae omaa. no mNie~was mods br It ds omme to, wv undezvound mom mad em x4ures w@un at eaumv he 1-44"-t propery t r�r r Dote m rrt gj Tik aer:sy has pasq ptapuod tar the areaage use of to exetbae ntvnad hereon dray end the ire FwJSan m not e.4arfd'b err,tra Dmad pertim raja N�tlrti Men—ujht Ult tat.erner>!a na noted as%ciahonS FA d18�y rw mrp[tf o�c rr snem 10)tai yB or pol b�'o trerea7 woe,taoadwrya nct noted m Meta or er CrEsch arm Vs nnt.sm 1s1Fo'atdano m arrdkrr Iooti n taderneeth tre ground wartace het may crass beyond 8w bounoary Mt of ti a hash dee.7med M m we papa( am rot Mown evnsoo tw T�'f7I Caft is+pea a Rebor braC and ttown on are eF¢!�of:iwey tm s no cape unkes pd'tetvAee 9tateC a Moll ta¢ 1�-f4trr ownasffb defamers ny vetoed rnasra o'tIy fd artyk Levey ownerafttp rot Oet�n+lhttiQ. w. us Fmm f 4)!da ate s h d remros wee made by"thrn pastas thf re Ord plsC ttsetora wa do not h+PN ar a®pt rerQO mlbehr tQ ary ccw_ a Easwra,M Drase aeon or Lmlatlon for w4 h Irdwrnesm was ru mod. v. coatEa tat t5)lbatitet trn appop�a:rtodse Xw to dry design wen on the nervan•aeeetcea parcel for WLS-0 W36 7.dnht<)axcrrnaton r ae rrma.»r nxj 1 W prdlganiony t wo Bwmyor and Mapper to rerperaVe dmrya:fiotsrdo Ora L3 4412 State d Fbntfe_ ' � 0 Urn T 7)7fes eorve'r Y rzat vasd wthouttM +m and tie defend eel d e Fbrde Lrer+H>;Y t.erb 6ravercn and Mapper- v. troy ral BY: R DD Or�TIZ I.S 6312 r.cr ►oeamm mvm war Oil• RICARDO ORTIZ LS 5629 ri war w wroxsao. I hereby ebrtty b t+e above nerved arts andiw persons t,d ft smch d 9tmey d the deaa'Ded properly b tare end enroa to .c Para s ra mem PRD>'ESSIONAL LAND SURVEYOR M poet of my ie'l C and bead.as reearYly s�yed aria planed unow rry ffiachon;eCO hat ma6N the WAIm al7edtrozal '.f .vrr w i� k IlAPpER, •STATE OF FLORIDI. Swciarda set to Chapter 5131 T-a.Fiorlda Ad nt#tts4.e Code.puraLn"to 6ecadn 472.027 tlonde S>»c n DATE- JOB Hal BEd'{N,: r MAVldtl BY. ON3 r 29-za©v Planning Board Meeting July 13, 2004 LOCATED IN THE FRONT SETBACK AREA WHICH IS PROHIBITED IN THE RO ZONING USE DISTRICT: AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Note: At this time,Mr. Illas informed the Board with regards to Item PB-04-01 1, he would recluse himself from voting. He explained that as a realtor he had assisted in the closing for the purchase of the property. Mr. O'Donniley concurred that it was appropriate for him to recluse himself. Action: Mr. Morton read the item into the record. Mr. O'Donniley presented the staff report. He explained that the applicant is requesting approval of a two parking variances from the provisions of the Land Development Code to allow a single family residential building at 6230 SW 70t' Street to be used for office use. The property is located in an isolated"RO"Residential Office Zoning Use District. Additionally, Mr. O'Donniley stated the parking-variances are being requested so that the number of off-street parking spaces provided would be sufficient to permit the structure to be used for commerical offices. The type of offices in an RO district is very limited and at this site would be further limited by the number of off-street spaces provided. Based upon the size of the structure (1162 sq. ft.) a total of five parking spaces would be required for mist professional and business offices at a formula one space for each 250 sq. ft. of gross floor area. Offices such as medical, dental, or other health related uses would not be able to locate in this building due to a higher number of spaces required. He also noted that the applicant is proposing to save several of the large oak trees currently located in the front yard of the property. This action will limit the number of spaces on the site to four, resulting in the first variance request to waive one required parking space. The configuration of the site and the location of the structure will require parking spaces to be placed in the front yard including the front setback area, which is allowed in all but one zoning district The RO zoning district does not permit required parking to be located in the front setback area, thereby resulting in the second variance request. Planning staff recommended that the two requested variances for 6230 SW 70th Street be approved subject to the following condition: commerical offices including but not limited to medical, dental, health related uses and any other similar use which has the same required parking are prohibited from locating in the subject building. At this point, Mr.Morton opened the public hearing. Applicant: Arthur Colsky (Owner) The Board, staff, and applicant discussed the request. The applicant stated that the property will not be used for medical purposes, instead it will be used as an office. He plans on improving the appearance of the property with landscaping materials and will save the two large oak trees, which are shown on the site plan. Furthermore, Mr. Colsky stated that he Planning Board Meeting July 13, 2004 had no objection to adding turf blocks to the property. Mr. O'Donniley commented he had an e-mail which he needed to enter into the record. This email was written by Beth Schwartz, who is a neighbor located two houses away from the 6230 SW 70th Street. She indicated in her email that any consideration of the variance request should be based upon requiring the implementation of the Parking Study for the street.. She further explained in her e-mail that neighbors would like to request a small raised and landscaped culdosac which could be placed adjacent to the newly relocated do not enter signs. This culdosac would allow for commerical parking on the east side in a semi circular fashion as to provide for maximum parking spaces, and a moderately landscaped greenspace area on the west side for the many residents who walk. Speakers: NAME ADDRESS Dean Whitman 6259 SW 70' Street Opposed application Mr. Whitman strongly opposed the application. He provided the Board with an article from the Miami Herald. Furthermore,.he.voiced his opinion_about.traffic problems in the area and his disagreement with the requested variance. After hearing a summary of Ms. Schwartz's email Ms. Yates recommended that in the future the Parking Study be further review by Planning Staff. In addition, Board member Ms. Gibson informed the Board that the property was formally used as a day care center classroom. Mr. O'Donniley stated perhaps that it was for that reason that the "RO" zoning was designated. Board member, Mr. Comendeiro was concerned of the possibility of a day care being opened on that property. Mr. O'Donniley asked the applicant, Dr. Colsky if he had any objections to specifically eliminating day care as a potential use. Dr. Colsky had no objection. Therefore, the following amended motion was passed. Motion: Ms. Gibson moved and Ms. Yates seconded a motion to approve the requested variances with the following conditions: (1) Commercial offices including but not limited to medical, dental, health related uses, day care centers, and any other similar use which has the same required parking are prohibited from locating in the subject building. (2) The parking surface shall be constructed of a pervious material. The motion was approved by the following vote: Vote: Ayes 4 Nays 1 (Mr. Liddy) Recluse 1 (non-voting) (Mr. Illas) E:\Comm Items\200AS-3-04Txcerpt PB Mins 6230.doc MIAMI DAILY BUSINESS REVIEW Published Daily except Saturday,Sunday and Legal Holidays t�w Miami,Miami-Dade County,Florida j ► x c ,yj? r� '� a �t 717yv h Erkw rr .-. a tFx. ery np�.t.t^.J+ .,� xn�3 d t?a Sys Y!' � c � sl a STATE OF FLORIDA +s C� OF SOUTHMIAMN��2�= � COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADS: S' x NOTICE OF PUBLIC WARM G'; Before the undersigned authority personally appeared Ni n n�> + -rat 'St.. ,fr+ pti' , ",�e ' . OCTELMA V.FERBEYRE,who on oath says that he or she is the SUPERVISOR,Legal Notices of the Miami Daily Business NOTICEIS FIEREBaf i�iertitaaYthe C� Commisstota of the CI sof South Review f/k/a Miami Review,a daily(except Saturday,Sunday Miam! F1or�daw{II conductPubllc�FTeanngs atats regulaG City Commisslor and Legal Holidays)newspaper,published at Miami in Miami-Dade meettg scedule fokTuesday Dececnber2l,2004 beginning at 7 30 p County, Florida;that the attached copy of advertisement, m`yn the City C�mmi'ssion Chambers 610 Sunsetnve„to considerttie. 1 t a xzs ya being a Legal Advertisement of Notice in the matter of foRnwlrag atetts x S`ret3cr-Qo.w n,ddu�"F iea k d lnLa'�`"Or�ad.5 l,nvae4s rn1 cs'eM�'`L*'•�,"• ir.tS ,aXyxr'� v` �Jy4 en.``'�'r t„n 4f a} �! CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI Yp(�taRDIN%1NCEOF71E>MAYtOR AND CFTY COMMISSION OF.; PUBLIC HEARING 12/21/2004 T}fE CITY�60F�SOL TIi M(AMI FLOE3IDARELATING740 THEPER x 17'FEE SCIiEDULE�wAMENDING. , RDI.N.:M g1490-1, . ASI in the XXXX Court, AMENDED BY RDINANGES,,f6-92 i501,��i7 M"1154 i0-95-i was published in said newspaper in the issues of x'1583,i6 99-x692,28-00 ir730;'32 01$`1763 14=p2 1782AND21 Q3-: �8D5IAI ORDER A Tfl;ADJUST 'S-4E ARPLICAiIOA1 FEES; 12/10/2004 tk�PROVdD'1NG FOR}SEVERABILITY`ORDINANCES IN CONFLICT A 1itANDAfiIEfFECTIVEDATf�sty� + }rr �^ � �" "w e 5 j Vt,v '1,"' #..s nl'y ag ,� g .w?` 1t ry'^?F�S IN y Affiant further says that the said Miami Daily Business Resolution N'W' t r� "1 i A ESOLUTCOUF'THEtIIIAYOR'&CITYCOM ISSION OFTHEc IT Review"is a newspaper published at Miami in said Miami-Dade "CITX O SOUTH MI IMI;FLORID/C,`RELi471NGTQ '�tEti" County, Florida and that the said newspaper has v F0RtAPPROVAI:OFxTHE FOLLOWING-%.,, ARKING;VARI heretofore been continuously published in said Miami-Dade County, �x'pNCES IN QRDErt O�PERtNITAFF3OPERN;LOCATED A7 6230 Florida,each day(except Saturday,Sunday and Legal Holidays) r Syy+7ATH'STRIE V.IIN�AN RO RESIDENTIAL OIp ICE ZONING and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post Y USE;DISTRicri�TOk;BE USED;A$ h R, "Z OFFICEf office in off olne i ear next Ild the first ubl ationoof the W LAND�,DEVELO IJIENT CODE TO ALCDW FO R .......FS STREE P Y preceding P attached copy of advertisement;and affiant further says that he or kPARKING SnSPACES.WNERE THE'fiEQUIREDz DFF STREE she has neither paid not promised any person,firm or corporation APARKING'IS FIVE SPACES;(2)VARIANCE.,' SECTION 20 any discount,rebate,commission or refund for the purpose ~>A�ND DEYELOPMENCCQDErTO AGLOW REa of secu'ng this advertisement publication in the said QUIRED PARKING fO,BE LOCATED IN"THE FRONT;SETBACK P AREA WHICimg,".PROHIBITED'IN.T IE RO ZONING USErDIS- news a er. %TRICT J1ND PROVIDING FORAN EFFECTIVE DATE ` t �j Aboveit�ms can 6e�inspected_in the Clty Cierl�sOffice•Mor�iiay Fntiayt dunrigregulalofficehou[s�,' �+�° L 2'^,Pn{P Yh[ ��e�f tt!6i 4,+.4 vw f . ,w ALL Interested parties ate tnvded to ittend anCv ill`be,-ieard x Swom to and subscribed before me this ' Nana IJI fllenendez yd� }� gz Clty.t:IBdC y��'tt ! ; 7r f. S 10 da Of DECEMBER A.D. 2004 y Y it j ca» i Putst�antokFlorldaStattites 286 01D5 the El�tyhtereby�advises the public; that ifa pefsoq decides fo appealsanydeois ortoaade by this Board Agen �� j`� �_ cy or Cotrtm ssioa(nnthY iespect to any mattereonsiderEd,at its meeting orb heanng'he or she will deed a recoArd of the proceeding's and.1h t forsucMi d t, (SEAL) purpose`affected person maynee`d to er> ure that a uertiatim recor o the;proceedings is made whictx e�rd includes the testimony and evt deuce upon which the appeal Is to`be based r ,, y � OCTELMA V. FERBEYRE personally known tome ,,%r ov, Cheryl H Marmer _ My Commission D0338559 Abr�o` Expires Jury 18.2008 MIAMI DAILY BUSINESS REVIEW Published Daily except Saturday,Sunday and Legal Holidays Miami,Miami-Dade County,Florida STATE OF FLORIDAS�`d _ qtr j �► G � '�Yrx r, r COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE: { 4 asp r N r��Q S 'a a ......-F Before the undersigned authority personally appeared ? a SOOKIE WILLIAMS,who on oath says that he or she is the VICE PRESIDENT,Legal Notices of the Miami Daily Business Review f/k/a Miami Review,a daily(except Saturday,Sunday 1A sra r � tt ! and Legal Holidays)newspaper,published at Miami in Miami Dade t Ar CITY OFOUTH.MIAMh County,Florida;that the attached co of advertisement, M ` copy `,{{ AIO-ISM. PUBLIC HEARINGS ; being a Legal Advertisement of Notice in the matter of x k t u {L I NOTICE-1 groan ttta#the City Gom�missionvbf the U lyxof,South CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARINGS Miatrn Flonnllnductsa.J'tabfic Neangdunng its aegtlla R;Clty: RESOLUTION RE:TWO PARKING VARIANCES,ETC.-1/4/2005 CommissionmeetingonTuesdayJaniyar400begln�mg at�730. p m to the Clty CommissionYChambers:6130Sunse3DnveoYconslder W. in the XXXX Court, 1►RESOLUTION�OF THE MAYOR&CITY COMMISSION OF�4A was published in said newspaper in the issues of THE GITir�O $OUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA, RELATING TO A :� x> ,REQUEST 1FOR APPROV.05,-OF THEFSFOLLyOWING TWO t 12/27/2004 PARKING aVARIANCES IN;DRDERrTO PERMIT�PROPxERTy a�4 LOCATED i4T 623,0�5W 70H STREET lN'AN ROiESIDEN -r t TIAL`''UFEFICE ZONING USE DISTRIGT'+�TO BE�vSED AS`A�, s Affiant further says that the said Miami Daily Business } COMMERCIAL� OFFICEBUILDING� VARIANCE FRONT Review is a newspaper published at Miami in said Miami-Dade a SECTION 20-4r�{(S)(10) OF�rTHE,,.,,LAND DE1,ELOPMENT . County, Florida and that the said newspaper has CODEtj, RLOW FOUR OFFSTREETxPARKING SPACES; WHERE THE REQUIRED OFF STREET PARKING S FIVE heretofore been continuously published in said Miami-Dade County, ;SPACES, (2)VARIANCE,_ ROM„SECTION'20-4 4(F)(3) OF Florida,each day(except Saturday,Sunday and Legal Holidays) THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE TO ALLOW REQt31RED and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post PARKING TO BE LOCATED IN THE FRONT$ETBACKIRF�1 office in Miami in said Miami-Dade County,Florida,for a WHICF� SPROIjIBITED INTHEfiO ZONINGIJSE DISTRICT h, period of one year next preceding the first publication of the ANDPROVI6INi3FOR AN EFFECTIVEDATE attached copy of advertisement;and affiant further says that he or ` ` +� ? �Ss ;; gh� paid nor promised any person,firm or corporation Inqumes concemmg�thls dam shoal z lie directed{3oy ihe,Piannmg'. ebate,commission or refund for the purpose Department at305 663 6326E t �$rx f 1 h ;h,i rti advertisement for ublication in the said ' }P Al-Lyntere�ed parties are to'ayi a f � Z.1 ubscribed before me this Pursuantsto Fionda�Statutes 286t)i05 "the C4.. hereby advises She. public that firma person tiecldes to appeal aqy', Sion made by this 27 o E A• 004 BoaidAgenncy or O wfthrespect io any irtatter ciinsldered at ds meeting or heanng'tie orshe�nnll need a record of ttie pro'ceedings and"that for such purposes affected5person may need toensure that a, verb tlm record of,the proceetlings�is made which record ncludes,Yhe testimony and eutdence upon which the appeal is to be teased (SEAL) 12/27 SOOKIE WILLIAMS personally known to me 2N Maria I.Mesa e My Commission DD293855 q Expires March 04r 2008 _.. _ � . . .._.. is •_ GCHANGE OLD U S-Si S T OU OVA Our TV Week is your handy guide to ISH YOUR TUB &TILE o this week's`Best Bets'in TV and REPLACEMENT ®J�279-5322 cable listings. �LORS FREE ESTIMATES LIC.SINCE 1962 m I F w iW Q • Z D COURTESY-NOTICE I CITY OF SOUTH. MIAMI, FLORIDA I w . On Tuesday, January.4, 2005, beginning at 7:30 p.m.,-in the City Commission.Chambers, 6130 Sunset Drive,the,City Commission will hold a Public Hearing to consider the following item: . A RESOLUTION FOR APPROVAL OF THE FOLLOWING TWO PARKING VARIANCES IN ORDER TO PERMIT PROPERTY LOCATED AT 6230 SW 70TH STREET IN AN"RO" RESIDENTIAL OFFICE ZONING USE DISTRICT TO BE USED AS A COMMERCIAL �.3 OFFICE BUILDING: (I), VARIANCE FROM THE LAND DEVELOPMENT..CODE TO 13 ALLOW FOUR OFF-STREET PARKING SPACES WHERE THE REQUIRED OFF- STREET PARKING IS FIVE SPACES;(2)VARIANCE FROM THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE TO ALLOW REQUIRED PARKING TO BE LOCATED IN THE FRONT SETBACK AREA WHICH IS PROHIBITED IN THE RO ZONING USE DISTRICT. Inquiries concerning this item should be directed to the Planning Department at 305-663-6326. f ALL interested parties are invited to attend and will be heard. 1 Maria M.Menende"z City Clerk !. Pursuant to Florida Statutes 286.0105,the City hereby advises the public that if a person decides to appeal any decision made by this Board,Agency or Commission with respect to any matter considered at its meeting or hearing,he or she will need a record of the proceedings,and that for such purpose,affected person may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. i , i i { i ALL Running-& Fitness Even some kids 'RUNNING SHOES ' APPAREL shoes&-sandals o ON SALE 4®- 6® /� OFF 20 - 60% OFF from: - I I ALL SANDALS Aatl i 15% OFF r C s7 r4° 1 ONG. newbalance I, Limited styles,sizes and color available in sale items Cabrera, Lourdes From: Rabi, Hector Sent: Thursday, December 01, 2005 8:34 AM To: Cabrera, Lourdes Cc: Kruger, Luis; Youkilis, Sanford Subject: RE: Good Morning I do not have any occupational license for that address. -----Original Message----- From: Cabrera, Lourdes Sent: Wednesday, November 30, 2005 11:49 AM To: Rabi, Hector Cc:Youkilis, Sanford; Kruger, Luis Subject: Good morning Hector, Address: 6230 SW 70 Street Do they have an occupational license for VALET PARKING? Please let me know because I need a copy. Thanks, Lourdes SK .. CH OF SURVEY SCALE - m 10.00� A194411 1411ger ref 040,;�- e-,A14' T14 Mv 5 A _ _ 90 EnicaO�►CN�S lo,sp r` 4 r �;• 1 xZO rHE 8457EQ Ui' 0;A a.o�i Cow z) A wvuo F swum Q Ei,lc►AA�EFS I"T o Td E I MIZ Owe rND n�� i A . 3� A ccbop � �p ENC.�A�1/ES 2.©d� '" �rb4'/I�TD 7'j,'� aDdtNE,i2LJ' �c%t A tMFNT� , IW6 Sot/T��/z' .of Y 12Poe S eu 70-0 t>7"9E,67- /5 A4f7- ACOOHDW TO THE INK ROOD PFKX WW TIDE S AJECT PROPEM FALLS N ROOD ZONE COMMUNTY No: PANS No. OWM- DATE OF FfM PAM ZONE: SAEJ FLOOD ELEV LOCA'nON MAP (N.Ts.) x+t 5'► rT �'0 N PROPERTY ADDRESS: 6230 S.W. 70th Street, Miami, Florida 33143 . LEGAL DESCRIPTION: The West 54 .00 feet of the North 88 .00 feet on the East 137 .00 feet of the North 150.00 feet of the West of the Southeast J, of the Southeast I of the Southwest 4 of Section 25, Township 54 South, Range 40 East, lying and being in Dade County, Florida.. FOR: MARTA MILLIAN GONZALEZ. CERTIFY TO: MARTA MILLIAN GONZALEZ. UNION TITLE SERVICES, INC. STEWART TITLE GUARANTY COMPANY, INC. SURVEYOR'S NOTES: PREPARED BY` 1)This survey was conducted or the purpose of a•eourvary Survey orvy ono a not winded to tlNneate the r'eguwory Rufhsohcton of any federal,state:reolonat or sora1 agency,board,ocrnmlmlcn or other entity. GUN TER oil Vlf OU , INC. L8 4507 z)The accuracy obettnsd by rnaanuramerrta and cetcuatio o on this surva,meets end exceeds the Mintykmh raaxrral Standards LAND SURVEYNG— LAND PLANNNG npQL rarnenhta for a Suburban area(1 Mot In 7.600 feet)as apsoaled In Chapter 61G17$,Florida AdmW40tra"Code. 3)The Survey not reflect or dolorrriline owrlershlp 9350 5.W. 22nd TERRACE 4)Legal.tiseoflplon eub)ebt to any dodone",tkThthWprn.restrabaons reservetons or eeeenlenfs of,a= A MIAMI, FLORIDA 33163 67 Eiumktstlon of ate Abair=of T1te MB.hsve to be made to dolorm he recorded tnst urnenb,if any erecting the Drop";searon n/w srwt a a. (305) 220-0073 of autift iisocdo rot Partoff ned by tde office. d)No eitort was made by the ofaoe to Iocew any underground WUass wxWr structures wthin or auLM*V art outloot pfdperp.. (art.) CALOL .TFD e ro Met)as rpr s• S)This su ey br the excMUeh a use of the erttlUae narned hereon only and the certifications hdo not mr- a es w.w a 9)Utility facaen within Uft£ nwh aer*not noted as Ookvtioro. 'y`n r e 10)Cwkroaya or porbone aresof vrlritr+Fbadways not nptad as v%oatoro a enaoachmorha '� a�f�C a sru000 wf' 4•a,s 1 11)Sou daaons and/or fooangs under*heath she ground surtaae riot rrey doss beyond are boundary lines of the herein doew beo (m) a u� '`� ya QCs)' panOM we not shrnm ddb 1 Z)At ton Fip6a or Ae%oor found and shown on the sketch of survey Have no cape union otherwise stated, 0. theirs >r 13)Fence owneraflo debrrrW*by visual maars only(A arc;Legal ownership not debvtvNned. CA-F. d UM Fort[ :y` .. - 14)44o search d records was made toy thb fom beside the record plot;thorefore we do not Irripty or accept tespons"Ity rot any .:r. tom rpr¢ ), if EE-aearrharlt,Oadlosticn or Ltrdtaaon for whlon ahfbrTrhstlOn was rot tlrnwihed. ac � Pour I " .� 15)Contact 41e appropriate authorities prior o airy deagn Y 0W on the Mr eon-deectlbad Wool R1r awwv and Zonev etonnaton F wrc rnoiuv+r tf>7 PldressiorhY Lend 6vrveyor and Mapper eh responsible Cherye:ftoandq Ortd LS 4312.State of Flonde. wismratTta - _ I?)Ttas sure"Y not vallo without the signature and the reload asst of a Fonda Licensed Land Surveyor and Mapper. a°' M00e rdl6 it t-$t4 . UP'T rata .v -MM fxO1T CM T I nsraby ovVy to tiro above named aim ardW parsons that the Wwtotoh d Survey d the desortbed property b true and correct to rrc wear o°r teat[JrcF "'t �y fro best or my itnovv .g and beast,as reowMy surveyed and patty under my 0"Won;two asst mesa the PAthtrnr n TOCh yCN r,T. horn v 1MQlIC �a { OA St aTdard a met in Chapter 61©17-0,flaws Admthwtslhe Code,Pt.rroUmrs b Seollorh x72.027 fioride Statutes. - ° DA Nto: WSTCH Na: WN FEV00IJS eD-1,391_7 13613 /0 e 0(2 y 4 y 4t��..1 k _ �y- fi i • owl `'. Pon IF fi �diiwi 81-. _ � t (F 6'i(yyiaml,. • � ! r—�I �_ -' a sz �'v � '+�1 jt r ?U r E "`'' � .,r'��`izy"' w,: �„. i?•�wx �: �4 �(>:#° �v2 A;1� -u+.,.2a�xC�R.w. w � r. xt• fk n .�' i .f S•+f1=� ti lox WO • : . u . . \. .. . . . . . < . . . \d\'\\ ; A m > SUL, � 6� � d �F zap a CoZ�JO � 2or 2 r "Try Rte. Id V-4 v I 1aC 4 a M J ,�y,rt ,��► ,ui'< .ice':_ �`.�'� �, �• �, ^�ht' emu,; '�'.t_► = yb .4¢ J'• i • • t 1* .j. - ..-.. �. ..a.- Va