The URL can be used to link to this page

5845 SW 68 ST_PB-74-16 CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE PLANNING BOAP.Z "..'LE IN DUPLICATE) THIS APPLICATION MUST BE COMPLETED AND RETURNED, WITH ALL REQUIRED SUPPORTING DATA TO THE OFFICE OF THE ZONING DIRECTOR BEFORE PROCEEDINGS MAY BE STARTED FOR PUBLIC HEARING. APPLICANT - AS (OWNER, TENANT, AGENT, ETC. SPECIFY) RALPH H. COKER, JR. Owner (and as Executor) ADDRESS OF APPLICANT CITY STATE ZIP PHONE 10510 S. W. 42nd Street Miami Florida 33165 667-7579 OWNER DATE OWNERSHIP OF PROPERTY OBTAINED Estate of Ralph Coker, Deceased and Ralph Co er, Jr. ADDRESS OF OWNER CITY STATE ZIP PHONE _ 10510 S. W. 42nd Street Miami Florida 33165 667-7529 IS PROPERTY OPTION OR CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE? MORTGAGEE IS NAME AND ADDRESS First National Bank YES -X NO lof South Miami,. 5750 Sunset Drive, S.M. IF APPLICANT IS NOT OWNER, IS LETTER OF AUTHORITY FROM OWNER ATTACHED? YES NO LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY COVERED BY APPLICATION LOT(S) 13, 14, 15 & 17 BLOCK 8 SUBDIVISION Townsite of Larkin PB 2/105 METES AND BOUNDS SIZE OF AREA COVERED BY APPLICATION NAMES AND OFFICIAL WIDTHS OF ABUTTING I/WIS 125 ' wide x 147 ' deep S. W. 68th Street ADDITIONAL DEDICATIONS PROPOSED STRUCTURES LOCATED ON PROPERTY Frame and CBS Office Building and' CBS Garage APPLICATION TO THE PLANNING BOARD FOR ACTION ON THE FOLLOWING: X CHANGE OF ZONING EXCEPTION OTHER (SPECIFY) VARIANCE AMEND SECTION OF CODE PRESENT.ZONE CLASSIFICATION CHANGE OF ZONING REQUESTED RS 4 C-3 USE DESIRED NOT PERMITTED BY EXISTING REGULATIONS Transfer of existing property without jeopardizing existing and any other C-3 uses. _ THE FOLLOWING SUPPORTING DATA REQUIRED IS SUBMITTED WITH THIS APPLICATION. (ATTACHED HERETO AND MADE PART OF APPLICATION. ) - CERTIFIED SURVEY SITE PLAN PHOTOGRAPHS X STATEI.IENT OF REASONS 1R CONDITIONS JUSTIFYING CHANGE REQUESTED PROPOSED FLOOR PLAN _ HEARING FEE (CASH OR CHECK) OTHER THE UNDERSIGNED HAS READ THIS COMPLETED APPLICATION AND REPRESENTS THE INFORMATION AND ALL SUPPORTING DATA FURNISHED IS TRUE AND CORRECT TO THE BEST OF HIS KNOWLEDGE AND BB�ELIEFF.. T _ may+ SIGNAT J&F-r v1,-Z. O�ER, . Individually antes—Execu��((o��rLJl o a FOR OFFICE USE ONLY DATE OF HEARING _ HEARING NO. PSBIOO-21 DATE FILED REV. 4-21-59 CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI ZONING DIVISION PROCEDURE ON APPLICATION FOR HEARING BEFORE THE PLANNING BOARD 1. SECURE APPLICATION FORMS FROM THE ZONING DIRECTOR'S OFFICE. 2. HAVE SKETCH OR PLANS WITH SUFFICIENT DETAILS INDICATING THE VARIANCES OR EXCEPTIONS REQUESTED. FOR CHANGE OF ZONING, PLANS MAY NOT BE REQUIRED. THE APPLICANT IS-INSTRUCT- SO THAT A SEPARATE APPLICATION WILL BE REQUIRED FOR VARIANCES AND EXCEPTIONS AFTER THE CHANGE OF ZONING HAS BEEN GRANTED BY COUNCIL. 3. FILL OUT THE APPLICATION COMPLETELY AND ACCURATELY WITH SURVEYS, PHOTOS, PLANS, ETC. AS NEEDED BEFORE SUBMITTING TO THE ZONING DIRECTOR. 4. SUBMIT THE APPLICATION TO THE ZONING DIRECTOR AT LEAST THREE (3) WEEKS PRIOR TO THE PLANNING BOARD MEETING. A FEE OF $50. 00 IS REQUIRED AT THE TIME THE APPLICATION IS FILED. S. REGULAR PLANNING BOARD MEETINGS ARE HELD TWICE PER MONTH, ON TUESDAY PRECEDING THE REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING. (COUNCIL MEETS ON THE FIRST AND THIRD TUESDAY OF EACH MONTH). THE MEETINGS ARE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS, CITY HALL AND BEGIN AT 89 00 O'CLOCK P. M. 6. THE APPLICANT (OR HIS AGENT) SHOULD REPRESENT HIMSELF AT THE PLANNING BOARD MEETING: THE APPLICANT WILL BE EXPECTED TO PRESENT HIS CASE WITH PLANS, PETITIONS, AFFIDAVITS OR ANY OTHER DATA WHICH HE FEELS WILL HELP IN HIS PRESENTATION. THE PLANNING BOARD WILL ACT ON THE APPLICATION BASED ON THE INFORMATION AVAILABLE IF NO ONE IS PRESENT TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF THE APPLICANT. 7. THE PLANNING BOARD WILL MAKE ITS RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE COUNCIL WHICH WILL THEN ACT ON THEM. 8. THE APPLICANT SHOULD BE PRESENT AT THE COUNCIL MEETING TO PRESENT HIS CASE AT WHICH TIME THE COUNCIL WILL PASS A RESOLUTION OR ORDINANCE, APPROVING OR DENYING THE REQUEST MADE BY THE APPLICANT. 9. A CHANGE OF ZONING, VARIANCE OR EXCEPTION REQUIRES AN ORDINANCE BE ADOPTED BY COUNCIL. THIS BECOMES EFFECTIVE AFTER COUNCIL HAS TAKEN ACTION AT TWO CONSEQUENT MEETINGS. THE ORDINANCE BECOMES EFFECTIVE UPON ADOPTION AFTER THIRD READING. a , s STATEMENT ATTACHED TO APPLICATION FOR ZONING There is no RS 4 use on this block on either side of the street. To the east is the Florida Power & Light Transformer installation and among other uses of surrounding property are a moving company, a junkyard, and an automobile repair and similar use. Lots 23 through 26 immediately to the east have recently been 're-zoned to C-3 and there is no basis to restrict the use of the property covered by this application to RS 4. JEPEWAY,GASSEN&JEPEWAY,ATTORNEYS AT LAW,DADE FEDERAL BUILDING,MIAMI,FLORIDA 33131 • TELEPHONE 377-2386 JEPEWAY, GASSEN & JEPEWAY ATTORNEYS AT LAW 6 1 9 D A D E FEDERAL B U I L D I N G 101 EAST FLAG LE R STREET LOUIS M.JEPEWAY MIAMI, FLORIDA 33131 . JOSEPH GASSEN TELEPHONE 377-2356 LOUIS M.JEPEWAY, JR. October 16, 1974 Mr. Gilbert Russe Planning and Zoning Department City of South Miami 6130 Sunset Drive South Miami, Florida RE: Zoning Application Crockett, PB 74-15 Zoning Application Coker, PB 74-16 ;1 Dear Mr. Russe: The City Council passed both of the captioned matters on first reading at the regular meeting on Tuesday, October 15, 1974. At that time, Mayor Block announced that both matters would be brought up for public hearing and final reading at the- regular council meeting on the first Tuesday in November, to wit: Tuesday, November 5, 1974. I trust that you will do all of the posting of notices and advertising that is necessary. Please be good enough to send me a copy of the notices. We did receive a copy of Mr. Duncan' s report dated October 10, 1974, and appreciate your furnishing #t b us very much. , Thank you for your courtesies to us throughout.this. C dilly, JOS PH GASSEN JG/j jb cc: -Mr. Ralph Coker, Jr. Mr. . T. R. Crockett •+ - 5 � 1 s Y 7 L t � � � � / 9 Sub; a NiN R�coA rrvi,✓Q.4Ti*Ad R /Q,eQsT e peo�P�e z��,a� v�,� eTw Q.J a e�.ecT _tG svQS7'AT'a 4Ad, s a � .,.,� F _ �x f, - 3 ! yR`+ raa - ... x: '... '� '' � ft,3,� �.,,..• �yo-74M Y a �a� � ;s, �. s ,.. .'��., •�; «• �y'x..1'°� .ms's;�,w„ � x} ��+ e. -� Y i...r:• � ,,.'r ne -~ s .. +,'' «s> a.;. �"y: �: ' has. -� ,>a a � � S iw AA C'o P.4 r/es daJ►�R i ;, . y: .. -a �.a, • `_r �z, y"r r' "'•�r"i°,r4-.., F.i�— ♦± 'as -,. a.r 10 14 cop Jq ` e z BCS. t f�f tc**1 O� O AMPs A46 fq?JT�Pl irY�/� a ' ;�MIbIPIC•ii Ar �'�I�4+Pr I i1f QC1Er' "" ;�~' �T'bP�� IN�P�✓�oeo!1 Pi; /�Sr �A�?� /S�QD/T/on� v O Lei �if A! ND7"4 hIA� t�apo�/'GiA� .[ ��l�R�C — rr -� - z � Y ,_-� .. -_-�__ .�+i.-..+_ '.Yp..!,y,> --..♦�, iws J* P _ _ -.sue ._1..., r- ar- - ' - .. ¢ - .A � op , - ev tay ao�- ,APR e.1 zee Ps'�.�. 4� ►Is �P�LfmIJ ��l p. rMa ko�d!OfJf QPYASO _ �-)/Y}�A dlRee giac eN�O�,tTa�q : F g y vT `ate T�IQ S drN, o eN�ine i f4o"#V F9P_ OAT J / YyV t,t tim sNo6►tpe f � ai�i�o C3 %4Ng ? � Ph- At detseR I v7eo!fi ..,4.. Oil DIt0 - COIAPATl�Gd 'Pkff t44 ORDINANCE NO. 47-74-845 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA, CHANGING THE ZONING OF CERTAIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY FROM RS-4 SINGLE FAMILY TO C-3 ARTERIAL COMMERCIAL. (Coker, Jr.-5845 SW 68th Street) * Councilwoman Willis moved d, seconded by Councilwoman Lantz that this be considered the Final Reading- of the Ordinance in its entirety and it be adopted as read and assigned the next number by the City Clerk. * Mayor Block stated Public Hearing in Session. No one caring to speak either for or against the Ordinance, Mayor Block deemed the Public Hearing closed. * Moved by Councilwoman Willis, seconded by Councilwoman Lantz that the Ordinance be amended as follows: Section 1. " . . . from RS-4 Single Family, to C-3 Arterial Commercial, and said change in zoning shall be reflected on the Official City Map. " Motion carried by the following roll call: "Yeas"- Councilwomen Lantz, McCann and Willis and Mayor Block. "Nays"-. None. Vice Mayor Gibson was absent. * Motion as amended carried by the following roll call : "Yeas" - Councilwomen McCann, Lantz and Willis and Mayor Block. "Nays" - None. Vice Mayor Gibson was absent. * The next item on the Agenda, No. 6, was the Final Reading of an Ordinance, captioned as follows: AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA, GRANTING A VARIANCE FOR A 0 FOOT SIDE SETBACK INSTEAD OF THE REQUIRED 15 FOOT SIDE SETBACK FOR THE PURPOSE OF PERMITTING THE CONSTRUCTION OF AN ADDITION TO AN EXISTING STRUCTURE AS TO CERTAIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY. (Thad Mark-5995 Sunset Dr.) * Moved by Mayor Block, seconded by Councilwoman Lantz that this Ordinance be deferred to the next Council Meeting when a full Council will be present. Motion carried by the following roll call: "Yeas" - Councilwomen Lantz and Willis and Mayor Block. "Nays" - Councilwoman McCann. Vice Mayor Gibson was absent. * The next item on the Agenda, No. 7, was a Resolution, captioned as follows : -4- 11/5/74/cw ORDINANCE No. 47-74-845 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA, CHANGING THE ZONING OF CERTAIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY FROM RS-4 SINGLE FAMILY, TO C-3 ARTERIAL COMMERCIAL. WHEREAS, the Planning Board has recommended a change in zoning from RS-4 Single Family, to C-3 Arterial Commercial, for the property to be rezoned. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA: Section 1. That the recommendation of the Planning , Board for a change in zoning. from RS-4 Single Family, to C-3 Arterial Commercial, in connection with the property described as: Lots 13,' 14, 15, 16 and 17, Block 8, TOWNSITE OF LARKINS, according to the Plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book . 2, Page 105 of the Public Records of Dade County, Florida, a/k/a 5845 Southwest 68th Street, South Miami, Florida, is hereby approved and the zoning of said property be, and the same is hereby changed from RS-4 Single Family, to C-3 Arterial Commercial. and said change of zoning shall be reflected on the Official City Map. PASSED and ADOPTED this 5th day of November, 1974. APPROVED: MAYOR City Clerk Moved by Willis Seconded by Lantz Passed on First. Reading: 10/15/74 YES. NO Passed on Final Reading: 11/5/74 Block X Willis X Gibson Absent Lantz X _ McCann X The next item, No. 13, was an Ordinance, captioned as follows : t AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA, CHANGING THE ZONING !p OF CERTAIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY FROM 9� RS-4 SINGLE FAMILY, TO C-3 ARTERIAL COMMERCIAL. (Coker, Jr. ) a * Moved by Councilwoman Willis, seconded by Vice Mayor Gibson that this be considered the first reading of the Ordinance and that it be placed on the Agenda of November 5, 1974, for Final Reading and Public Hearing. Motion carried by the following roll call : "Yeas" - Councilwomen McCann and Willis, Vice Mayor Gibson and Mayor Block. "Nays" - None. Councilwoman Lantz was absent. 4�* Council requested the City Manager give his recommendation on the Zoning Consultant' s written opinion on the zoning of the above properties and other properties on 68th Street. * Item No. 5, was brought before the Council for their reconsideration, which was an Ordinance captioned as follows : t AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA, GRANTING A VARIANCE FOR A 5 .46 FOOT INTERIOR SIDE SETBACK INSTEAD OF THE REQUIRED 10 FEET AS TO CERTAIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY (Snyder) * Moved by Councilwoman McCann, seconded by Councilwoman Willis that this be considered the Final Reading of the Ordinance in its entirety and- it be adopted as read and assigned the next number by the City Clerk. Motion carried by the following roll call: "Yeas" - Councilwomen McCann and Willis, Vice Mayor Gibson and Mayor Block. "Nays-"None. Councilwoman Lantz was absent. * The next item, No. 14 was a Resolution, captioned as follows : -7- 10/15/74/cw CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI INTER — OFFICE MEMORANDUM DATE October 9, 1974 TO: Mr. Jim Duncan, Zoning Consultant _ FROM' Gil Russe, Building Official . The administration was requested by the Planning Board to obtain your recommendation for the zoning of the property located. on the north side of 68th Street between 58th Place and the electric substation. Kindly send your opinion in a letter at your earliest convenience. ly ooe t?e Q-&rsr__ oic O-c?:-�J- -Ar G- 01AI - _ - --- - SW . lsY�� s7o �S�rwee�: -t�� _ ececr� tc s��Sr�T�a�_•qN�- - - - ---- — S Gov iP_eo4ei.., -r re Ako-orRrets. -s✓eoe,, - - -��SlbN�o _- �t� _.�e�/rr.�7°" /PS• y etgstsfie.4rior�.r o4woor l'M o" , SPoroocI G _/Q4�of 400v - -- - C aM/hrr�► tom T� *'S- 4 AT' TAM- T'im 4 6*44S 4004_ —- -�-- ----- - T®__�� 'i9►�R K . 1 w61ic_ �R�t _i�i��- -P�!'i�►�h!�U _e�f�1 - - __.--- -- -- - --- - -- -- vN-Of fS r•A-NO, t�i•or - �e 9�e� - -- px��r.eT� s_---a�/ -. 7i'�►E _/vQ/�_ Prt~lAM.—IyAS - - -- OIR/qt.l3,Cr0 _ I��!►A __. I,f CoNtIrOC�lE•p /pi!tt�T�! �r� woe G ---- - �l��1�.!_'�Ilt�jp_ _vSR6G �QCGep►t,✓pgT�e#✓---��T"" Lo?S _/3 7?�►R� - — - --71C - - - Wiles- DN *ke __ WCfT_.WO+iiO Crt�A- rt� - R_ 7rRgN1!Tt��J _moo - f -_------- � t MRS. FRANCES HERMAN 5465 S. W. 85th Street Miami, Florida October 2, 19.74 CITY COUNCIL City of South Miami South Miami, Florida CT 9 1974 Attention: City Manager. , Mr. Pete Pakey Dear Mr. Pakey: Please be informed that I am the owner of the property located in the Townsite of Larkins, Lots 10, 11 and 12 ; Block 8, PB 2/105,' This is at the corner of South West .",.__. 68th Street and 58th Place and is vacant land. At the Planning Board meeting on September 24, 1974, Mr. , , Ralph Coker, Jr. and Mr. T. R. Crockett, my two immediate neighbors, requested a change of zoning from RS-4 (single family) to C-3 (arterial commercial) ,-.. the Planning Board approved both requests and is recommending C-3 zoning to the City Council on both pieces of property. In 1973, Mr. LaPlante, whose property is at the other.-end . .- of the block from me, . next to Mr. Crockett, had his property reinstated to the C-3 zoning that the entire block had been when we bought it in 1966. Mr. James Duncan, the attorney for the Council, suggested at that time that this whole strip on 68th Street be re- 'instated back to C-3 but it was not done. My property on the corner is next to a plumbing company and across the street from warehouses, a junk yard and an air conditioning company. I would like to do something with the property that would both provide me with some income and the City with some tax revenue. Please consider my request to re-zone the whole strip, includ- ing my property back to C-3. Thank you very much for your consideration in this matter. Very truly yours, AO i MRS . FRANC ES HERMAN. 5465 S. W. 85th Street Miami, Florida October 2 , 1974 CITY COUNCIL City of South Miami South Miami, Florida Attention : Mr. Harvey P ierce, Chaiman Planning Board Dear Mr. Pierce : Please be informed that I am the owner of the property located in the Townsite of Larkins, Lots 10, 11 and 12 ; Block 8, PB 2/105. This is at the corner of South West 68th Street and 58th Place and is vacant land. At the Planning Board meeting on September 24, 1974, Mr. Ralph Coker, Jr. and Mr. T. R. Crockett, my two immediate neighbors, requested a change of zoning from RS-4 (single family) to C-3 (arterial commercial) ; the- Planning Board approved both requests and is recommending C-3 zoning to the City Council on both pieces of property. In 1973, Mr. LaPlante, whose property is at the other end of the block from me, next to Mr. Crockett, had his property reinstated to the C-3 zoning that the entire block had been when we bought it in 1966. Mr. James Duncan, the attorney for the Council, suggested at that time that this whole strip on 68th Street be re- instated back to C-3 but it was not done. My property on the corner is next to a plumbing company and across the street from warehouses, a junk yard and an air conditioning company. I would like to -do something with the property that would both provide me with some income and the City with some tax revenue. Please consider my request to re-zone the whole strip, includ- ing my property back to C-3. Thank you very much for your consideration in this .matter. Very truly yours, cn A U A 0 w a w x A w f eM r x ON c H m 0 0 C+ rn N• a � n Y• N CD C+ v i N CD 'tl 11 0'Q 1 �� O R. MINUTES OF A REGULAR MEETING �} PLANNING BOARD, CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI SEPTEMBER 24, 1974 APPROVED. OCTOBER 8, 1974 The meeting was called to order by Chairman Harvey Pierce at 7:40 P. M. The Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag of the United States was followed by the roll call. PRESENT: James Bowman Edward Coburn Jacques Fleischer Eva, Longbrake Pat Masters Harvey Pierce Robert Regan { Mr. William Godwin, .Public Works Director, Mr. Gilbert Russe, Building Official, and Lt. Cochran and Mr. Tarrant of the Metropolitan Dade County Fire Department were also present. The first item to come before the Board was approval of the Minutes of the Meeting of September 10, 1974. MOTION: By Mr. Fleischer, seconded by Mr. Coburn, to approve the Minutes of the Meeting of September 10, 1974. Mrs. Masters suggested that approval of the Minutes be deferred until after the Public Hearings and discussion with Lt. Cochran and Mr. Tarrant. Mr. Fleischer withdrew his motion to approve and Mr. Coburn withdrew his second to the motion. MOTION: By Mrs. Masters, seconded by Mr. Bowman, to defer approval of the Minutes of the Meeting of September 10, 1974 until after the Public Hearings and discussion with Lt. Cochran. VOTE IN FAVOR OF MOTION: Yes - (7) MOTION CARRIED. PUBLIC HEARING #72- S',_ ley Homes, Inc. i Request: Variance to permit construction of single family residence on existing lot which is only 40 feet in width (75 feet required) and variance to permit construction of single family residence on lot approximately 4,800 Sq. Ft. (10,000 Sq. Ft. required) . Legal Description: Lot 12, Block 1, SEAVIEW PARK, PB 17/80. Location: 5751 S. W. 84 Street. Robert M. Brake, Attorney for the applicant, requested that both hearings be heard at the same time. Mr. Ben Hendricks, Jr. , Attorney representing Mrs. Margaret Shaw who owns property adjacent to the properties at Lot 12, Block 1 and Lot 16, Block 2, SEAVIEW PARK, requested that the hearings be heard separately. Mr. Brake presented the request of the applicant to the Board and offered into evidence four photographs of houses which have been built on 40 foot lots (two of which are located in Coral Gables) ; Affidavit of John G. De War and Ruth A. De War, his wife, stating that they are the owners of Lot 12, Block 1 and Lot 16, Block 2 of SEAVIEW PARK, PB 14/34, that said lots were obtained by Warranty Deed dated September 15, 1962 from Agnes T. Beatty as Grantor, and John G. De War and Ruth A. De War, his wife, Grantees, that the said Grantor, Agnes T. Beatty, now deceased, was the mother of Ruth A. De War, and said property was deeded by Agnes T. Beatty to John G. De War and Ruth A. De War as part of the distribution of the Estate of Agnes T. Beatty and at no time did either Agnes T. Beatty or John G. De War and Ruth A. De War ever own any of the lots which are immediately adjacent to the two lots in question; Warranty Deed between Agnes T. Beatty and John G. De War and Ruth A. De War dated September 15, 1962 ; and Warranty Deed No. E16551 of Clifford Country Estates, Inc. These documents were accepted by the Chairman and made a permanent part of the file. Mr. Hendricks spoke in opposition to granting the request of the applicant stating that a 40 foot lot is too narrow to provide for the necessity of an aesthetically appealing residence. He stated that granting of these variances would create a hardship to his client, Mrs. Shaw, who owns the adjacent properties . Mr. Hendricks questioned the validity of the original application inasmuch as Shirley Homes, Inc. is not the owner. Chairman Pierce stated that Power of Attorney had been given by Mr. and Mrs. De War to Shirley Homes, Inc. and Robert M. Brake to act in their behalf in this application. Chairman Pierce asked if there was anyone present who wished to speak in favor of or against granting the request of the applicant and there was not. Chairman Pierce declared the public hearing closed. Page 2 - 9/24/74 jk A discussion was ha6 y the Board wherein it wa.; elt by the members that this constitutes a self-imposed hardship on the part of the applicant and that the variances requested should not be granted. The question was raised as to whether or not the property was contracted for with the knowledge that. the lots do not conform. It was further felt that houses on 40 foot lots consisting of 4, 800 Sq. Ft. would be detrimental to the health and welfare of the City because of problems with parking and septic tank placement. MOTION: By Mr. Fleischer, seconded by Mr. Bowman, to recommend denial of the request of the applicant. VOTE IN FAVOR OF MOTION: Yes - (7) MOTION CARRIED. PUBLIC HEARING #72-21 Shirley Homes, Inc. Request: Variance to permit construction of single family residence on existing lot which is only 40 feet in width (75 feet required) and variance to permit construction of single family residence on lot approximately 4,800 Sq. Ft. (10, 000 Sq. Ft. required) . Legal Description: Lot 16, Block 2, SEAVIEW PARK, PB 17/80. Location: 5780 S . W. 84 Street. Robert M. Brake, Attorney for the applicant, presented the request to the Board and requested that the documents presented in the previous hearing also be entered into the file in this hearing. Mr. Ben Hendricks, Jr. , Attorney representing Mrs. Margaret Shaw who owns property adjacent to the properties at Lot 12, Block 1 and Lot 16, Block 2, SEAVIEW PARK, spoke in opposition to the request of the applicant for the same reasons as stated in the previous hearing. Chairman Pierce asked if there was anyone present who wished to speak in favor of or against granting the request of the applicant and there was not. Chairman Pierce declared the public hearing closed. A discussion was had by the Board wherein it was felt by the members that if a. hardship exists in this case it is self-imposed and that the variances requested should not be granted. It was the opinion of the Board that while the owner of a property is entitled to the highest and best use of his property, its use must be in accordance with the laws designed to protect the interest of the majority. A recommendation was made to the. City Council that the provisions of Section 8-5 of the Zoning Ordinance No. 20-71-724 are clear and provide for the universally recognized idea that 50 ' is the minimum acceptable width for the construction Page 3 - 9/24/74 jk } of a. single family residence. MOTION: By Mr. Fleischer, seconded by Mr. Bowman, to recommend denial of the request of the applicant and to suggest to the City Council that to grant this request would be in violation of Section 8-5 of the Zoning Ordinance No. 20-71-724 of the City of South Miami. MOTION: By Mrs. Masters, seconded by Mrs . Longbrake, to amend the .Motion by adding the words, " and would not contribute to the health and welfare of the City of South Miami". VOTE IN FAVOR OF AMENDMENT: Yes - (3) No - (4) Bowman, Coburn, Fleischer, Pierce MOTION DEFEATED. VOTE IN FAVOR OF ORIGINAL MOTION: Yes - (7) MOTION CARRIED. Chairman Pierce called a. recess to the meeting at 8:25 P. M. The Meeting was called back to order at 8: 55 P. M. PUBLIC HEARING #$74-15 T. R. Crockett Request: Change of zoning from RS-4 (Single Family) to C-3 (Arterial Commercial) . Legal Description: Lots 18, 19; 20, 21 and 22, Block 8, TOWNSITE OF LARKINS, PB 2/105. Location: 5825 S. W. 68 Street. Mr. Joseph Gassen of 101 East Flagler Street, Miami, Fla. , Attorney for the applicant, presented the request to the Board. He stated that he had previously appeared before the Board representing Mr. LaPlant, who owns property in this same block, on July 31, 1973 . At that time, Mr. James Duncan, Planning Consultant for the City of South Miami, stated that he had reviewed the history of the zoning and uses of the properties (of which ' this parcel is a part) and stated that he preferred either C-1 or C-3 zoning. He stated that Mr. LaPlant eventually was granted C-3 zoning for his property. Page 4 - 9/24/74 jk Chairman Pierce a.ske ' if there was anyone preset_ , who wished to speak either for or against the request of, the applicant and there was not. Chairman Pierce declared the public hearing closed. MOTION By Mr. Fleischer, seconded by Mr. Coburn, to recommend granting the request of the applicant. VOTE IN FAVOR OF MOTION: Yes - (7) MOTION CARRIED. PUBLIC HEARING #74-16 Ralph H. Coker, Jr. Request: Change of zoning from RS-4 (Single Family) to C-3 (Arterial Commercial) . Legal Description: Lots 13, 14, 15, 16 and 17, Block 8, TOWNSITE OF LARKINS, PB 2/105. Location: 5825 S. W. 68 Street. Mr. Joseph Ga.ssen of 101 East Flagler Street, Miami, Florida, Attorney for the applicant, presented the request to the Board. He restated the arguments presented in the previous hearing. Chairman Pierce read into the record a card received from Mr. Walter A. Mobley of Mobley Enterprises stating that, as a property owner within the 500 foot vicinity of the lots in question, he fully concurred with the requested zoning change and stated that he felt the change would be an asset to the area . Chairman Pierce asked if there was anyone present who wished to speak either for or against the request of the applicant and there was not. Chairman Pierce declared the public hearing closed. A discussion was had by the Board wherein it was their opinion that this zoning should be increased either to C-2 or C-3 due to the zoning of the immediate surrounding properties and they felt that a. recommendation should be requested of the City Planning Consultant. MOTION: By Mr. Bowman, seconded by Mr. Fleischer, to recommend granting the request of the applicant. MOTION: By Mr. Fleischer, seconded by Mrs. Masters, to amend the Motion to approve to C-2 or C-3 zoning, depending upon the recommendation of the City Planning Consultant. VOTE IN FAVOR OF AMENDMENT: Yes - (5) No - (2) Bowman, Coburn Page 5 - 9/24/74 jk MOTION: By Mr. Bowman, seconded by Mr. Pierce, to approve the original Motion as amended. VOTE IN FAVOR OF MOTION: Yes - (7) MOTION CARRIED. PUBLIC HEARING #74-17 Anselmo L. Alliegro Request: Variance to permit an 8, 237 Sq. Ft. lot size (10, 000 Sq. Ft. required) for single family residence. Legal Description: Lot 14, Block 1, SOLIMAR SUBDIVISION, PB 94/50. Location: 4899 Ludlan Road. Mr. Alliegro was not present and, .a.fter a. discussion of the Board, it was decided to defer this hearing. MOTION: By Mrs. Masters, seconded by Mr. Bowman, to defer this hearing to the next regular meeting, in view of applicant ' s failure to appear. VOTE IN FAVOR OF MOTION: Yes - (7) MOTION CARRIED. EXECUTIVE SESSION: After discussion of the Board it was decided to postpone the Executive Session of the meeting until after the "Remarks" due to the fact that a discussion was scheduled at that time with Lt. Cochran and Mr. Greenwald of the Metropolitan Dade County Fire Department and they had been present and waiting for some time. REMARKS A discussion was had with Lt. Cochran and Mr. Tarrant (Mr. Tarrant in place of Mr. Greenwald who could not attend) regarding the fire code, fire prevention and fire protection in the City of South Miami. Various questions were raised by the Board members concerning the adequacy of the water supply in the City, inspection of high rise buildings and the require- ment of redevelopers to bring water systems up-to-date. Page 6 - 9/24/74 jk EXECUTIVE SESSION: MOTION: By Mrs. Masters, seconded by Mr. Bowman, to approve the Minutes of the Meeting of September 10, 1974 as read. VOTE IN FAVOR OF MOTION: Yes - (7) MOTION CARRIED. A discussion was had by the Board concerning the number of fire hydrants in the City and it was the general consensus of the Board that the number of fire hydrants within the City limits needs to be increased. The Board merrbers were also in agreement that a. general survey of the City' s water supply and availability should be made. A discussion was had concerning overgrown lots within the City and in particular the lot at 80th Street a.nd 67th Avenue and also overgrown lots along the south side of Sunset Drive. The question was raised as to whether our Ordinance governing overgrown and unkept lots was adequate and that it should be reviewed and revised, if necessary. A discussion was had about Planning Board procedure in hearing applications and improving communications with the City Council. A discussion was had about Melaleuca trees being replaced, not just removed. There being no further business to come before the Board, the meeting was, upon Motion duly made and seconded, adjourned at 10:45 P. M. Page 7 - 9/24/74 jk PIANNING ADVISORY BOARD HEARING: # 7 DATE: TAME ADDRESS f Ile, P 3 B 100-22 CORAL GABLES TIMES. Published Bi -Weekly in Coral Gables , 'Dade County , Florida State of Florida COUNTY OF DADS Before the undersigned authority personally appeared lano who , on oath , says that she is the Manager of Accounts of Coral Gables Times., a bi -weekly newspaper , published at Coral Gables in Dade County, Florida ; that the attached copy of advertisement , being a Legal Adver tisement or Notice in the matter of public Nearing on September 24 1974 ,was published in said newspaper in the issues of: September' 8, 1974. Affiant further says that the said Coral Gables Times is a newspaper published at Coral Gables , in said Dade County., Florida , and that said newspaper had heretofore been continuously published in said Dade County , Florida , and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post office in Miami , in said Dade County , Florida , and for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of,_.the attached copy of adver- tisement; and affiant further says that she has neither paid nor promised any person , firm, or corporation any discount , rebate , commission or refuse for the purpose -of securing this advertisement for publication in said newspaper. Sworn to and subscribed before me this da of A. D. , 19W. Notilry Public State of Florida at Large SEAL) NOTARY PU11 C STATE OF FLORIDA AT LARGI My commission expires Mt COMMISSION EXPIRle MAR 19 19'7 ED THRU GENERAL INSURANCE.UNDERWRITERS amc 11/73 �;ak# :^dEGY11�KiTiCf4s M'^*� tMn.�1•�jd6eLue.�la`1�nOn �0••ri,ay.t.s•.fi'r, ,,fi•ri4 stria, ... mswa fork.;S"", i•m7,�!Tutrla):'f.�=` Nm1n21,'1071x1']90?�.'aasx.usru}- ' '-br n;pars,..31i._Iida;hr_iti•pria•+t",. .ti••rut n•n•fif•r•rsti�•nab w lbfik. 1t••ri•�SAY-20ij3Yir1.71•�•+�t•e.nr1•* ' 1•M:M.di••a 1�,reil s•••tr•etiu it:di►.4 tt•t•p•lf n.iN•a••••utt•,s 1:1 wild 1t!rb'} IM's w,IM.'L:sN N•e`ri,ti•e'Ltts,)I•aia: surlEw � aT :t.aw.a=s16t s :' Ik.Aig!73!M I3itrlq#•r•ylwntr J�.taaii lrmiA•ea•a.*�wtaK.l.t�)ddb.a"s�s ,- _. .7y0IM I&VwL'tna MsaVti:CL•I1R''�I/ii - - - :ASUVIEWtsoL,t!017f/sO.+Laii.�57s�'f �l••riq'!lT4i5 �,ti�'ti•ekifl n rq«rt'M �t:-s'{iMf7_als•a,sirefatj:'1.�ilJncr7/tiM`s: t't__isff l s:31�s0,21i a'fYt,'SbA`.1�:fi01111�tE iF RA0[IIIS' luriq EIt3Sliit. ea r 1 Af 44(il�lilpt y s Or w,rM p•al.re'M.giits.a,.S'Tr.etas—a(sf.�• _ f+ )»aiSn:rws.aw•rctfj L.salli" �.ryt„uuata;%ti,Si..•11t,Ilse �IIE lF t,ISmIS two•lf:if1,Y15"7W�fli .rt.s�aati�rl.•.i..a:ilrt•u..f.. �.nl.i•rnnuo:ri�t+�Slt,tsi'SA:-fL dz•(1tpiN SI.fL rgtni)1ir ta,M'1)' nsiinew Ly�•10•t li lit si,tl.ei ;. 10LI11W f00i1YMM r�1insS1!{ .Jlas' Z s . 4 Sept. 1974 RR: Lots 13, 14, 15, 16 & 17 Blk. 8, Townsite of Larkin; change of zoning request Ralph, H. Coker, Jr. . Please be advised that as a property owner within the 500 ft. v:i?cinity of said lots; I fully concur with the requested zoning changes. Furthermore, I believe said changes will be an asset to the area, already short of such zoned use. Walter A. Mobley MOBL EY ENTtRPRI&ES X300 RICE STREET#q. �,:� -�� ' " ""`�°• --.� P. 0 BOX 330451 a '�T SamuelAdams MIAMI, FLA. 33133 as /C Y U 80 Mr. Harvey Pierce, Chairman City of South Miami Planning )3 oard 6130 Sunset Drive South Miami, Florida 33143 t T H E C I T Y O F s AWN ff o u d 4-I t iam i 61$0 SUNSET DRIVE, SOUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA 85149 PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT September 4, 1974 The Coral Gables Times-Guide P. O. Box '580 Coral Gables, Florida 33134 Gentlemen: Please advertise the following legal notice, one time only, on Sunday, September 8, 1974, and may we please have proof of publication with your invoice. Yours very truly, W. E. Godwin Director of Public Works LEGAL NOTICE There will be a public hearing before the Planning Board, City of South. Miami, Florida, City Hall, 6130 Sunset Drive, South Miami, on Tuesday, September 24, 1974 at 7:30 P. M. , or as soon thereafter as appears on the Agenda, for the purpose- of--hearing views of interested persons, on the following: Hearing #k72-20 by Shirley Homes, Inc. on request for variance to permit construction `of single family residence on existing lot which is only 40 feet in width. Legal Description: Lot 12, Block 1, SEAVIEW PARK, PB 17/80. Location: 5751 S. W. 84 Street. Hearing #72-21 by Shirley Homes, Inc. on request for variance to permit construction of single . family residence on existing lot which is only 40 feet in width. Legal Description: Lot 16, Block 2, SEAVIEW PARK, PB 17/80. Location: 5780 S. W. 84 Street. „CITY OF PLEASANT LIVING" The Coral Gables Times-Guide September 4, 1974 Page 2 Hearing #74-15 by T. R. Crockett on request for change of zoning from RS-4 (Single Family) to C-3 (Arterial Commercial) . Legal Description: Lots 18, . 19, 20, 21 and 22, Block 8, TOWNSITE OF LARKINS. Location: 5825 S. W. 68th Street. Hearing #74-16 by Ralph H. Coker, Jr. on request for change of zoning from RS-4 (Single Family) to C-3 (Arterial Commercial) . Legal Description: Lots 13, 14, 15, 16 and 17, Block 8, TOWNSITE OF LARKINS. Location: 5845 S. W. 68th Street. Hearing #74-17 by Anselmo L. Alliegro on request for variance to permit a 8,237 Sq. Ft. lot size (10,000 Sq. Ft. required) for single family residence. Legal Description: Lot 14, Block 1, SOLIMAR SUBDIVISION. Location: 4899 Ludlam Road.. J` CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI PLANNING BOARD NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Hearing: #k74-16 Date: September 24 , 1974 . Time: 7:30 P. M. Applicant: Ralph H. Coker, Jr. Request: Change of zoning from RS-4 (Single Family) to C-3 (Arterial Commercial) Legal Description: Lots . 13, 14, 15, 16 and 17 Block 8, Townsite of Larkins . Location: 5845 S.W. 68th St. PUBLIC HEARING WILL BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS AT THE CITY HALL, 6130 SUNSET DRIVE, SOUTH MIAM19 FLORIDA, AT THE TIME AND DATE STATED ABOVE. ALL INTERESTED PARTIES ARE URGED TO ATTEND. OBJECTIONS OR EXPRESSIONS .OF APPROVAL MAY BE MADE IN PERSON AT THE HEARING OR FILED IN WRITING PRIOR TO OR AT THE HEARING. THE BOARD RESERVES THE RdGHT TO RECOMMEND TO THE CITY COUNCIL WHATEVER THE BOARD CONSIDERS IN THE BEST INTEREST FOR THE AREA INVOLVED. THE BOARDIS RECOMMENDATION ON THIS MATTER WILL BE HEARD BY THE CITY COUNCIL AT A FUTURE DATE. INTERESTED PARTIES REQUESTING INFORMATION ARE ASKED TO CONTACT THE OFFICE OF THE ZONING DIRECTOR BY CALLING 667-5691 OR BY WRITING. REFER TO HEARING NUMBER WHEN MAKING INQUIRY. HARVEY PIERCE, CHAIRMAN PLANNING BOARD PS B 100-7 THIS IS A COURTESY NOTICE - NOT REQUIRED BY LAW REV, 10-22-70 '! ORGANIZATION OF THE PLANNING BOARD UNDER THE CODE OF ORDINANCES OF THE CITYt THE PLANNING BOARD ACTS ONLY AS A RECOM- MENDING OR ADVISORY BODY TO THE CITY COUNCIL. THE ACTIONS OF THE BOARD ARE SUBJECT TO THE FINAL APPROVAL OF THE CITY COUNCIL. ALL MEETINGS OF THE BOARD ARE OPEN TO THE PUBLIC AND FOUR MEMBERS PRESENT CONSTITUTES A QUORUM. THE BOARD IS REQUIRED TO TAKE MINUTES OF ITS PROCEEDINGS AND THE VOTE OF EACH MEMBER IS RECORDED. THE PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE PLANNING BOARD IS A COURTESY PUBLIC HEARING FOR WHICH NO NOTIFICATION OR LEGAL ADVERTISEMENT IS REQUIRED. AS A MATTER OF CITY POLICY, NOTICES ARE MAILED TO AFFECTED PROPERTY OWNERS WITHIN A 500 FOOT RADIUS OF THE PROP- . ERTY UNDER CONSIDERATION AT THE PLANNING BOARD HEARING. COURTESY SIGNS ARE POSTED ON THE PROPERTY UNDER CONSIDERATION FOR A 15 DAY PERIOD PRIOR TO THE ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL AND THE COURTESY PUBLIC HEAR- ! ING BEFORE THE PLANNING BOARD. 589.0 SFs60 SSS 58.4 - 5834 Sg3o 5820 58/O f 5903 5ft7 v C— 5902. Sg9 58£f8 J`87g 568 � � � '� 590¢ Ste! 58E7� '8886 X70 P ■■�� 5906 S 5872 �; s� 0 5874 R?6 x zS>� zS' 26' 35 j . K l0 it i2 /3 14 /5 /6 /7 /8 19 20 21 A2 23 24 26 26 S 4/ 9 5 915 7 5 7 S 84 5 2 S /3 D 5 96 S 7 S 7,2 5858 S 6 5 0 57 5860 S%�2 lr 6 S838, �� k, \3,- Of ol Nil 1 , APPLICANT: ALF' N C`� COY. �i , J R OWNER: STA'T' i' ii - MAP REFERENCE: F V=I C.l L.- ,�� f LA S , Compass COMMENTS: HANGS QF" HoNjNca FROM Scale.� .- 16)(9 . Date. . ( l j rt A 1t Drn.�. .Chk W �G CITY of SOU 1 H N�lAMI ~ PLANNING 50A RD Fearing N0.44:.�6 r !r CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI PLANNING BOARD NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Hearing: 474-16 Date: September 24, 1974 . Time: 7:30 P. M. Applicant: Ralph H. Coker, Jr. . Request: Change of zoning from RS-4 (Single Family) to c--3 ( C-3 (Arterial Commercial) Legal Description: Lots 13, 14, 15, 16, and 17 Block 8, Townsite of Larkins . Location: 5845 S.W. 68th St. PUBLIC HEARING WILL BE HELD IN THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS AT THE CITY HALL, 6130 SUNSET DRIVE, SOUTH - MIAMI, FLORIDA, AT THE TIME AND DATE STATED ABOVE. - ALL INTERESTED PARTIES.ARE URGED TO ATTEND. OBJECTIONS OR EXPRESSIONS ,OF APPROVAL MAY BE MADE IN PERSON AT THE HEARING OR FILED IN WRITING PRIOR TO OR AT THE HEARING. THE BOARD RESERVES THE RIGHT TO RECOMMEND TO THE CITY COUNCIL WHATEVER THE BOARD CONSIDERS IN THE BEST INTEREST FOR THE AREA INVOLVED. THE BOARDIS RECOMMENDATION ON THIS MATTER WILL BE HEARD BY THE CITY COUNCIL AT A FUTURE DATE. INTERESTED PARTIES REQUESTING INFORMATION ARE ASKED TO CONTACT THE OFFICE OF THE ZONING DIRECTOR BY CALLING 667-5691 OR BY WRITING. REFER TO HEARING NUMBER WHEN MAKING INQUIRY. HARVEY PIERCE, CHAIRMAN PLANNING BOARD THIS IS A COURTESY NOTICE - NOT REQUIRED BY LAW PS B 100-7 REV. 10-22-70 ORGANIZATION OF THE PLANNING BOARD UNDER THE CODE OF ORDINANCES OF THE CITYt THE PLANNING BOARD ACTS ONLY AS A RECOM- MENDING OR ADVISORY BODY TO THE CITY COUNCIL. THE ACTIONS OF THE BOARD ARE SUBJECT TO THE FINAL APPROVAL OF THE CITY COUNCIL. ALL MEETINGS OF THE BOARD ARE OPEN TO THE PUBLIC AND FOUR MEMBERS PRESENT CONSTITUTES A QUORUM. THE BOARD IS REQUIRED TO TAKE MINUTES OF ITS PROCEEDINGS AND THE VOTE OF EACH MEMBER IS RECORDED. THE PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE PLANNING BOARD 15 A COURTESY PUBLIC HEARING FOR WHICH NO NOTIFICATION OR LEGAL ADVERTISEMENT IS REQUIRED. AS A MATTER OF CITY POLICY9 NOTICES ARE MAILED TO AFFECTED PROPERTY OWNERS WITHIN A 500 FOOT RADIUS OF THE PROP- ERTY UNDER CONSIDERATION AT THE PLANNING BOARD HEARING.. COURTESY SIGNS ARE POSTED ON THE PROPERTY UNDER CONSIDERATION FOR A 15 DAY PERIOD PRIOR TO THE ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL AND THE COURTESY PUBLIC HEAR- ING BEFORE THE PLANNING BOARD. .2 I S9o� 58'x' 585&' 5890 5880 s�o 585 584 8 SS34 �g30 5820 58/O l 3 Qo. G/ 'P 5905 50 S.�o7 58ri ° 58$/ 587/ 59 oz x'89 5888 5878 5868 P� 590¢ 559 588! 51600 597<2 5'906 S 5872 S8 0 587.4 76 is' as' 26' 25 25 _17 L.S__/_9 20._21 a.2....23, 24 .25 2fo Pki S-P011 91,6 583 5 D S 96 S 7� 5 0 57 5860 5Ima v 58'64 �a VA ZI s APPLICANT-: R AL.-P H C C'i� , J.F2_.d _ OWNER: S-rAT F c;,r- A t-P A MAP-REFERENCE:, OPFi c-i ... A-xL-r?4.5 . Compass COMMENTS : C MANGE c F z:.ON i. N(33 FROM RS- 4- Scale ./ .= AOO./. . . To C. Date . . Drn .�.-t. .Chk W f? CI 1 Y OF SOU 1 H MIAMI ow PLANNING 150A RD Hearing No.;4-.16 V � 1 1 I r M -7 ;--- -- -__- _ _ F 1 a3` c`Qw,_.. • �.. r i —,! I' Y �3 se ZD 7n�. .. e�7 3 0,97 FiE CITY OF r 0"t4 4'lwiami 6190 SUNSET DRIVE, SOUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA 38143 PUBLIC SERVICE DEPARTMENT Z O N I N G P E T I T I O N Property Description, Location and Legal : �eP Si=ec: p Request : The Owners of the above property have made the following request : 7-0 Petition: We, the undersigned property owners, are within 300 feet of the above property. We understand and approve the above request . NAME DATE ADDRESS - - - -�� - - - --- ='z = -� � _ ,- -fig- - - r - - - - - - T ' - -- - - - - - - - -- - - - _ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _ _ '-� i core - - �� - - - - - - - - - ® - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _ . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - PW50-37 (continued on page 2) Page 1