Loading...
1313 1 2 ORDINANCE NO. _____ _ 3 4 An Ordinance amending Section 20-4.2 of the City of South Miami's Land 5 Development Code to add criteria for the City's approval of the subdivision of land, 6 inclnding subdivision by a waiver of plat or through the process set forth in Chapter 7 28 of the Miami-Dade County Code. 8 9 WHEREAS, Section 20-4.2 of the City's Land Development Code provides for the process of 10 subdividing parcels ofland in the City of South Miami; and 11 12 WHEREAS, Section 20-4.2 defers to the Miami-Dade County platting process of Chapter 28 of 13 the Miami-Dade County Code of Ordinances; and 14 15 WHEREAS, Miami-Dade County platting ordinance requires that a tentative plat must be 16 approved by the City of South Miami before it can obtain final County plat approval; and 17 18 WHEREAS, Section 20-4.2 does not provide any criteria for the approval of a plat that has been 19 tentatively approved by the Miami-Dade County platting division; and 20 21 WHEREAS, this proposed amendment to section 20-4.2 will have been presented to the 22 Planning Board before second reading of this ordinance and the board's recommendation will be attached 23 as backup for second reading; and 24 25 WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Commissioners of the City of South Miami desire to enact 26 criterial for the approval of a plat that has been tentatively approved by the Miami-Dade County platting 27 division. 28 29 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION 30 OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA: 31 32 Section 1. Section 20-4.2, "Land subdivision regulations," is hereby amended to read as follows: 33 Section 20-4.2 Land subdivision regnlations. 34 35 (A) Applicable Regulations. The subdivision of all land within the city shall be subject to 36 Chapter 28 of the Miami-Dade County Code of Ordinances and administered by the Miami-Dade 37 County Department of Public Works. However. waivers of plat, tentative plats, and final plats 38 must also be approved by the City Commission and meet the requirements of Subsections (B) and 39 (B) (I), (2), (3). and (4) of this Section as set forth below. 40 (B) Platted Lot Compliance. Every building or structure hereafter erected, moved or 41 structurally altered within the city shall be located on a platted lot, except that the <;::sity 42 <;::sommission may waive platted lot compliance in accordance with section 28-4 of the County 43 Code and the procedures set forth below. 44 (I) Waiver of Plat A waiver of plat may be approves By the City Commission. 45 46 (I) Review and Notice. Prior to City Commission approval, the application for any 47 subdivision approval shall be reviewed by the Planning Board. The sllbjeet property shall Be 48 posted ten (10) days prior to the Planning Board review of the applieation, and mailes notiee shall 49 Be provides to all property owners within a five hnnsres (500) foot rasins of the snbjeet property. 50 At least ten (10) days prior to the City's Planning Board review of the application for waiver of 51 plat. tentative or final plat. the subject pIQPerty shall be posted by the Planning Department, with 52 a notice ofthe date. time and place of the Planning Board meeting, on the subject property Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 fronting all roadways that abut the property, and published. In addition, 10 days prior to the meeting of the City Commission to consider either a waiver of plat, or tentative or final plat approved in accordance with Chapter 28and this section, notice of the date, time and place of the City Commission meeting shall be posted (in the same manner as required above for a Planning Board review), published, and provided by U.S. Mail to all property owners within a-five hundred (500) feet fflffitts-ofthe perimeter of the subject property. (2) City Commission Findings. Prior to approving a waiver-of-plat, tentative or final plat, the ~eity ~eommission shall use the following guidelines: (a) The building site created by the proposed waiver-of-plat, tentative or final plat, will be equal to or larger than the majority median ofthe existing building sites and of the same character as the surrounding area (this shall be demonstrated using copies of the official plat maps for the subject property and surrounding neighborhood). Surrounding area is defined as all lots within the same zoning district and within five hundred (500) feet from the perimeter of the subject property. In addition, the lot frontage and net lot area ofthe building site(s) created shall be not less than the median of the lot frontage and net lot area of lots within the same zoning district and within five hundred (500) feet of the perimeter of the subject property and which shall exclude the applicant's proposed building site(s), to be created. No building site shall be diminished such that the street frontage and net lot area of the parcel is less than prescribed by the City's land development regulations, or is actually existing on the same block face as the subject property, if expressly pennitted by the City Commission as part of the waiver-of-plat, tentative or final plat. (b) The building site created by the proposed waiver-of-plat, tentative or final plat, will not result in existing structures becoming nonconforming as they relate to setbacks, lot area, lot width and depth, ground coverage and other applicable regulations of these land development regulations and/or City's Code of Ordinances. ( c) The building site created by the proposed waiver-of-plat, tentative or final plat, will bc free of encroachmcnts from abutting buildable sites. (d) The building site created by the proposed waiver-of-plat, tentative or final plat, is free of any declarations of restrictive covenants, unity of title, easements, or the like which would prevent the separation of the site. (eD Thc scale of any proposed new construction shall be compatible with the as-built character of the surrounding area, and shall not create adverse impacts on the surrounding area. (3) Additional Conditions. The e~ity e~ommission shall may-dcsignate such additional conditions in connection with a waiver-of-plat, tentative or final plat, as will, in its opinion; assure that such waiver-of-plat, tentativc or final plat, will conform to the foregoing requirements in this section. (a) Additional conditions shall ensure the rctcntion of specimen trees and fifty (50) percent of existing protected tree canopy (as provided for in the City's tree protection ordinance) on the subject property for a period of time to be determined by the City Commission in its sole discretion. (b) Miami-Dade County waivers of minimum septic tank standards shall not be granted by the ~ (c) In their review and recommendations, the Planning Department and Planning Board may recommend, and the City Commission may prescribe, conditions or safeguards restricting the square footage, orientation and location ofthe new structures to be built on the resulting lots, and for existing single family homes that qualify for designation under the criteria for historic preservation in the Land Development Code a referral to the Historic Preservation Board for consideration. All such conditions and safeguards shall be consistent with the purpose and intent of the City's Land Development Code and Comprehensive Plan. ('}4) Additional Application Requirements. As part of the required tentative or final plat or waiver-of-plat application, applicants shall be required to submit a proposed conceptual site plan for the reslIlting lmilsing Jlarsels, an e,listing tree sllr'iey (may be inslllses in JlroJlerty sllr'iey) whish shall insisate an)' JlroJloses tree removal or relosation Hesessary, aHs, if so, the aJlJlFOJlriate Page 2 of4 1 eit)' applieation for tree removal or reloeation drawn to scale, and indicating the following 2 information for the entire subject property'to be subdivided: 3 a. Building footprints, 4 b.Setbacks, yard requirements and easements. Future construction may deviate from the building 5 footprints shown on the conceptual plan, as long as the setbacks and yard requirements are in 6 accord with the Code existing at the time of such future construction. 7 c. A certified tree survey overlaid directly upon the site plan, and indicating the location, 8 referenced to structures, of all trees meeting the dimensions set forth in Section 20-4.5. The 9 survey shall distinguish the existing trees proposed to be destroyed, relocated, replaced, preserved 10 at their present location, or introduced into the development from an off-site source. All trees 11 shall be identified by variety, trunk circumference and height. Once an application for a waiver 12 of plat or tentative plat is filed, a moratorium is placed on tree removal until after final waiver-of- 13 plat or final plat approval is issued. 14 d. No final certificate of occupancy shall be issued nor electrical power cut-in authorization 15 given until the relocation or replacement of trees, as required by the tree removal permit has been 16 completed, and the final tree inspection approval by the City. Trees relocated from one portion of 17 the site to another, which do not survive transplantation, shall be replaced with a suitable 18 replacement tree, as determined by City staff. 19 e. No variances shall be allowed on subdivided lots, regardless of whether such lots are created 20 by waiver-of-plat or replat. 21 22 (C) Improvements Required. 23 (I) Sidewalks, curbs, gutters, drainage and paving shall be installed by the developer in 24 accordance with Chapter 28 of the County Code and other applicable city requirements, unless 25 such can be and are waived or deferred by the city commission. 26 (2) No building shall be erected, improved, modified, altered or enlarged in any zoning use 27 district, other than in an RS residential district, unless proper public improvements have been 28 installed. 29 (D) Crealien &jAutheri£cd Suilding Sites. 30 (I) }!o bllilding permit for tile eonstrlletion of any stmetllfe witHin tHe eity SHall be isslled 31 llntil an alltHorized bllilding site Has been ereated whieH meets at least one (I) of tHe following 32 eriteria: 33 (a) Is part ofa reeorded sllbdivision plat; 34 (B) Is part of an offieially approved planned unit development wHieH: 35 i. Provides for all utility and drainage easements, alleys, streets and otHer pllblie 36 improvements neeessary to meet tHe normal re~llirements for "Iaaing, and 37 ii. Inellldes tHe designation ofBllilding areas and easements, alleys and streets re~llired and 38 properly dedieated, and neeessary pllblie improvements; or 39 (e) Fronts llpon a dedieated pllBlie street and was separately owned prior to the effoeti"e date 40 of tHis Code or annellation to tile eity; 41 (2) Vihere"er there ellists a single family dwelling llnit wHieH was eonstmeted on a Bllilding 42 site eontaining two (2) or more platted lots, tHe noneollforming lot ofreeord provisions in tHis 43 Code SHall apply. 44 (3) EstabliSHed Bllilding sites SHall not Be reslleed ill allY manner to a size 'Nilieh is less than 45 that re~llired for tHe zoning sistriet in wilieh loeated. 46 47 Section 2, Codification. The provisions of this ordinance shall become and be made part of the 48 Land Development Code of the City of South Miami as amended; that the sections of this ordinance may 49 be renumbered or re-lettered to accomplish such intention; and that the word "ordinance" may be changed 50 to "section" or other appropriate word. 51 52 Section 3, Severability, If any section, clause, sentence, or phrase of this ordinance is for any 53 reason held invalid or unconstitutional by a court of competent jurisdiction, this holding shall not affect 54 the validity of the remaining portions of this ordinance. Page 3 of 4 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Section 4. Ordinances in Conflict. All ordinances or parts of ordinances and all sections and parts of sections of ordinances in direct conflict herewith are hereby repealed. Section 5. Effective Date. This ordinance shall become effective upon enactment. PASSED AND ENACTED this __ day of ATTEST: CITY CLERK 1" Reading 2,d Reading 3'd Reading READ AND APPROVED AS TO FORM: LANGUAGE, LEGALITY AND EXECUTION THEREOF CITY ATTORNEY Page 4 of 4 ___ ,2016. APPROVED: MAYOR COMMISSION VOTE: Mayor Stoddard: Vice Mayor Welsh: Commissioner Edmond: Commissioner Liebman: Commissioner Harris: 1 2 ORDINANCE NO. _____ _ 3 4 An Urilinance amending Section 20-4.2 of the City of South Miami's Land 5 Development Code to add criteria for the City's approval of tbe subdivision of land, 6 including subdivision by a waiver of plat or tbrougb tbe process set fortb in Cbapter 7 28 ofthe Miami-Dade County Code. 8 9 WHEREAS, Section 20-4.2 of the City's Land Development Code provides for the process of 10 subdividing parcels of land in the City of South Miami; and 11 12 WHEREAS, Section 20-4.2 defers to the Miami-Dade County platting process of Chapter 28 of 13 the Miami-Dade County Code of Ordinances; and 14 15 WHEREAS, Miami-Dade County platting ordinance requires that a tentative plat must be 16 approved by the City of South Miami before it can obtain final County plat approval; and 17 18 WHEREAS, Section 20-4.2 does not provide any 6riteria icr iter ia for the approval of a plat that 19 has been tentatively approved by the Miami-Dade County platting division; and 20 21 WHEREAS, this proposed amendment to section 20-4.2 will have been presented to the 22 Planning Board before second reading of this ordinance and the board's recommendation will be attached 23 as backup for second reading; and 24 25 WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Commissioners of the City of South Miami desire to enact 26 criterial for the approval of a plat that has been tentatively approved by the Miami-Dade County platting 27 division. 28 29 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION 30 OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA: 31 32 Section 1. Section 20-4.2, "Land subdivision regulations," is hereby amended to read as follows: 33 Section 20-4.2 Land subdivision regulations. 34 35 (A) Applicable Regulations. The subdivision of all land within the city shall be subject to 36 Chapter 28 of the Miami-Dade County Code of Ordinances and administered by the Miami-Dade 37 County Department of Public Works. However. waivers of plat. tentative plats. and final plats 38 must also be approved by the City Commission and meet the requirements of Subsections (8) and 39 (B) (I). (2). (3). and (4) of this Section as set forth below. 40 (B) Platted Lot Compliance. Every building or structure hereafter erected, moved or 41 structurally altered within the city shall be located on a platted lot, except that the ~eity 42 ~eommission may waive platted lot compliance in accordance with section 28-4 of the County 43 Code and the procedures set forth below. 44 (I) Wai",er ef Pial A wai"er ef Illal m~'be allllre"eaby Iha Cit)' Cemmissien. 45 46 (I) Review and Notice. Prior to City Commission approval, the application for any 47 subdivision approval shall be reviewed by the Planning Board. The suBjecI Ilrellerty shall be 48 lleSlea len (W) a~'s Ilrier Ie Iha Planning Beara ra",iaw eflhe Blllllicalien, ana mailea neliee shBII 49 Be Ilre"iaea Ie all Ilr91lerty ewners '",ilhin a fh 'a hunarea (5()()) feel raaius eflhe j3 erimeteHJf. Rsvise<i-&er~ Page I of 4 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 the sHbjeet propeR]'. At least ten (10) days prior to the City's Planning Board review of the application for waiver of plat. tentative or final plat, the subject property shall be posted by the Planning Department, with a notice of the date, time and place of the Planning Board meeting, on the subject property fronting all roadways that abut the property, and published. In addition, 10 days prior to the meeting of the City Commission to consider either a waiver of plat. or tentative or final plat approved in accordance with Chapter 28and this section, notice of the date, time and place of the City Commission meeting shall be posted (in the same manner as required above for a Planning Board review), published, and provided by U.S. Mail to all property owners within a- five hundred (500) feet radius of the perimeter of the subject property. (2) City Commission Findings. Prior to approving a waiver-:of-:plat, tentative or final plat, the l::eity l::eommission shall use the following guidelines: (a) The building site created by the proposed waiver-of-plat, tentative or final plat. -will be equal to or larger than the majori~' averagemedian of the existing building sites and of the same character as the surrounding area (this shall be demonstrated using copies of the official plat maps for the subject property and surrounding neighborhood). Surrounding area is defined as all lots within the same zoning district and within a radius of five hundred (500) feet from the perimeter of the subject property. In addition, the lot frontage and net lot area of the building site(s) created shall be not less than the averagemed ian of the lot frontage and net lot area of lots within the same zoning district and within a-five hundred (500) foot radiusfeet of the perimeter of the subject property and which shall exclude the applicant's proposed building site(s), to be created. No building site shall be diminished such that the street frontage and net lot area of the parcel is less than prescribed by the City's land development regulations , or is actua ll y existing on the sa me b lock face as the sub ject property, if expressly permitted by the City Commission as part of the waiver-of-p lat. tentative or final plat. (b) The building site created by the proposed waiver-of-plat, tentative or final plat. will not result in existing structures becoming nonconforming as they relate to setbacks , lot area, lot width and depth, ground coverage and other appl icable regulations of these land development regulations and/or City's Code of Ordinances. The voluntary demolition ofa strueture whieh e liminates any of the eonditions identified in this eriterion shall not eonstitute or result in eomplianee with this eriterion UHless the demolition or removal oeeurred more than four (4) years arior to the applieation for a waiver of plat. (c) The building site created by the proposed waiver-of-plat, tentative or final plat, will be free of encroachments from abutting buildable sites. (d) The building site created by the proposed waiver-of-plat, tentative or final plat, is free of any declarations of restrictive covenants, unity oftitle, easements, or the like which would prevent the separation of the site. (e) The proposed building site maintains and preserves open spaee as required by the _£able LOon ing distriet, promotes neighborhood eompatibility, preserves hi storie eharaeter, and eHhanees visual attraetiveness of the area. Ef(e ) The scale of any proposed new construction shall be compatible with the as-built character of the surrounding area, and shall not create adverse impacts on the surrounding area . (3) Additional Conditions. The el::ity el::ommission shall rnay-designate such additional conditions in connection with a waiver-of-plat. tentative or final plat, as will, in its opinion ,,; assure that such waiver-of-plat, tentative or final plat. will conform to the foregoing requirements in this section. (a) Additional conditions shall ensure the retention of specimen trees and eanop)' on sub jeet property and shall ensure adherenee to minimum wning code standardsfifty (50) percent of ex ist in g protected tree ca nopy (as provided for in the C ity's tree protection o rdinan ce) on the Re"i se d Sept. 2 0 20 15 Page 2 of 4 I 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 I I 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 s ubj ec t pro pe rty for a pe ri od o f tim e t o be d ete rmin ed by th e C ity Co mmi ss ion in its so le di sc re t ion . Ib) Miami-Dade County waivers of minimum septic tank standards shall not be granted by the Q!L Ic) In their review and recommendations, the Planning Department and Planning Board may recommend, and the City Commission may prescribe, conditions or safeguards restricting the overall s izesguare foota ge , orientation and location of the new structures to be built on the resulting lots, and r e quire p r eser v ati o n o ffor existing single family homes that qualify for designation under the criteria for historic preservation in the Land Development Code, a r e ferra l to th e Hi storic Preserv ation B oard fo r co ns id e rati o n . All such conditions and safeguards shall be consistent with the purpose and intent of the City's Land Development Code and Comprehensive Plan. I~) Additional Application Requirements. As part of the required tentative or final plat or waiver-of-plat application , applicants shall be required to submit a proposed s it e p lanco nce ptu a l s it e p la n H3F Ih e Fes HltiR g Imil s iR Il; paF ee ls, SR ex is liR g IF ee sHFv ey (m ay b e iR e lH ses iR prepeFe' sH",'ey) whi eh s ha ll iRsi eale BRy prepsses IFee Femsyal SF Fe lseali e R Reeessary, a Rs , ifss , t he- IWIllifflF ia le a il')' a pp li eslis R H3F IFee Fe m evsl eF Fe lsesti s R drawn to scale, and indicating the following information for the entire subject property to be subdivided: a . Loeati o n , s hap e and spati a l arrangement of a ll ellisting and prop0se6-9uil d ings, 'Nall s, improvem e nts and s true tures. a. Bui ldin g fo otpri nts, b. Loeati on, shape and spatia l arrangem e nt of all parking are a£-ftfl d-aeeess roailir. e . El(is ting and pro pose d utility serviees. d. Ellislin g and pro p ose d e l evati ons . &.-Setbacks, yard requirements and easements. e uture co n stru cti on m ay dev iate fro m th e .bui ldin g foot prints s hown on th e co n ce pt ual pla n, as lon g as the se tb ac ks a nd ya rd req uire me nts a re in acco rd with th e Co d e ex istin g at th e tim e of s uc h futur e co ns tructi on. f. Ellist i ng and proposed w e lls. g . A ll s ink h o l es, so lutio n h o les, roek o u teropp in gs and hi storieal s ites . h c , A certified tree survey overlaid directly upon the site plan, and indicating the location, referenced to structures, of all trees meeting the dimensions set forth in Section 20-4.5. The survey shall distinguish the existing trees proposed to be destroyed, relocated, replaced, preserved at their present location, or introduced into the development from an off-site source. All trees shall be identified by variety, trunk circumference and height. NeOn ce a n a pp li ca ti o n fo r a wa iver o f p lat o r tentat ive plat is fi le d , a mo ra torium is pla ced o n tree removal permit appl-iootion s shall b e s ubmitted t o the C ity an4-no t r ee removal p ermits s h a ll be issu eEl-by- the C i t y , until after final wai ve r-o r-p la t o r fina l plat approval, is iss ued . id . No final certificate of occupancy shall be issued nor electrical power cut-in authorization given until the relocation or replacement of trees, as required by the tree removal permit has been completed, and the final tree inspection approval by the City. Trees relocated from one portion of the site to another, which do not survive transplantation, shall be replaced with a suitable replacement tree, as determined by City staff. e. No va ri a nces s ha ll be a ll owed o n s ubdi v ide d lots, r ega rdl ess o f w he th er s uc h lots are created by wa ive r-o f-pl at o r re pl a t. (C) Improvements Required. (I) Sidewalks, curbs, gutters , drainage and paving shall be installed by the developer in accordance with Chapter 28 of the County Code and other applicable city requirements, unless such can be and are waived or deferred by the city commission. RtWi~ed-,';;el'l. 20 20 15 Page 3 of 4 I (2) No building shall be erected , improved, modified, altered or enlarged in any zoning use 2 district, other than in an RS residential district, unless proper public improvements have been 3 installed. 4 . (D) Creal;"" f!lAllth"F;~ed BII;I<ii"g Sites. 5 (I) 1>1e aHilaing ~ermil fer Ihe eeAstrHelieA efaAY strHelHre withiA Ihe eity shall ae issHea 6 HAlil aA aHtheri2ea aHilaiAg sile has aeeA erealea whieh meels alleast ene (I) efthe fellewiAg 7 erileria: 8 (a) Is ~art efa reeeraea sHaah'isien ~Ial; 9 (e) Is ~art efaA effieiall), a~~reyea ~laAAea HAil ae\'ele~meAI wRieR: 10 i. Pre"iaes fer all Hlilil)' aAa araiAage easemeAls, alle)'s , slreets aAa elher ~Halie II im~re·.'emenls Aeeessary Ie meet the Aermal reEjHiremeAls fer ~lattiAg, aAa 12 ii. InelHaes Ihe aesigAalieA ef aHilaiAg areas ana easemeAls, alleys aAa slreels reEjHirea aAa 13 ~re~erl)' aeaiealea, aAa neeessary ~Halie im~re'.'emeAls; er 14 (e) FreAls H~eA a aeaiealea ~Halie streel aAa was se~arale l)' ewnea ~rier Ie Ihe effeeli\'e aale IS ef Ihis Ceae er aAAe),atieA Ie the eil)'; 16 (2) WRereyer there e)(isls a siAgle fumily awelliAg HAil wRieR 'o\'as eenstFHelea eA a aHilaiAg 17 sile eenlaiAing !Yo'e (2) er mere ~Iattealets, Ihe AeneeAfurming lei efreeerEI ~re, .. isiens iA this 18 Ceae shall a~~ly. 19 (3) !lslaalisRea aHilaiAg siles shall Ael ae reaHeea iA aAY maAAer Ie a si2e ';,weR is le ss IRaA 20 Ihal reEjHirea fer Ihe 2eAiAg aistriel in whieh leeatea. 21 22 23 Section 2. Codification. The provisions of this ordinance sha ll become and be made part of th e 24 Land Development Code of the City of South Miami as amended; that the sections of this ordinance may 25 be renumbered or re-Iettered to accomplish such intention; and that the word "ordinance" may be changed 26 to "section" or other appropriate word. 27 28 Section 3, Severability. If any section , clause, sentence, or phrase of this ordinance is for any 29 reason held invalid or unconstitutional by a court of competent jurisdiction, this holding shall not affect 30 the validity of the remaining portions of this ordinance. 31 32 Section 4, Ordinances in Conflict, All ordinances or parts of ordinances and all sections and 33 parts of sections of ordinances in direct conflict herewith are hereby repealed. 34 35 Section 5, Effective Date, This ordinance sha ll become effective upon enactment. 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 PASSED AND ENACTED this __ day of _____ , 2016. ATTEST: CITY CLERK I" Reading 20d Reading 3'd Reading READ AND APPROVED AS TO FORM: LANGUAGE, LEGALITY AND lWises ~e~l. 29 29 15 Page 4 of4 APPROVED: MAYOR COMM ISSION VOTE: Mayor Stoddard: I 2 3 4 5 6 7 EXECU TI ON T HEREOF C IT Y A TIO RN EY I Re¥ised-Seph!()~ V ice Mayo r Harri s: Co mmi ssio ner Edm ond : Co mmi ss ioner Li eb ma n: ___ Co mm issio ner We ls h: Page 5 of 4