The URL can be used to link to this page

Res. No. 112-01-11260RESOLUTION NO:112-01-11260 A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI,FLORIDA,RELATING TO AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO NEGOTIATE HOURLY RATES AND TO EXECUTE PROFESSIONAL GENERAL ENGINEERING SERVICES AGREEMENTS WITH CONSULTING ENGINEERING AND SCIENCE,INC.,CORZO CASTELLA CARBALLO THOMPSON SALMAN,P.A.AND KIMLEY-HORN &ASSOCIATES,INC.AND PROVIDED THAT INDIVIDUALLY EXECUTED AGREEMENTS BE MADE A PART OF THIS RESOLUTION. WHEREAS,theCity Commission desiresto retain consultants toprovide ProfessionalGeneral Engineering Services;and WHEREAS,pursuant to Florida Statute287.055theCity published a Notice for Professional General Engineering Services and received atotal of fourteen (14) responses;and NOW,THEREFORE,BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI,FLORIDA: Section 1:That theCity Commission authorizes theCity Manager to negotiate andto execute three separate professionals services agreements with: •Consulting Engineering &Science,Inc. •Corzo Castella Carballo Thompson Salman,P.A. •Kimley-Horn &Associates,Inc. Section2:ThattheAgreementallowsforrenewal of anadditionalperiod of twoyearsat the City's option. Section3:ThatthenegotiatedProfessionalGeneralEngineeringServicesAgreementsbe made part of this resolution. PASSED AND ADOPTED this j^day of z^^,2001. ATTEST:APPROVED: :s: MAYOR CommissionVote:4_q READANDAPPROVEDASTOFORM:MayorRobaina:Yea CITY ATTORNEY Commissioner Bethel: Vice Mayor Feliu:q^.of town Yea Yea Commissioner Wiscombe:Yea CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI INTER-OFFICE MEMORANDUM To:Mayor and City Commission From:Charles D.Scurr City Manager Date:August 2,2000 AgendaItem#f Comm Mtg.08-07-01 Re:Consideration of Authorizing Contracts for Professional General Engineering Consultants REQUEST A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI,FLORIDA,RELATING TO AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO NEGOTIATE HOURLY RATES AND TO EXECUTE PROFESSIONAL GENERAL ENGINEERING SERVICES AGREEMENTS WITH CONSULTING ENGINEERING AND SCIENCE,INC.,CORZO CASTELLA CARBALLO THOMPSON SALMAN,P.A.AND KIMLEY-HORN &ASSOCIATES,INC.AND PROVIDED THAT INDIVIDUALLY EXECUTED AGREEMENTS BE MADE A PART OF THIS RESOLUTION. BACKGROUND: LastyeartheCityinitiatedaprocess of selectinga number of consultants under MiscellaneousProfessionalServicesAgreementsinfourdifferentprofessional categories.Selection of Engineeringconsultantsarerequiredtobedoneinaccordance withFloridaStatutes 287.055 (Consultants'Competitive Negotiation Act).Thesepre selected consultants will be used,as funding is made available,for miscellaneous projects,basiccost of whichdoesnotexceed$500,000oraplanningstudyactivityof whichthefeefor professional services doesnot exceed $25,000.The execution of these Miscellaneous Services Agreements nowaycommitstheCitvtoanv minimum amount of fees and or guarantees anv work. Withtherecentgrantsandlegislative appropriations receivedforprojects,suchasWater MainImprovements,Drainage&Roadway Improvements,itisessentialthatwesecure Professional Engineering Consultants inotherto immediately implement theprojectand meettheestablishedtimeindicatedinthefundingagreements. A total of fourteen (14)firms submitted for consideration.A committee consisting of Mr. W.Ajibola Balogun,Director of Engineering &Construction,Mr.Eduardo A.Vega, Miami-DadeCountyAssistantPublicWorksDirector,Mr.OrlandoMartinez,Public WorksDirectorandAssistantCityManagerSubrataBasu recommended thefollowing threefirms,listed alphabetically,forthiscontract: •Consulting Engineering &Science,Inc. •Corzo Castella Carballo Thompson Salman,P.A. •Kimley-Horn &Associates,Inc. The recommendation was based on the committee's review of the submitted information, Presentation &Interview of six(6)shortlistfinalistand telephone interview of references. Excerpts of theproposals of thethreefinalistsareattachedforyourinformation. RECOMMENDATION ItisrecommendedthattheCityManagerbeauthorizedtonegotiatehourlyratesand executethreeseparateagreementsforprofessionalgeneralengineeringservicesin accordancewiththeFloridaStatues287.055foraperiod of twoyears,withprovisionsto renew for two years. Attachments: List of Consultants considered Selection Committee Tally sheet (Information Review Shortlist) Selection Committee Tally sheet (Presentation &Interview) Proposed resolution Published Notice for Professional Service Excerpts of Proposals City of South Miami Professional General Engineering Services Consultant Selection Process Selection Committee Tally Sb •-♦(For Short List) Date:July 23,2001 Name of Firm Ranking by Committee Men.b—s Total Tie Breaker (if necessary Final Rank RemarksAjibolaB.Eduardo V.Orlando M.Subrata B. A&P Consulting Transportation 31 37 37 30 135 Calvin.Giordano &Associates 35 38 35 42 150 Cashin Associates P.C.26 38 35 35 134 Consul-Tech Engineering,Inc.30 41 35 35 141 Consulting Engineering &Science 36 40 43 45 164 Corradino 37 40 43 42 162 Corzo Castella Carballo...40 43 40 45 168 Gannett Fleming 34 40 39 42 155 HJ.Ross Associates,Inc.33 40 38 40 151 Kimley-Horn &Associates,Inc.37 43 41 43 164 Kunde Sprecher &Associates.Inc.31 40 37 40 148 Serraalto &Associates,Inc.27 41 38 40 146 URSCorporation 34 43 36 40 153 Williams,Hatfield &Stoner,Inc.391 42 35|43 159 City of South Miami Professional General Engineering Services Consultant Selection Process Selection Committee Tally Sheet (P...ation &Interview) Date:August 01,2001 Name of Firm Ranking by Committee Member^ Total Tie Breaker (if necessary)Final Rank RemarksAjibolaB.Eduardo V.Orlando M.So^.jta B. Consulting Engineering &Science 39 45 41 44 169 3 Corradino 39 42 37 35 153 Corzo Castella Carballo...45 4643 45 179 1 Gannett Fleming 38 43 42 33 156 Kimley-Horn &Associates,Inc.41 47 45 45 178 2 Williams,Hatfield &Stoner,Inc.36 43 44 30 153 i A 1 A&P CONSULTING TRANSPORTATION ENGNEERS 2 CALVIN,GIORDANO &ASSOCIATES,INC. 3 CASHIN ASSOCIATES P.C. 4 CONSUL-TECH ENGINEERING,INC 5 CONSULTING ENGINEERING &SCIENCE,INC 6 CORRADINO 7 CORZO CASTELLA CARBALLO THOMPSON SALMAN 8 GANNETT FLEMING 9 H.J.ROSS ASSOCIATES,INC 10 KIMLEY-HORN &ASSOCIATES,INC. 11 KUNDE SPRECHER &ASSOCITES,INC 12 SERRAALTO &ASSOCIATES,INC 13 URS CORPORATION 14 WILLIAMS,HATFIELD &STONER,INC. MIAMI DAILY BUSINESS REVIEW PublishedDaily except Saturday.Sunday and Legal Holidays Miami.Miami-Dade County.Florida STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE: Before the undersigned authority personally appeared O.V.FERBEYRE.who on oath says that she is the SUPERVISOR,Legal Notices of the MiamiDaily Business Review f/k/a Miami Review,adaily (except Saturday.Sunday and Leyal Holidays)newspaper,published at Miami in Miami-Dade County.Florida;thatthe attached copyof advertisement, beingaLegal Advertisement ofNoticeinthematterof CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI RFQ NO. PROFESSIONAL GENERAL ENGINEERING SERVICES in the XXXX Court. was published insaid newspaper in the issues of 07/02/2001 . Affiantfurther says that the said MiamiDaily Business Review isa newspaper published atMiamiin said Miami-Dade County.Floridaandthatthe said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published insaid Miami-Dade County. Florida,each day (except Saturday,Sunday andLegalHolidays) and has been entered as second class mail matter atthe post officeinMiamiinsaid Miami-Dade County,Florida,fora periodof one year next preceding thefirst publication of the attached copy of advertisement;and affiant further says that she has neither paidnor promised any person,firmor corporation any discount,rebate,corjQmission or refund lor the purpose of securiod/this advertisement for publication in the said newspaper./" Sworn to and subscribed before me this >LY .A.D. / 02 day -..,-,-oocv/dc hl,j.OFFICIAL NOTARYSEALO.V.FERBEYRE personally knowrj tome jaNETT LLERENA NOTARY PUBLICSTATEOFFLORIDA COMMISSION NO.CC912958 MY COMMISSION EXP.JUNE 23J20G-! CITYOFSOUTH MIAMI,FLORIDA REQUEST FOR LETTER OF INTEREST AND QUALIFICATION SOUTH MIAMI RFQ NO. PROFESSIONAL GENERAL ENGINEERINGSERVICES The City ol South Miami will receive letter of interest and qualifications for various future projects,per specifications and scopeof sen/ices,until 3:00pm.July 16.2001.Interested firms must submit qualification package tothe Office ofthe City Clerk.6130 Sunset Drive.South Miami.Florida 33143.Anyqualification package submitted pastthe deadline and/or sub mitted to other locations or offices shall be deemed non-responsive and willberejected. Pursuant toChapter 287.055,Florida Statutes,the City of South Miami will retain consultants to provide professional General Engineering Ser vices (Civil.Roadway.Drainage and Environmental)for miscellaneous city projects.In order to fulfill such needs and meet the requirements for quick response and specialized services,the City intends to retain three (3)-qualified firms.Each selected firm shall enter into an agreemert for e terr.,*..::..„September 30.2003.Only firms with similaexperienca an,* a proven track record ofdelivering successful/on time-on budget project.; areencouragedtoapply.Nominimumamountofsuchserviceorcom pensation will be assumed to any of the firms so retained,and the City shall notbe prevented inany manner from retaining other firms atitssole discretion. The general scope for the professional general engineering services as follows: a)Roadway Engineering to include streets,sidewalk,curb,gutter, drainage,associated traffic control devices,stripping,lighting! speed reduction devices and incidental landscaping. b)Drainage Design includes the necessary analysis needed to im plement proposed drainage improvements,preparation of paving and drainage plan lor municipal building and facilities. c)Civil Engineering,to include Distribution (Watermain)system anal ysisand design and Sanitary SewerSystem Evaluation andde sign. d)Environmental Engineering,to include,site investigation and de sign needed to prepare remediation plans to mitigate underground storagetanks,hazardouswaste materials andasbestos materi als. Tobeeligiblefor selection consideration,interested consultants must submit one (1)original andfour(4)copies ol the following information: 1)Name oflirm(s);specifyastotypeofcontractual agreement be tween firms,andcertificate(s)of authorization toofferprofessional services throughtheFlorida Department ofProfessionalRegula tions,asapplicable,fromprimeaswellassupporting lirms. 2)Proofof authorization to transact business in the State fromthe Florida SecretaryofState,fromprimeaswellassupporting firms. • 3)Proposed organization chartidentifyingkeyprofessionalsandtheir areaof responsibilities. 4)Appropriate current Federal 254and255 forms showing the firm's dataand supoonin$the firm's abilitytoperformeachcategoryof work requ:red.r cetera'!orm 254 isrequiredforbothprimeandsub consultant. 5)Listofrecentclientreferenceswithcontact names andtelephone numbers. For lurther information,interested parties may contact Mr.W.Ajibola Balogun.REM,Director of Engineering &Construction at 305.668.7354. Please be advised that the City of South Miami comply with Miami- Dade County's Cone of Silence ordinance.Requests lor any information must be made inwriting. Ronetta Taylor.CMC City Clerk 7/2 01-B-40/176979M Consulting Engineering Science,Inc. (Excerpts from Proposal) m DESCRIPTION OF THE FIRM Organized m 1981,Consulting Engineering &Science has grown to become a leading consulting engineering firm,servicing clients throughout Florida,the southeastern United States and the Caribbean.While initially established to render civil and environmental engineering services,the capabilities of the firm and its staff have expanded to cover the specialized fields ofstructural engineering and coastal engineering including hydrographic modeling and coastal structure design. The firm's assignments fall into three general categories:Environmental Services*Civil Engineering and Design;and,Coastal Engineering and Design.These encompass the preparation of Development of Regional Impact and Environmental Impact studies environmental permitting,Phase I and Phase II Environmental Site Assessments and Contamination Assessments,residential and commercial site development and docks marina and coastal structures.Our services include preparation of planning studies and reports;preparation of final drawings,specifications and other contract documents;and technical supervisionand inspection of construction.'' Our environmental services cover all aspects of the planning and implementation of environmental impact and assessment projects of all types.Our services include environmental surveying of both terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems,site selection and evaluation studies,corridor locations studies,impact assessment reports,environmental audits,air and noise impact analyses,development of regional impact reports hydroeraplue and dispersion modelling,water quality studies,mitiaation design and implementation,field monitoring during construction,post operational studies and community structure studies.CES provides expert witness testimony and representation at public hearings. CES also provides environmental permitting services.Over the years we have developed an agency awareness of the expertise which we bring to our projects.Our past projects have included submerged land leases from the Florida Department of Natural Resources and construction permits for dredge and fill,maintenance dredging wetlands restoration,dock and breakwater construction and beach nourishment from the Florida Department of Environmental Regulation,the U.S.Army Corps of Engineers and numerous local governments.Our staff is knowledgeable of local,State and Federal permitting requirements and we have a proven track record for working with the regulatory agencies to secure permit approvals. Our site development services range from initial planning and preliminary feasibility studies through final design,preparation of contract documents and construction services Our experience covers a variety of civil engineering related projects including streets' sidewalks,and parking lots;roads and bridges;stormwater management and system design;water supply,treatment and distribution;domestic and industrial wastewater collection,treatment and disposal;solid waste;and electrical supply and distribution As a result,we are able to provide a multi-discipline response to the specific needs and time constramts that are inherent to the land development business Thefirmhasdevelopeda particular expertise intheplanninganddesign of coastal and marinafacilities.These projectshaveincludedvarioustypes of shoreline revetments, seawalls,bulkheads and moorings;and,fullservicerecreationaland commercial marina facilities.Inthepastnineyears,wehavedesignedover 40,000 linearfeet of newand rehabilitatedseawallandover3,000marinaslipsincludingindividual facilities of 179, 196,246and340slips.Ourprojectshavealsoincludedspecialstructuresincludinga ferrydockingfacility,a17,000squarefootposttensionedplatformintheMiamiShipping Channelandafixedpedestrianpromenadeinwaterdepths of 40feet.Ourclientshave includedprivatedevelopers,localgovernments,the U.S.militaryandthe federal agency, U.S.Aid to Caribbean Nations. ConsultingEngineering&Sciencestressespersonalizedand efficient servicetoassurea maintenance of dialogue with our clientsand on-time completion and effective execution of each assignment. PROFESSIONAL SERVICES &CAPABILITIES MASTER PLANNING Site Selection and Analysis Physical Planning Feasibility Studies Facility Programming &Planning Zoning Analysis Urban Design ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Site Inventories Baseline Monitoring Programs Environmental Impact &Assessment Studies Development of Regional ImpactAnalysis Permit Procurement ComputerModeling Post Construction ComplianceMonitoring Phase I and Phase II Environmental Site Assessments &Contamination Assessments P*T-DESIGN SERVICES Program Analysis Establishment of Design Criteria Budget Establishment Survey of Existing Conditions ENGINEERING DESIGN Beach Nourishment Civil Engineering Coastal Engineering Drainage Design Structural Engineering UtilitySystems Design Traffic&Transportation Engineering Value Engineering CONSTRUCTION SERVICES CPM Scheduling &Control Cost Analysis Bidding&Negotiation of Contracts On Site Observation I5fe Corzo Castella Carballo Thompson Salman,P.A. (Excerpts from Proposal) ; MUNICIPAL.ENGINEERING SERVICES Sewers &Pump Stations Drainage &Stormwater Management Strategic Planning &Budgeting UtilityRate Studies Grant&SRF Loan Applications Comprehensive Plan Amendments Land Development Codes City Mapping Utility Design.Studies &Atlases Parking Facility Utilization Studies HIGHWAY ENGINEERING Arterial,Collector &Local Roads Signalization Plans TrafficEngineeringStudies Hydrology &Hydraulics Studies STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING Bridge Design Forensic Engineering Building Structures Industrial Structures Rehabilitation of Structures ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN Aviation Facilities &Master Planning ITS Airport Facilities Educational Facilities Governmental Facilities Parks &Recreational Facilities Space Planning &Interior Design Historical Preservation COASTAL ENGINEERING Public &Private Marinas Bulkhead &Seawall Rehabilitation Beach Reconstruction SITE DEVELOPMENT Economic Feasibility Studies Facility&Land Planning Water Management Studies Water Distribution Systems Pump Station Designs PROJECT &CONSTRUCTION SERVICES Highway &Bridge -C.E.I. Threshold Building Inspections Value Engineering Design/Build Fngineering Services ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING Water Treatment Facilities Septic Systems &Disposal EnvironmentalPermitting Mitigation Studies &Plans Water Supply Systems &Distribution FiveYearCapitalImprovementPlans FundingProgramConsultation Municipal Facility Designs Annexation Procedures &Studies Evaluation&AppraisalReports Zoning &Redevelopment Studies Plan Review Services Recreational Facilities &Lighting Corporate Services Pavement Markings &Signing Plans StreetLightingPlans Route Selection &Corridor Studies PD&H Studies Bridge Maintenance &Inspection Bridge Rehabilitation Foundation Design Waterfront Structures Commercial &Retail Facilities SeaportFacilities&Terminals Industrial Facilities FeasibilityStudies Urban&MasterPlanning ADA Compliance Studies Contract Administration &Purchasing Wind &Wave Studies Ship Repair &Storage Facilities Erosion Control EnvironmentalPermitting Grading.Paving&Drainage Design Canal&RetentionBasinDesign Wastewater Collection Systems RegionalImpactStatements(D.R.I.) Land Development Construction Materials 'Testing ConstructabilityReviews Geotechnical Engineering Waste Treatment Facilities Solid Waste Incinerators &Landfills Site Assessments &Remediation Plans Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plans MECHANICAL/ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING Mechanical Fngineering Plumbing Engineering Electrical Engineering Fire Protection Fngineering CORZO CASTELLA CARBALLO THOMPSON SALMAN,P.A. Engineers'Architects"Planners ™HE Governmental Clients Municipal Clients CityofCoconutCreek CityofCoral Gables CityofCoralSprings Cily ofFt.Lauderdale Cityof Hialeah CityofHialeahGardens CityofLauderhill Cityof Margate City ol"Miami CityofMiamiBeach CityofNorthMiami City of NorthMiamiBeach Cityof Opa-locka CityofPalmBeachGardens CityofPanamaCity CityofPembroke Pines CityofPlantation CityofSouthMiami Cityof West Miami TownofBayHarborIslands Town of Davie Town of Medley Villageof HI Portal VillageofKey Biscayne County Clients Broward County Aviation Department BrowardCountyParks&Recreation Miami-Dade Aviation Department Miami-Dade Parks &Recreation Miami-Dade Public Health Trust Miami-Dade Public School Board Miami-Dade Public Works Palm Beach County PalmBeach County SchoolBoard St.Lucie County State Clients Florida Atlantic University FloridaDepartmentofAgriculture Florida Department of Highway SafetyandMotorVehicles Florida Department ofManagement Services FloridaDepartmentofTransportation District I (Bartow) District II(LakeCity) DistrictIII (Chipley) District IV(Ft.Lauderdale) District V (DeLand) District VI (Miami) District VII (Tampa) FloridaHighwayPatrol Florida International University CORZO CASTELLA CARBALLO THOMPSON SALMAN,P.A. Engineers 'Architects"Planners ™EB Kimley-Horn and Associates,Inc. (Excerpts from Proposal) mam BSE33B pr o f e s s i o n a l m& W A / &n x j A A % e £ A i n x j / s e r v i c e s Ki m l e y - H o r n an d As s o c i a t e s Se r v i n g mu n i c i p a l cl i e n t s fo r ov e r 30 ye a r s Fu l l - s e r v i c e co n s u l t i n g fi r m Av a i l a b l e r e s o u r c e s fo r an y as s i g n m e n t Va r i e d , lo c a l ex p e r i e n c e wi t h pr o v e n tr a c k re c o r d Lo c a l o f f i c e o n l y mi n u t e s aw a y Lo c a l ex p e r i e n c e wi t h al l mu n i c i p a l is s u e s Ci t y o f So u t h Mi a m i ex p e r i e n c e an d As s o c i a t e s , In c . pr o f e s s i o n a l ' ^ w s t r ^ n c& e A V & w l / &l% O A A W e / l A A W : : ^ m * im " se r v i c e s . - * m m Fu l l - S e r v i c e Fi r m T o S e r v e Y o u * Ci v i l en g i n e e r i n g Co a s t a l en g i n e e r i n g l * ^ Ur b a n pl a n n i n g an d la n d s c a p e ar c h i t e c t u r e de s i g n St r e e t s c a p e de s i g n Tr a f f i c ca l m i n g Str u c t u r a l de s i g n an d an a l y s i s " J ^ r De v e l o p m e n t an d si t e pl a n n i n g E n v i r o n m e n t a l s e r v i c e s a n d pe r m i t t i n g W a t e r a n d wa s t e w a t e r s y s t e m Ro a d w a y d e s i g n St o r m w a t e r ma n a g e m e n t Ag e n c y co o r d i n a t i o n an d li a i s o n Gr a n t wr i t i n g Co n s t r u c t i o n ad m i n i s t r a t i o n an d ob s e r v a t i o n Pa r k s an d re c r e a t i o n fa c i l i t i e s Pl a n s re v i e w an d pe r m i t t i n g Tr a f f i c st u d i e s an d an a l y s i s Pu b l i c in v o l v e m e n t / C o m m u n i t y c o n s e n s u s P ^ M F I Kim l e y - H o r n ^ J •• ' * an d As s o c i a t e s , In c . Ar e a s of Ex p e r t i s e Ke y Pr o j e c t St a f f Ro d r i g o Pi g n a , P. E . Do u g Co p m e r , P. E . J o h n Po t t s , P. E . Ru s s e l l Ba r n e s , P. E . Ga r y Ra t a y , P. E . Da n Sh e p h e r d M i k e D a v i s We n d y Cy r i a c k s - G u z m a n Ju l i e O' N e a l , P. E . Mi k e Ki e f e r , E. l . Sc o t t Mi n g o n e t , AS L A , AI C P St e v e Le f t o n , A S L A , AI C P Mi k e Sp r u c e , P . E . Da v i d St e w a r t , P. E . To m Fa r n a n , P. E . Pa u l C h e r r y , P. E . St e v e Or r , CE T Al G a r c i a G l e n R i e s k e Aa r o n Bu c h l e r , P. E . Ju a n Ji m e n e z , P. E . Wa l t e r L u g o , E. l ir o c o <d o > - a : q Ke y Re s p o n s i b i l i t i e s £ Pr o j e c t M a n a g e r 13 Pr i n c i p a l - i n - C h a r g e QC / Q A 29 Wa t e r / Wa s t e w a t e r Sy s t e m s 14 Wa t e r / W a s t e w a t e r Sy s t e m s 14 Wa t e r / W a s t e w a t e r Sy s t e m s 32 St o r m w a t e r Sy s t e m s 27 E n v i r o n m e n t a l E n v i r o n m e n t a l E n v i r o n m e n t a l 1 7 La n d s c a p e / I r r i g a t i o n V La n d s c a p e / Ir r i g a t i o n St o r m w a t e r Sy s t e m s 9 S t r u c t u r a l 2 3 S t r u c t u r a l 20 Ro a d w a y D e s i g n 31 Ro a d w a y / Co n s t r u c t i o n C o n s t r u c t i o n P h a s e S e r v i c e s 10 C o n s t r u c t i o n P h a s e S e r v i c e s 35 Pe r m i t t i n g 6 Pe r m i t t i n g 6 Pe r m i t t i n g _2 _ a . o c o -( — CO E> f% % a>c ( Oa > CO5 o Q 3 a . 'e n T 3 " 5 Q _ CD O1 i- r » >c t oot o cL UOr a i — * - * C O> * -< — » CD TO OQ . ( OTO 5 — oTO i 1 J i§ Q . U . C l C O I — C O 1 — H -