Res. No. 106-08-12703Xz=
WHEREAS The applicant, Diana M. Calderon, has submitted Historic Preservation Board
Application No. HPB-08-017 requesting approval of a certificate of appropriateness which will allow
for the exterior renovation, painting and signage on a designated historic site at 5904 Sunset Drive
(Amster Buildings); and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 20-5.1.9(E) of the Land Development Code, a, "Certificate of
Appropriateness", is required for applications affecting the exterior (renovation, repair, painting, signiage,
demolition or landscaping) of properties designated historic, and
"WHEREAS, Section 20-5.19(E)(3) of the South Miarni Land Development Code requires the
Cite Con-unission to conduct a public hearing on certificates of appropriateness and to approve, deny,
approve in modified form, or defer a subject application; and
WHEREAS, the Historic PreseiAation Board at its April 21, 2008 adopted a motion by a vote of
7 ayes 0 nays recommending approval of the requested Certificate of Appropriateness with certain
conditions; and
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Commission of the City of South Miami desire to accept the
recon-irnendation of the Historic Preservation Board.
-NTO% THEREFORE, BE IT RE, SOLVE, D BY THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA THAT-
Section 1. Historic Preservation Board Application No. HPB-08-017 requesting a Certificate ,
of Appropriateness which will allow for the exterior renovation, painting and signage on a designated
historic site at 5904 Sunset Drive (Amster Buildings) is approved as shown on the applicant's plans
marked "Exhibit "A" attached to this resolution subject to the following conditions:
I
Res. ate.. 106-08-12703
Section . This resolution shall be of %ctive immediately after the adoption hereof,
PASSED AND ADOPTED this _ ' ' � clay of , 2 008
CIT�t'
CLERK—
CITY A T ORNE
APPROVED:
COMMISSION VOTE: 5-0
Mayor Feliu:
Yea
Vice Mayor Beasley:
Yea
Commissioner Wisconibe:
Yea
Commissioner Palmer:
Yea
Commissioner Becks -naia
lea
XAComm ttenis \2008\5- 20- 081CCiA 5904 5u11set Dr Iiesol,doc
I
CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI
OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER
INTER-OFFICE MEMORANDUM 2001
To: The Honorable Mayor relic and Members of the City Corrunission
Via: Ajibola Balogun, City Manager
rA rom: Sanford A. Youkilis, Acting Plaiming Dircct.,W,,�/ -
T
Date: June 3, 2008 ITEM No._
APPLICA,NT'S REQUE, S
The applicant is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness for the exterior renovation of a vacant
store and the placement of new business signage on a designated historic site at 5904 Sunset
Drive (Amster Properties / Dorn Brothers Building). The historic designation consists of three
buildings; the subject COA request is for one of the buildings.
0000• �,�)SED �RE
The applicant is proposing to pressure clean and repaint the existing facades on a vacant store
which faces both Sunset Dr/ S. Dixie Highway and an interior courtyard facing Dorn Avenue.
The proposed renovation will re-create a Mediterranean theme for the building. In addition the
applicant is proposing to place an oval shaped name sign on both facades. The sign will be
Plexiglas with raised lettering and will be IS square feet -which is within the size limitation of a
wall sign.
RISTORIC 130ARD ACTION
The Historic Preservation Board reviewed the applicant's proposed renovation and sIg0 nage, at its
April 21, 2008 ineeting. The Historic Preservation Board made several suggestions to the
applicant concerning signage and colors and pressure cleaning.
The Board then adopted a mot on by a vote of 7 ayes 0 nays recommending approval of the
requested Certificate of Appropriateness with the following conditions:
1. The yellow color scheme shall be used for the exterior painting;
2. The rear of the building shall have vent tiles installed in order to create a more
symmetrical alignment above the rear door; '
3. The sign shall be consistent with the elevations as presented;
4, The sign shall be flat with direct lighting;
5. The building shall be pressure cleaned at 500 psi.
I
RE COWME, NDATION
It is recommended that the City Commission approve the "Certificate of Appropriateness" to
allow for the exterior renovation, painting and signage on a designated historic site at 5904
SUDset Drive (Amster Buildings) as shown on the applicant's plans marked "Exhibit "A"
attached to this resolution and subject to the conditions recommended by the Historic
Preservation Board:
Documentation:
Draft Resolution
Historic Preservation Board Staff ReporL 4-21-08
COA Application
Existing Condition Photos
Illustrated Plans (both facades)
Historic Prose `nation Board Minutes Excerpt 4-21-08
Public Notices
SAY/ K\Comin ItemsU005-20-08 COA 5904 Sunset CIA Report.doc
To Honorable Chair & Bate: April 21, 2008
5904 Sunset Drive
PROPOSED -RENOVATION
The applicant is proposing to pressure clean and repaint the existing facades on a vacant store which faces
berth Sunset Dr/ S.Dixie Highway and an interior courtyard facing Dorn Avenue. The proposed renovation
will re- create a Mediterranean theme for the building. In addition the applicant is proposing to place an
oval shaped name sign on both facades. The sign will be plexiglass with raised lettering and will be t
square feet which is within the size limitation of a wall sign.
General
The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Historic Preservation Projects
With Guidelines for Applying the Standards (1'979) as may be amended.
6202 SW 56 Street
COA/Variances
August 20, 2007
Page 2 of 2
I
Building "C ", (5901 Sunset Drive)
One story height
Projecting center bay terminating in a pediment shape
Three, regularly spaced blind arches above the entrance and square storefront
windows.
0 Series of circular the vents along the parapet wall
Tile coping
RECOMMENDATION
The storefront renovation and the proposed signnge on both facades are compatible with the specific
design criteria for the building at 5904 Sunset Drive, The Board is being given the opportunity to suggest
a color to be used in the repainting. The applicant demonstrates a color selection pallet on p.I of the
submitted illustrated plans.. It is recommended that the COA application, as submitted be approved.
Attachments:
COA Application
Existing Condition Photos
Illustrated Flans (bath facades)
Renovation Plan
SAY
X:113PB Historic Bd\HPB Agendas Staff reports'MO&A- 21- 08T[P13 -08 -017 COA Renovation 5904 Sunset.dou
„ a
Mr. Sanford A. Youkiiis, AICP
City of South Miatni
Re: Historical Preservation Board ; Meeting — PV08 -017'
Crepe Cuisine
5904 South Dixie Highway
I
HISTORIC NAME (II; ANY
2E AL DESCRIPTIO
WNER
=I2ESS, r �y
ly #I�Wlgx-
site plan floor plan elevations(s) cta(s)
survey color sample aterial sample
other (describe
(2)
Applications will be scheduled :for a Board hearing when received by 12:00 noon on the second Monday of the
month.
Structural systems - SON Q-
Roofs and roafing - NQt�?,-
Windows and doors QN�
Materials (masoro, wood, metal, etc.) -
0- M-
Porches, porte Cocheres, and steps - 0qWQS
EM-AP
M
AS- OW�4� OF THE A13OVE-REFERF-NCED
APPLICAmN ON MY BEHAtF
Oct 2004
EAHPB Historic Bd\UPB Njis c\Certi flea te of appropriate project\Cert. of Appropriateness Appl.doc
HPB USE ONLY
DATE RECEIVED:-
HPB MEETING:-
PERMIT NO.-
T �
�ICD
LU
a
LI
CD j
COURTESY AOTICE-
a
C yg®
On Tuesday, June 3, 2005, beginning at 7;M p,m., in the bi Unmltli si6rl
Chambers, 61 30 Sunset Drive, the Olty06mmissi6rt quill ttalrirthiic tieRfnge
t6 consider thb.fellowing items:.
A RESOLUTION' RELATING TO AN APPEAL dF A-ADECISION OF THE-
ENVIRONMENTAL- „REVIEW AND- P- RESERVATIbN ':BOARD, -°r0.' DENY'
-_ PROPOSED TAKE -'QUTT ORDER SIGNAGE FOR GARW-BA'S ITALIAN
AND - OUTBACK STEAKHOUSE: RESTAURANT LOCATED AT'5829 SW 73 =
STREET (SOUTH MIAMI MUNICIPAL PARKING GARAGE)
A RESOLUTION RELATING TO THE ISSUANCE OF CERTIFICATE -OF
APPROPRIATENESS PURSUANT TO SECTION 2D 519(E)(3) OF THE LAND- -':
DEVELOPMENT CODE FOR THE - EXTERIOR RENOVATION PAINTING AND
- SIGNAfiaEONA DESIGNATED' HISTIIRICC OMMERCIAL.BUIL61NG,LOCATED.:°-
V5904 SUNSET DRIVE (AMSTER BUILOING�S}
A RESOLUTION R FLAT INGTOA REQUEST PURSUANT 1`O SECTION
20- 3::;1(6)(4)(b)” OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE FOR A SPECIAL USE
APPROVAL TO LOCATE A GENERAL RESTAURANT - LOCATED AT., 5734 SW
72nd STREET WITHIN THE "SR (HO ov% SPECIALTY RETAIL (HOMETONJN
DISTRICT OVEREAYJZONINGI }ISTRICT ' ._
-A RESOLUTIONRELATINGTOi ,RE(IUESTFORAVARIANCEF601" SECTION':
2045(E) OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE TO ALLOW FORA NEW,"
;SINGLE FAMILY HOME TG HAVE REAR' -,SE BACK OF 19,1 FEET WHERE `
A MINIMUM 25 FOOT HEAR SETBACK IS REOUIREO: ALL ON A PROPERTY
WITHINAN,`RS -4" SINGLE - FAMILY RESIDENTIAL USE DISTRICt, LOCATED
j' AT 5400 SW 57TH COURT -
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 7 OF THE SOUTH MIAMI CODE OF
ORDINANCES BY CREATING SECTION 7 716 "PRE - CONSTRUCTION AND
CONSTRUCTION STANDARDS FOR SITES;" REOUIRING CONSTRUCTION
SITES TORE KEPT IN CLEAN AND ORDERLY CONDITION; REQUIRING THE
INSTALLATION OF A CHAIN LINKFENCE PRIOR TO CONSTRUCTI()NALONG
THE BORDERS OF JHE SITE; AND TO PROVIDE DETAILED PROCEDURES
FOR OBTAINING FENCE PERMIT PRIOR TO CONSTRUCTION.
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING.. CHAPTER TOF THE SOUTH MIAMI CODE
-O ORDINANCES • `BY MODIFYING SECTION 7 -15.2 . "DEMOLITION '
REQUIREMENT STANDARDS" TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL CLARITY AS TO
PROCEDURES FOR OBTAINING" FENCE PERMIT, PRIOR TO DEMOLITION
AND CONSTRUCTION.
AN _dRDINANGE- .RELATING" TO AMENDING THE, CITY'S "CODE OF
ORDINANCES CHAPTER 2,: AI PbLE , (,.:SECTION . 2A-, (H) AND (J)`
- ESTABL18HINt- PROCEDURES FOR PUBLIC -COMMENTS IN IN ORDER TO
FACILITATE AN ORDERLY PROCESS IN MANAGING PUBLIC COMMENTS.'
AN ORDINANCE REiATINGTOA AEOUESTTOAMEND LAND DEVELOPMENT'
-CODE- SECTION 20-5.9 ENTITLED "VARIANCE APPROVALS' IN:OROER
TO .ADD A. SUBSECTION (H). PROVIDING CRITERIA FOR' REVIEW AND
APPROVING VARIANCE APPLICATIONS; AMENDING SECTION 20-.61 (B)(3) .
'(h} IN ORDER TO REMOVE THE-EXISTING-GUIDELINE:
It you have any trirlurries on the above items please contact the Planning and Zoning
Departments office at 305 - 663 76326:
ALL Interested parties are invited to attend and will be heard..
• Ma
na M. Mrinendez, Cfx1G
City Clerk
Purs'6anf to Florida Statutes 285.o165„ 1ha City hereby advises the public that if a parson decide:
topppeat arty decisitrt made by this Board, Agency or Commission writh respect fa any matter
corisidefed at its meeting ur hearing, he or she vr',IT need:a record of ft proceedings, and that tot
such purpose, affected person may need 10 ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings i.
made which record fnctudes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based-
o C? '�S mcWrl &x-Z °70 ' n
ZF
U,-. ° �k-00 3%'C9:
v
—Mg z.¢5t
zoo �Q x'n Cy - xOF � a w
E- Z? O:[CVatJ<— ca Dw �z Uzm 1?g!
. C na.G Zo,x„m w� :2 p.. mWtn�q. ny rjo °yoF -..
�.®. ti =moo ¢a.. w§ <
rr.
C) o mac.. ocl �e?ienn�: °. rxq -9 o�a9:.� a z }.
o.
_ w
W.-c ES? U1Q�y �Cj�LT ~&- t°iaix G.
1=Eu ¢:O ¢rG am PR w ¢O1-i �a �oc<i xl�.nvlo svwv_r
E.a ¢ca�Ga
j KFf2K4
O W Z. C�SZF- 900. —Mz ion
Li
2p�..
y�$Nw�C¢QBwGS °yet]. IX
JJg���2'Ci�
cc
K{[�ti
o ZJ (LC
v
LU
R
pppp�,
Vf vy c
fn
- A�;W 6t1,O<MDO
tiU❑ � JOyW,
W
yea
t: ij
�� ,
._
�s.
\w ».w�;
DH
.,, . ..e,mmmwma.
?\ % <?yd »2\»
} .
ƒ