Res No 119-10-13153RESOLUTION NO. 119-10-13153
A Resolution of the Mayor and City Commission of the City of South Miami, Florida
relating to the issuance of a Certificate of Appropriateness pursuant to Section 20-
5.19(E)(3) of the Land Development Code to permit the installation of wall signage on a
designated historic commercial building located at 5837 Sunset Drive (Shelley Building);
providing an effective date.
WHEREAS, the applicant, Luis Berthin has submitted Historic Preservation Board
Application No. HPB -10 -001 requesting approval for the installation of two wall signs on a
designated historic site at 5837 Sunset Drive (Shelley Building); and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 20- 5.19(E) of the Land Development Code, a
"Certificate of Appropriateness ", is required for applications affecting the exterior (renovation,
repair, painting, signage, demolition or landscaping) of properties designated historic; and
WHEREAS, Section 20- 5.19(E)(3) of the Land Development Code requires the City
Commission to conduct a public hearing on certificates of appropriateness and to approve, deny,
approve in modified form, or defer a subject application; and
WHEREAS, the Historic Preservation Board at its April 26, 2010 adopted a motion by a
vote of ayes 8 nays 0 recommending approval of the requested Certificate of Appropriateness
with a condition; and
WHEREAS, the Mayor and City Commission of the City of South Miami desire to
accept the recommendation of the Historic Preservation Board.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY
COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI, FLORIDA THAT:
Section 1. The Historic Preservation Board Application No. HPB -10 -001 requesting a Certificate
of Appropriateness, which will permit the installation of two wall signs (south and east fagade)
on a designated historic commercial building located at 5837 Sunset Drive (Shelley Building) is
approved as shown on the applicant's plans marked Exhibit "A" attached to this resolution and
illustrates the following condition:
1. Option two for the south fagade to be moved over the eastern arch and the same style of
sign is to be reduced to five feet in length or width on the eastern fagade.
Section 2. This resolution shall be effective immediately after the adoption hereof.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this 2nd day of June , 2010
Res. no. 119-10-13153
ATTEST:
TY CLERK
READ AND APPROVED AS TO FORM
AND SUFFICIENCY:
ITY ATT RNEY
APPROVED:
M /(/
COMMISSION VOTI
Mayor: Stoddard
Vice Mayor: Newman
Commissioner: Palmer
Commissioner: Beasley
Commissioner: Harris
X: \Comm Items \2010 \6- 1- 10 \COA 5837 Sunset Dr Resol.doc
4 -0
Yea
Yea
absent
Yea
Yea
2
South Miami
All-America City
-� CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI
• ��c0 RY9P o OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER
INTER — OFFICE MEMORANDUM 2001
To: The Honorable Mayor Stoddard and Members of the City Commission
Via:
From:
Buford R. "Randy" Witt, Acting City Manager
Thomas J. Vageline, Director
Planning and Zoning Departme
ITEM No. 5
pvj
Date: June 2, 2010
SUBJECT:
A Resolution of the Mayor and City Commission of the City of South Miami,
Florida relating to the issuance of a Certificate of Appropriateness pursuant to
Section 20- 5.19(E)(3) of the Land Development Code to permit the installation of
wall signage on a designated historic commercial building located at 5837 Sunset
Drive (Shelley Building); providing an effective date.
APPLICANT'S REQUEST:
The applicant is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) for the installation of
two wall signs on a designated historic site at 5837 Sunset Drive (Shelley Building).
STAFF ANALYSIS & HISTORY:
The existing historically designated two -story building with arcade will be occupied by a
new restaurant by the name of Old Lisbon, previously occupied by the Alta Cocina
restaurant. The restaurant's location is the east corner bays on the first floor, facing SW
72 Street (Sunset Drive), located within the Specialty Retail Hometown District Overlay
(SR: HD -OV) Zoning District. The attached photograph of the South Elevation illustrates
an entire facade of the existing Building Elevation. The following photograph also noted
South Elevation illustrates an entire facade of the Proposed Building Elevation, which
illustrates the applicant's intent. At this time, the applicant is requesting a Certificate of
Appropriateness approval for signage by the City Commission.
PROPOSED SIGNAGE:
The applicant is proposing to install two flat signs each sign on a different wall (south
and east) of the arcade on the building's facade. It is important to note that the applicant
has submitted for review and approval a revised Option two. This was stated as a
condition set forth by the Historic Preservation Board. The sign on the south facade was
to be moved to be over the eastern arch (above the arch) and the second sign on the
eastern facade be the same style of sign but reduced to five feet in length as follows:
Option 2: One irregular shaped sign will be placed on the south wall above the arch,
facing Sunset Drive. The sign will contain the name of the business (Old Lisbon
Restaurant). The sign area at 4 feet by 6 feet, totals 24 sq. ft. This does not exceed the
maximum permitted square footage of a flat sign, which is 20% of the existing 370 sq. ft.
facade or a maximum of 74 sq. ft.
The second sign will be placed on the east wall and consistent with the first sign, in other
words, both signs are the same in style, material, and color (Pantone 295C blue), but not
the same size. Actually, the applicant has reduced the sign down'to four feet, one foot
smaller than what was recommended by the Historic Preservation Board. The sign
characteristics for both signs include PVC lettering, V thick sign panel mounted directly
on the wall with %4" studs and silicone, as illustrated on the specification plans by Sign -
A -Rama. Pursuant to Section 20- 4.3(1)(5) All Other Zoning Districts, of the Land
Development Code, the newly proposed flat signs comply with the guidelines.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD ACTION:
The Historic Preservation Board reviewed the applicant's proposed signage at its April
26, 2010 meeting. The Historic Preservation Board discussed and analyzed three different
signage options submitted by the applicant. The HPB recommend signage option number
two for approval with conditions to the city commission.
The Board then adopted a motion by a vote of 8 ayes 0 nays recommending approval of
the requested Certificate of Appropriateness with the following condition:
1. Option two for the south fagade to be moved over the eastern arch and the
same style of sign is to be reduced to five feet in length or width on the eastern
fagade.
RECOMMENDATION:
It is recommended that the City Commission approve the "Certificate of
Appropriateness" to allow for the proposed signage on a designated historic site at 5837
Sunset Drive (Shelley Building) as shown on the applicant's plans marked Exhibit "A"
attached to this resolution which reflect the conditions recommended by the Historic
Preservation Board.
ATTACHMENTS:
• COA Application, submitted on January 14, 2010
• Map indicating Subject property
• Historic Preservation Board Staff Report, dated 4 -26 -10
• Historic Preservation Board Excerpt Minutes, dated 4 -26 -10
• Sketch of Boundary Survey w /Location Sketch, dated May 7, 2010
2
Revised Signage plans prepared by Sign -A -Rama, dated May 7, 2010:
• Photographs of Neighboring properties (right and left)
• Building Elevation (existing) — South Elevation
• Proposed Building Elevation — South Elevation
• PVC Panel Sign: Option 2 — South Elevation
• Installation Specifications — South Elevation
• PVC Panel Sign — East Elevation
• Installation Specifications — East Elevation
• Letter Height — Option 2 — South and East Elevation
• PVC Sign Panel Specifications — South Elevation
• Color Swatch: Pantone 295C
• Public Notices
TJV/LCH
Y:\Comm Items \2010 \6- 2- 10 \COA 5837 Sunset Drive \COA 5837 Sunset CM
Report.doc
CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI HISTORIC PRESERVATION
PLANNING DEPARTMENT BOARD
6130 Sunset Drive, South Miami, Florida 33143
305- 663 -6326
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS APPLICATION
(The Historic Preservation Board will act on completed applications only.)
SECTION I
PROPERTY ADDRESS {" v ums t� bte, HISTORIC NAME (IF ANY)
&Kp-S S�!i Pty y lf,) 1-675 S- 6 - Y -`3 G-? - f7 tar. 7 LESS S (4,1 P FT
LEGAL DESCRIPTION IiiL`C /DTSI �O :a.I3IYYX iA��Z 06!` 34017 Pf2?
OWNER
k(Qf) SQ PHONE NUMBER. 3b ' rl ' Q % ti
ADDRESS � (o e 10) 9 Sal
jiC ^ f_/ rAn 6 �
APPLICANT
__6U 1 v
/ PHONE NUMBER
ADDRESS /'� � �f D &V yi/ HJ +4-A1
ARCHITECT OR ENGINEER PHONE NUMBER
SECTION 2
PLEASE INDICATE THE CATEGORY WHICH BEST DESCRIBES THE WORK TO BE PERFORMED
(SEE ATTACHED SHEET)
type
mark
type
mark
type
mark
below
below
below
MAINTENANCE /REPAIR
REHABILITATION
NEW CONSTRUCTION
RESTORATION
DEMOLITION
OTHER �5 /c, /` f-
'
v
SECTION 3
DESCRIBE THE PROPOSED WORK (A BRIEF NARRATIVE):
SECTION 4
JAN 142010
ATTACH THE FOLLOWING SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION (IF APPLICABLE) ;
site plan floor plan
survey color sample
other (describe)
elevations(s) photo(s)
material sample
(2)
SECTION 5
PLEASE NOTE THE FOLLOWING:
• Applications will be accepted by the Planning Department only in completed form.
• Applications will be scheduled for a Board hearing when received by 12:00 noon on the second Monday of the
month.
• Applicant(s) or representative(s) must attend the hearing and present the proposal to the Board.
• Decisions made by the Board maybe appealed to the City Commission no later than 60 days-after the ruling.
• If there is no appeal or City Commission action, the Historic Preservation Board's decision shall be final.
The Certificate of Appropriateness is valid for a period six months after date of approval.
SECTION 6
BRIEFLY DESCRIBE THE PROJECT'S IMPACT ON THE FOLLOWING BUILDING FEATURES:
Structural systems -
Roofs and roofing -
Windows and doors -
Materials (masonry, wood, metal, etc.) - .
Porches, pone cocheres, and steps -
Painting and finishes -
AS OWNER OF THE ABOVE- REFERENCED
PROPERTY DO HEREBY AUTHORIZE THE tLING OF THS APPLICATION ON MY BEHALF.
HPB USE ONLY
DATE RECEIVED:
HPB MEETING:
Oct.2004 PERMIT N0.
EAHPB Historic Bd \HPB MiscTertificate of appropriate projecKert. of Appropriateness Appl.doc
� 1
Explanations of categories for Section 2
Maintenance or Repair: The act or process of applying measures to sustain the existing form integrity and
material of a building or structure and the existing form or vegetative cover of a site. It may include initial
stabilization work, where necessary, as well as ongoing maintenance and repair. (Samples of material may be
requested).
Restoration: The process of accurately recovering the form and details of a property and its setting as it
appeared at a particular period of time by means of the removal of later work or by the replacement of missing earlier
work. All applications for restoration shall include elevations, site and landscape plans (if necessary), and any other
supplementary information that will support the proposed project.
Rehabilitation: The process of returning a property to a state of utility through repair or alteration which makes
possible an efficient contemporary use while preserving those portions or features of the property which are
significant to its historical, architectural, and cultural values. All applications for rehabilitation shall include:
elevations, site and landscape plans (if necessary), and any other supplementary information that will support the
proposed project.
Demolition: The process of destroying or tearing down a building or structure or a part thereof, or the process of
removing or destroying an archaeological site or a part thereof. The applicant(s) shall include a report explaining why
the proposed action should occur. If the action is to occur for reasons of financial hardship, all pertinent financial data
should be included pertaining to the cost of preservation, demolition and new construction. Any other material
pertinent to the application is also encouraged as supplementary information.
New construction: The process of constructing a building or structure that has never existed at that location.
Applications shall include a site plan, elevations, floor plan, and landscaping plan.
Other: (relocation, excavation, etc.)
City of South Miami Building
Historic Site Designation (IF OV) Shelley
5837 Sunset Drive
r
SW 68TH ST
Q. 5816 5798 6760 5112
6950 $92 5920 0 d19 087 0 F- 5848 5791 D ■
8858 6750 r
681t 5711
U 9 52 � ■
$907 5897 5875 3 7 5764 676 � 6601
_ 6845 Eno
-- - 7
$820 $163 •
5879 '
5850 °
5865 0 °
6927 5867 8864
6900 5690 5880 8 6801 �� r■
5821 O\��4i ■ 1578
0 °
5 [
■
7001" 5996 7000 t
7019 6959 5715
0 5995 7090 5870 6820
SW 71ST ST y� $UBJEC p N j
PROP E Y ■
.5960 5840 8 81 0 W OF
6915
6075 $975 5857 5795 S
6825 5801
SW 72ND ST
5995 5875 6 "
93 SUNSET DR
■
SW 72ND ST 0 ' 5640
6110 6000 6880 $860 5850 5840 5800 0 5796. 5756
X60 5'100
5950 2p 0 0 6898 5738
.
6000 9 0 T2t1 0
5930 0 7230 5869 0 7230
5885 5829 1301
0 5195
0 6946 8 0 0 0 ■
.Tr 7301 ■
6000 7331 $824 5818 5800 0 p 7311 7300
5940 ® 7325
7311 0 0 7320 7321
5950 7310 0
7321. 5850 ■
7390
0 0 5791 7331 1 7375
5966 5901 0 T ■
■
6022 6970 0
6040 7400 1400 ■
6950 }- $901 5875 5839 6801 6791 5730
0 0 o V 7420
SW 74TH TE SW 74TH TE ■
rn
.1435 7410 7420 5800 J786 5 8 X70 5730 7450 °
T430 5890 6884 4
N
7440 1441 7600
0 100 200 300 600
900 1,200 1.,500
Feet
CITY OF SOUTH .T
PLANNING AND DEPARTMENT
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
To: Chair & Board Members, Date: April 26, 2010
Historic Preservation Board Monday 7:30 p.m.
Via: Thomas J. Vageline, Director Re: Certificate of Appropriateness
Planning and Zoning Department HPB -10- 001 -COA
From: Lourdes Cabrera- Hernandez, LEED AP Signage Installation
Principal Planner ' 4e�
HPB -10 -001 -COA
Applicant: Luis Berthin
Property Owner: Sunset 58, LLC
Location: 5837 SW 72 Street (Shelley Building)
Request: Two Flat Signs
BACKGROUND & APPLICANT'S REQUEST:
On January 14, 2010, the applicant, Luis Berthin, filed a Historic Preservation Board
(HPB) Application with the Planning and Zoning Department at the City of South Miami.
The signage company, by the name of Sign -A -Rama submitted sign detail plans for
review and approval from the HPB. The applicant is requesting a Certificate of
Appropriateness for the installation of two wall signs on a designated historic site
located at 5837 Sunset Drive (Shelley Building). The recommendation of the Historic
Preservation Board will be transmitted to the City Commission for final approval.
On February 22, 2010, the application was presented before the Historic Preservation
Board (HPB) and was deferred with comments and suggestions from the Board. The
Board members asked to see a photo of the entire front of the building as the Board
members study the proposed sign. Furthermore, the Board's motion stated the letter
size be reduced by ten percent for the sign facing Sunset Drive. The sign facing east is
acceptable. At this time, the Boards suggestions have been taken into consideration
and a revised proposal dated April 12, 2010 has been submitted for review. Attached,
for additional information are the HPB excerpt minutes of the HPB February 22, 2010
meeting.
STAFF ANALYSIS:.
The existing historically designated two -story building with arcade will be occupied by a
new restaurant by the name of Old Lisbon, previously occupied by the Alta Cocina
restaurant'. The restaurant's location is the east corner bays on the first floor, facing SW
72 Street (Sunset Drive), located within the Specialty Retail Hometown District Overlay
(SR: HD -OV) Zoning District. The attached photograph of the South Elevation illustrates
an entire fagade of the existing Building Elevation. The following photograph also noted
South Elevation illustrates an entire fagade of the Proposed Building Elevation, which
illustrates the applicant's intent.
The applicant is proposing to install two flat signs each sign on a different wall (south
and east) of the arcade on the building's fagade. It is important to note that the applicant
has submitted three options for the south wall fagade of the building facing Sunset
Drive, as follows:
COA: Signage Installation
5837 SW 72 Street (Shelley Building)
HPB -10- 001 -COA presented on April 26, 2010
Option 1A: One rectangular shaped sign will be placed on the south wall centered on
the column, facing Sunset Drive. The sign will contain the name of the business (Old
Lisbon Restaurant) with a background drawing. The sign area at 36 in. by 901in. totals
22.5 sq. ft. This does not exceed the maximum permitted square footage of a flat sign,
which is 20% of the existing 370 sq. ft. facade or a maximum of 74 sq. ft.
Option 113: This rectangular shaped sign is the same as Option 1A, except it is only an
alternate location above the arch.
Option 2. One irregular shaped sign will be placed on the south wall centered on the
column, facing Sunset Drive. The sign will contain the name of the business (Old Lisbon
Restaurant). The sign area at 4 feet by 6 feet, totals 24 sq. ft. This does not exceed the
maximum permitted square footage of a flat sign, which is 20% of the existing 370 sq.. ft.
fagade or a maximum of 74 sq. ft.
Option 3: One oval shaped sign will be placed on the south way above the arch, facing
Sunset Drive. The sign will contain the name of the business (Old Lisbon Restaurant).
The sign area at 48 in. by 84 in. totals 28 sq. ft. This does not exceed the maximum
permitted square footage of a flat sign, which is 20% of the existing 370 sq. ft. fagade or
a maximum of 74 sq. ft.
On February 22, 2010, HPB meeting, the Board requested for the signage to be
reduced by ten percent. A copy of that proposal has been attached for comparison only.
That proposal referred to letters at 14 inches for "Old Lisbon and 5 inches for
"restaurant" with a total of 13.41 sq. ft. As noted and a part of this submittal, the letter
height are as follows, for Option 1A - 9.25 in, Option 2 - 7.24 in and' Option 3 - 8 inches.
Therefore, letter heights have been reduced.
As previously designed, the second sign will be placed on the east wall of the building
(on the arcade's end). It will be visible by the pedestrians heading west on the sidewalk
of Sunset Drive, approaching the restaurant. This sign is consistent with the first sign in
letter style and color but not in the size. The sign area at 7 in. by 62.98 in. is 3.06 sq. ft.,
plus 2.5 in. by 25 in. is 0.43 sq. ft., totaling 3.49 sq. ft. This does not exceed the
maximum permitted square footage of a flat sign, which is 20% of the existing 97 sq. ft.
facade or a maximum of 19.4 sq, ft.
On February 22, 2010, at the HPB meeting, the Board noted the size of the sign on the
side of the building facing east was acceptable. The design of this sign has not been
changed.
In reference to the sign characteristics the applicant has provided for the south elevation
a3/4" thick sign panel mounted directly on the wall with '/4" studs and silicone. The east
elevation are individual PVC letters, 7" in height and 2.5" in height, blue PVC letters
mounted directly on the wall with '/4" studs with silicone, as illustrated on the
specification plans by Sign -A -Rama. The applicant has submitted a color swatch,
Pantone 295C and the proposed color for the letters on both signs with either option is
to be blue.
2
COA: Signage Installation
5837 SW 72 Street (Shelley Building)
HPB- 10- 001 -COA presented on April 26, 2010
Pursuant to Section 20- 43(1)(5) All Other Zoning Districts, of the Land Development
Code, the following are the regulations for flat signs: 1
FLAT SIGNS with a total aggregate sign area, not to exceed
twenty (20) percent of the area of any building face, for the
purposes of sign regulation, there shall be considered to be
only four (4) facades to any building; no single sign shall
exceed two hundred (200) square feet in area. Direct
illumination is permitted.
RECOMMENDATION:
It is the policy of the Planning and Zoning Department that the amount of allowable
signage shall be kept to a minimum on historically designated buildings and notes that
the proposal does not include illuminated letters of any kind, which may be a compatible
solution for the subject historic Shelley Building.
Staff recommends approval of the proposed two flat signs, with the following condition:
The design intent should be in character with the architectural vocabulary and existing
character of the historic building and compatible with the current signage.
Attachments:
• HPB excerpt minutes of the HPB February 22, 2010 meeting
• Designation Report: The Shelley Building
• Copy of February 22, 2010 proposed signage for comparison only
® Sketch of Boundary Survey w /Location Sketch, dated April 12, 2010
• Revised Signage plans prepared by Sign -A -Rama, dated April 12, 2010:
• Photographs of Neighboring properties (right and left)
• Building Elevation (existing) — South Elevation
■ Proposed Building Elevation — South Elevation
■ PVC Panel Sign: Option 1A — South Elevation
■ PVC Panel -Sign: Option 1 B Alternate Location — South Elevation
■ PVC Panel Sign: Option 2 — South Elevation
■ PVC Panel Sign: Option 3 — South Elevation
■ Letter Height: Option 1A & 1B, Option 2, and Option 3
■ Individual. Letters - East Elevation
■ Individual PVC Letters Specifications — East Elevation
■ PVC Sign panel Specifications — South Elevation
■ Color Swatch: Pantone 295C
On file:
• COA Application, submitted on January 14, 2010
• Articles of Organization for Florida Limited Liability Company of Old Lisbon Sunset, LLC
• Certificate of Designation of Registered Agent/Registered Office
® Property Information Report
TJV /LCH Y: \HPB Historic Bd \HPB Agendas Staff reports\2010 \4 -26 -10 \HPB -10- 001- COA- SIGNAGE
5837 SW 72 St. (Sunset Drive).doc
CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI
HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD
REGULAR MEETING
EXCERPT MINUTES
MONDAY, April 26, 2010
City Commission Chamber
7:30 P.M.
I. Call to order: Ms. Clyatt called the meeting to order at 7:47 p.m.
II. Roll Call: Roll call was performed. Board members present constituting a quorum: Mr.
LaMonica, Ms. Shelley, Mr. Ruiz de Castilla, Mr. Hochstim, Ms. Clyatt, and Mr. Kurtzman,
Ms. Dison, and Ms. Lahiff.
Board members absent: None.
City staff present: Thomas J. Vageline (Planning & Zoning Director), Lourdes Cabrera -
Hernandez (Principal Planner) and Alerik Barrios (Secretary).
City staff absent: Sanford Youkilis (Consultant).
III. ADMINISTRATION: Mr. Vageline stated that the next meeting of the Board will be
on Monday, May 24, 2010 at 7:30 p.m. He further informed that there would be no meeting
during the month of June. Mr. Vageline commented that at the next scheduled meeting the
Board will elect a new Chair and Vice- Chair. Mr. Vageline read to the Board LDC Section
20 -6.1 (b) concerning election procedures.
Ms. Clyatt questioned if the Board member terms would be extended an extra year. Ms.
Lahiff responded that this question was not asked in the last meeting. Mr. Vageline
commented that the Department will look into that question.
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: For the Board's meeting on February 22, 2010; Mr.
Kurtzman motioned for approval with corrections. Seconded by Mr. Hochstim.
Vote: 8 Ayes 0 Nayes.
Page 2 of 4
V. CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS APPLICATIONS:
HPB -10 -001* (continuation)
Applicant: Luis Berthin
Property Owner: Sunset 58, LLC
Location: 5837 Sunset Drive (Shelley Building Properties)
Request: Signage Installation — (Old Lisbon Restaurant)
Mrs. Cabrera - Hernandez explained that the applicant is requesting a signage installation for
the new location of Restaurant Old Lisbon. Mrs. Cabrera - Hernandez informed the Board that
the recommendation of the Historic Preservation Board will be transmitted to the City
Commission for final approval.
At a previous meeting, Board members asked to see a photo of the entire front of the building
so members could visualize study the proposed sign. Furthermore, the Board's motion stated
the letter size should be reduced by ten percent for the sign facing Sunset Drive. The sign
facing east is acceptable.
As previously designed, the second sign will be placed on the east wall of the building (on
the arcade's end). The sign will contain the name of the business (Old Lisbon Restaurant)
with a background drawing. The final option proposed is for an oval shaped sign that will be
placed on the south wall above the arch, facing Sunset Drive. In reference to the sign
characteristics the applicant has provided for the south elevation a V thick sign panel
mounted directly on the wall with ' /a" studs and silicone. The east elevation are individual
PVC letters, 7" in height and 2.5" in height, blue PVC letters mounted directly on the wall
with V4" studs with silicone, as illustrated on the specification plans by Sign -A -Rama. The
applicant has submitted a color swatch, Pantone 295C and the proposed color for the letters
on both signs with either option is to be blue. Pursuant to Section 20- 4.3(1)(5) All Other
Zoning Districts, of the Land Development Code, the following are the regulations for flat
signs:
FLAT SIGNS with a total aggregate sign area, not to exceed twenty
(20) percent of the area of any building face; for the purposes of
sign regulation, there shall be considered to be only four (4) facades
to any building; no single sign shall exceed two hundred (200)
square feet in area. Direct illumination is permitted.
Staff recommended approval of the proposed two flat signs, with the condition that the design
intent should be in character with the architectural vocabulary and existing character of the
historic building and compatible with the current signage.
Discussion:
Ms. Clyatt questioned if all the options were correct and is the sign in compliance with the
Board's request. Mrs. Cabrera- Hernandez responded yes and the dimensions were reduced in
size as request by the board.
Mr. Hochstim commented that he is concerned of the overall building because of the Rainbow
Nails sign that is off center, not centered on the arch and hung crooked. He suggested that the
option 2 is the proper option for the building and it should be hung over the arch.
Page 3 of 4
Mr. Hochstim proposed to the Board a drawing the applicant would want to consider,
Mr. Kurtzman questioned if the proposal is to go with individual letters being on studs on the
eastern facade. Mr. Kurtzman commented that if option two were approved the eastern facade
sign would have to be a lot smaller than the main sign.
Mr. La Monica questioned the sign on the eastern facade, if it was going to be the same size as
the front sign. Mr. Kurtzman commented that two of the conditions that the Board had requested
included the overall construction of the sign and lettering.
Mr. La Monica suggested that the signs should be consistent so that there is a unified identity and
look.
Mr. Hochstim questioned the dimensions of the east sign versus the south sign, are they the same
size. Mrs. Cabrera- Hernandez responded that the proposed size was different, but the applicant
provided options to hopefully be approved.
Mr. Hochstim commented that option two has to be the same as the main signage and the
illumination system has to be moved if the applicant wants the sign to be illuminated. He further
commented that the signage on the east side would be slightly smaller (5 square feet) and the
other sign is to be six square feet.
The applicant requested if the signage being proposed could include a logo look in the
background. Ms. Shelly commented that the tile piece in the restaurant is a logo for the company,
but she does not agree since it is not a clear read.
Ms. Lahiff commented that esthetically the signage being proposed with the image in the back
ground is not offensive.
Motion: Mr. Kurtzman motioned to approve the application with the stipulation that option two
for the south facade to be moved over the eastern arch and the same style of sign is to be reduced
to five feet of width on the eastern facade. Mr. Hochstim seconded.
Vote: 8 Ayes 0 Nays
Motion passed
VI. NEW /OLD BUSINESS:
Ms. Lahiff commented that she did a tour of Dade Heritage in Miami Beach. They are
developing Mid -Beach and it includes architecture. They are developing a new Mid -Beach
architecture and awareness which encompasses the 1950's — 1960's (Mimo). She further
commented that there are some buildings in South Miami that are of that time. Ms. Lahiff
commented that its time the Historic Board looked into that time.
Mr. Hochstim commented that there are not more than four or five buildings that are from that
time in the city.
Ms. Lahiff and Mr. Hochstim came to the determination that they will be looking into any
historic buildings that represent the 1950's — 1960's.
Mr. Hochstim commented that he has just been appointed to the National Board of Directors of
DOMM (Documentation of Modern Movement). This is predominately post World War Il
architecture. He commented that they are looking for examples in order to inform people of those
buildings to save them and designate them.
Page 4 of 4
Ms. Shelly commented that the Miami Conservatory should be considered for Historic
designation.
Mr. Hochstim informed the Board that if they are interested on the lectures to e-mail him and he
would inform them of the lectures.
Mr. Kurtzman questioned if the Bougainville Tavern had applied for a demolition permit and it is
on the City Commission agenda for the next meeting. Mr. Vageline responded that during the
last Commission meeting the item had been deferred to the next meeting in June. He further
commented that the department is working on that as of this moment.
Mr. Kurtzman questioned if picketing would jeopardize his position on the Board. Mr. Vageline
responded that the questioned will be forwarded to the City Attorney.
Ms. Shelly questioned if Ms. Klepser has any standing to tell the Board what to do. Ms. Clyatt
responded that Ms. Klepser requested that the meeting to be on a specific date because June is
the month were most people are out of town on vacation.
VII. ADJOURNMENT
Motion: Ms. Clyatt motioned to adjourn the meeting at 9:25 p.m.
YAHPB Historic Bd\HPB Minutes\2010 MinuteMprit 20101Historie .Minutes.04.26.10.doc
I
N
n
Ir
GO
1 r
n
O
m
Q
i
0'$
W
ILI
G)
0
2
9
m
a
Q,
Ix
W
11)(Y
qnNA&V 99 VS
tD
6
9
91
MAY o 7 2010
A
U
ZIP
pUU
Eu
®m
a
sN;w
4:4
�w
/ U Y
I NZ
�1qy�
'o
J
1
g ryoo
rn•u¢F � �Ci�
w
,^ tool 12 �2
7 �fL S
.iRrl /�.._.A� lJ •n0�
F W�CM V
6R WO—_v
U�Me
N� Bogg a
NIL
0aa n
O W�LL
CL t �,
0
U � �
O (S�LLV
0
19,E
m
f0
O Q
J
O n
Z O Z
T [J
O
—co
W
EUJ
m
b i VI
O � O
1
ddb
zz,
mwl
Qi'M
I
7
dt
G
Sxi
Y!
sl
IN
rNYr�
K�
,gym,
T
�aN
mN>
�mn
�aq
n�
N � V
L
CCD
0 O J
EXHIBIT "N'
y
e
W
L
O
4
cu
VJ
CV)
J
L
Lo
I.6
oN
U
N Q
7
O
CL*
N�
m
@ O
E �
r o
N
CD
Q C
i
*3 i;
Z 0
� s ,
� 3
o m
a
ay
n=3
0
a 3 0
00
> m
3 N
U C
X --
ID �p
7
L �
� C
O C
a@
O T
@.O
m
O
L
� 5
m C
m O
3
O @
T O-
C
,2---
CD
m N
_ O
n
E
n n
O T
N C
O1 @
C
3 0
m -O
.o (D
.N
C r
@ 3
C o
'N U
U
N 'C
L X
r
k'lY i
O
4
W
O
v.)
M�
W r�
o �U
a
m Q
7
O
n*
m Q
m
� Z
O �
CU)
ro O
E
N
C
o
cn 3
o a)
n�
o O
n�
O
N -O
U C
ro �
t7
U
N
� C
DT
C
Qro
m .o
U m
m°
3 3
m c
O
7 �
O N
J. 2
� C
U Q1
N N
� O
� Q
O �
N c
c:
c
'3 0
-o N
U
C r
ro�
c
0)
�
)
m �
U
A L
F d
I— . i
JI
OM
w �NI0O�
13
6-mm
U, I�al q
q,t i i
V 0 a
ir P) 01
Z
0
m
U)
C
Cu
M
E
0
0
re-
L
13
ri)
0 F-
0a^ 0
, D
n bo
JI
OM
w �NI0O�
13
6-mm
U, I�al q
q,t i i
V 0 a
ir P) 01
Z
0
m
U)
C
Cu
M
E
0
0
re-
L
13
AD
i
0
0
T3 .
Uzi
• U 0
k
0 ro
o-
O-S 1
�i =
(D 0
> a)
X-
a) W
(D
aj c:
2 >,
cu -a
-o
in
E
-3
m2
0
L4
C =
w 7�
c
L
U)
(L).9?
-o
M) _C
ri)
0a^ 0
C)
n bo
AD
i
0
0
T3 .
Uzi
• U 0
k
0 ro
o-
O-S 1
�i =
(D 0
> a)
X-
a) W
(D
aj c:
2 >,
cu -a
-o
in
E
-3
m2
0
L4
C =
w 7�
c
L
U)
(L).9?
-o
M) _C
/NSTALLAT /ON C-54i
LD GDES FOR SIG
12445'S. Dixie Hwy.
Miami, Fi 33956
305- 253 -5390
305- 253 -530B fax
Company: OLD LISBON
Drawn by: LB
314rr PVC PANEL
stud mounted to wall.
Blue Pantone 295c
OLD LISBON
RESTAURANT
ui
\ cri
SOUTV ELEVAT /ON
This design and drawing submitted for your review and approval is the exclusive properly of SIGN *A *RAMA. It may not be reproduced, copied,
exhibited or utilized for any purpose, In part or in whole by any Individual Inside out oulside without written consent of SIGN *A *RAMA.
i
P VC PA NEL SIGN
12445 S. Dixie Hwy.
Miami, PI 33156
305- 253 -5310 9 OLD LISBON
305- 253 -5308 fax :� I � PS - EFLAU �R A N - I'
Company: OLD LISBON
Crown by: LB
EAST LLAE VATIORK
12445 a. Dixie Hwy.
Miami, FI 33156
305- 253 -5390
305- 253 -5308 fax
Company: OLD LISBON
Drawn by: L.E3
3/4" PVC PANEL
stud mounted to wall.
Blue Pantone 295c
EAST ELEVAT /ON
)n and drawing submitted for your review and approval Is the exclusive property of SIGN *A *RA6fA. It may not be reproduced, copied,
or utilized for any purpose, In part or in whole by any Individual Inside out outside without written consent of SIGN *A *RAMA.
,o
W
O
LQ
N
0
N
L
C
0
�1
W
W
W
N
0
h
0
.Q
f.
0
m�
U
a�0
�Z
o�
C
@ O
E
QN
c
* 3
o
� 3
o N
a
a) 3S
°'
0
d 3 o
0
N a
3 'y
U C
X "-
m �
m 3
L a
N 0
� C
n> T
C C
Q
O_ T
cU 1]
a m
C p
� L
3 3
m c
m `o
o C0
T O'
� C
O "-
am
d O
d
E 3
n n
�T
N �
m�
ma
O N
a_
C 3
N
U, a
a:6
M
O
W
O 0
J
zQ
M
cA
0 ° z
= c�
Erg
W —MM
iw
�LLNN
of m
0 �Q0
.Q
f.
0
m�
U
a�0
�Z
o�
C
@ O
E
QN
c
* 3
o
� 3
o N
a
a) 3S
°'
0
d 3 o
0
N a
3 'y
U C
X "-
m �
m 3
L a
N 0
� C
n> T
C C
Q
O_ T
cU 1]
a m
C p
� L
3 3
m c
m `o
o C0
T O'
� C
O "-
am
d O
d
E 3
n n
�T
N �
m�
ma
O N
a_
C 3
N
U, a
a:6
M
llvm
S � J
J
W
Z o
Q
a J
Q�
(Z`���z v
�0U0
a W r
Y Z 2 Z
g�Q
M
m�.Q
a
m Q
7
Q
m
� Q
m
.0 z
C �
N O
E
m
. N
D
* 3
o
L_
� •3
om
tN
a=
o.s
a=
0
>_m
N "O
X C
d �p
ra
o c
Q�
❑.
Cl. .o
vm
co
mL
33
.0 C
m O
=m
T Q.
`o
vm
mo
-n 0
= T
N C
m N
.30
vm
,D .N
ro
ao
m
Vl
N L
N N
W
0
F-
�
>
m
U)
_ w
x Irl N W
a
NNN
IL
u
�
c
�
m
m N
m
`
� �
c
3
� oN�
a EMM
f0
0
[9
m�.Q
a
m Q
7
Q
m
� Q
m
.0 z
C �
N O
E
m
. N
D
* 3
o
L_
� •3
om
tN
a=
o.s
a=
0
>_m
N "O
X C
d �p
ra
o c
Q�
❑.
Cl. .o
vm
co
mL
33
.0 C
m O
=m
T Q.
`o
vm
mo
-n 0
= T
N C
m N
.30
vm
,D .N
ro
ao
m
Vl
N L
N N
W
a
F-
"�
wJ
r
v
ti J
� 3
0 Lp
m�.Q
a
m Q
7
Q
m
� Q
m
.0 z
C �
N O
E
m
. N
D
* 3
o
L_
� •3
om
tN
a=
o.s
a=
0
>_m
N "O
X C
d �p
ra
o c
Q�
❑.
Cl. .o
vm
co
mL
33
.0 C
m O
=m
T Q.
`o
vm
mo
-n 0
= T
N C
m N
.30
vm
,D .N
ro
ao
m
Vl
N L
N N
i
a
r
0
W
lirn0
pi I
in
LLa
�N
2m
m
w
O
N
�A
19
z
m
U)
C)
ij
c
to
CL
0
0
m
c
L
0
tj
in
0)
N
W
Z
0
Z
is
D
0
Z
D
LL
0
0
W
Z
4
Z
N
lu
W
MIAMI DAILY BUSINESS REVIEW
Published Daily except Saturday, Sunday and
Legal Holidays
Miami, Miami -Dade County, Florida
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF MIAMI -DADE:
Before the undersigned authority personally appeared
V. PEREZ, who on oath says that he or she is the
LEGAL CLERK, Legal Notices of the Miami Daily Business
Review f /k/a Miami Review, a daily (except Saturday, Sunday
and Legal Holidays) newspaper, published at Miami in Miami -Dade
County, Florida; that the attached copy of advertisement,
being a Legal Advertisement of Notice in the matter of
CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI - NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
AND DATE CHANGE - JUNE 2, 2010
in the XXXX Court,
was published in said newspaper in the issues of
05/21/2010
Affiant further says that the said Miami Daily Business
Review is a newspaper published at Miami in said Miami -Dade
County, Florida and that the said newspaper has
heretofore been continuously published in said Miami -Dade County,
Florida, each day (except Saturday, Sunday and Legal Holidays)
and has been entered as second class mall matter at the post
office in Miami in said Miami -Dade County, Florida, for a
period of one year next preceding the first publication of the
attached copy of advertisement; and affiant further says that he or
she has neither paid nor promised any person, firm or corporation
any discount, rebate, commission or refund for the purpose
of securing this adverti ent for publication in the said
newspaper.
Sworn to and subscribed before me this
21 day of MAY , A.D. 2010
(SEAL)
V. PEREZ personally known to me
r011' `�gi� Nofary public Stale of Florida
Cheryl H. Marmer
e MY Commfssfon /)/)793490
Or rLe. Expires 07118/2012
CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
AND DATE CHANGE
NOTICE IS HEREBY given that the City Commission of the City of
South Miami, Florida will.conduct a Public Hearing at its regular City
Commission meeting scheduled for Wednesday. June 2. 20i beginning
at 7:30 p.m. in the City Commission Chambers,.6130 Sunset Drive, to
consider the following item(s):
An Ordinance,of she Mayor and City. Commission of the City of South
Miami, Florida, relating to a request to amend the official zoning map of
the Ci-_of South, Miami ,Land Development Code by designating a
commercial byiiding located at 7221 SW 58 Avenue (aka Bougainvillea
Tavem);290,1egally described as being a portion of Lots 51 and 52; less
east 50 feet; in W. A. Larkin's Subdivision, recorded in Plat Book 3,
page 198 of Miami -Dade County Public Records, as an historic site and
by.plaRMent ;qf- an, Historic Preservation Overlay Zone (HP -OV)
over tile" existing 'inning use district for this property; providing
for. se, verabifijyProyiding for. ordinances in conflict; and providing an
effectivedate..^ -
An _ordinance_ {iof rthe ,Mayor and City Commission of the City of
South Mianil,- Florida; relating to Chapter BA of the City Code, repealing
Section BA- 2a=ofthe -Cod_e of Ordinances entitled "Code of Conduct
for all,'Pijblfb!6lifclals:and Board Members "; providing for severability,
"ordlnancesincofrflict andaheffectivedate.
A Resbitjtio roj�tlie Mayor and City .Commission 'of the City of
.,South.;Miami, Florida :relating to the issuance of a Certificate of
Appropria-teness,r_pursuant <to „Section 20- 5.19(e)(3) of the Land
Development Code to permit the installation of wall signage on a
designated:historic commercial building located at 5837 Sunset _Drive
(Shelley Building); providing an effective date. _
A Resolution of the Mayor and City Commission of the City of
South Miami ;'.Florida relating to. the issuance of a Certificate of
Appropriateness pursuant: t6 ,Section 20- 5.19(e)(3) of the Land
Development Code'to - the. Permit installation of wall signage on a
designated historic commercial building located at 5850B Sunset Drive
(D.J. Red Building); providing an effective date.
A Resolution of the Mayor and City..Commission of the City of
South Miami, Florida relating to the issuance . of a Certificate of
Appropriateness pursuant to Section 20- 6.19(e)(3) of the Land
Development _Code to the permit exterior renovation and roof
replacement on a designated historic single family building located
at 6202 SW 56 Street. (Miller Dr.)(Cambridge -Lawns Historic District);
providing an.effective date.
ALL interested parties are invited to attend and will be heard.
NOT4E: We are hereby Informing the public of the, date change of the
City Commission meeting from Tuesday, June.l.to Wednesday, June
2, 2010.
For further information, please contact the City Clerk's Office at:
305 -663 -6340.
Maria M. Menendez, CIVIC
City Clerk
Pursuant to Florida Statutes 286.0105; the City hereby advises the public
that if a person decides to appeal any decision made by this Board,
Agency.or Commission with respect to any matter considered at its
meeting or hearing, he or she will need a record of the proceedings, and
that for such purpose, affected person may need to ensure that a verbatim
record of the proceedings is made'which record includes the testimony
and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.
5/21 10-3-296/1481601M
;91ieMiam1 cral891
Ad Number: 849975001 Client Name:
Insertion Number: 849975001 Advertiser: CITY OF SOUTH MIAMI
Size: 4X7.0 Section /Page /Zone: NBRS SouthEast/SE43 /Dade
Publication Date: 05/23/2010 Color Type: B &W Description.
This EShest(R) Is provided as conclusive evidence that the ad appeared In The Miami Herald on the data and page Indicated. You may not create derivative works, or In any way exploit or repurpose any content.
5H ^•,�,OA 5t:45. g ;°.°5F
" m '�G�o r u a Hm f D� <.i° E' �mprdwro o E b ^ro °cti �'- n H yaSo v
,xH •�o °ru �. E�5 n5°n U aae m on
ay n�� �o
P�^c m:cw '§ oop'c.HEDP
Pr fa n OP ..:4 m �y CE, �� R
m lm n
W9 Op°o� �.
O° r � ww 0.n n Oro 0 w 0 p r•o i
O GO 5ayv .
dz i N y 0b 0 oo
T op � �41 r1'f . 0Wo I'
H4.4. >00. <{ =i O 31l
05° �bo 3= :.:0 d3�
O.f 3 = ?'0 ` C
C
� '"<
16 3 m 3 O W�N
O
to W SL
- .000,Caon �° °:a o°
0
on y,QP ^o a`N
ro <0 3 O rt
re P 1 1 K R
rZ '»nGa z� 5vm 'cn �o .$'. w+�0
a ?":oo Nwwr -1..1 v�F ^•don
y^Apm w. K 7
0 r0 O 1I p � O
A, F aoe o
. ° go 'Wn 0. f"' gC
a a o co" m a� Y F, a° o od c5 0 '.4 n �
5° °C 'p��o0 °
a »O. mn0 ro 0. UG p O tr 0 • n 0 H � r O cr W'O °00°a �' eoe COL 04 � 'op000�"' ix
e o o 5 5
a
�(✓A.yo �.� p 0.y w w c' H 7 r0�a r�or�0 R c1 .°. w R. y.o w O
E p n n a
p Crena lrm� n aopy°° O 05C•aM ^Zn_•.n,
. me QH�'°rn5 I mm� oo r*.n ro5 m xo <ty v
veO��mD ay�v oo °aa �a0 p�•£K�o Kg�',�R -pw o�
H y
q' rj . N M �i i--• ice to ° Er � N K p f-+ Q• a �l A• ° N H I- W i% I ID
1o,n -,•om �Wa
n
.0 OOrobpp.�vm
° ra N4 U °trio
xp -
P. cr'o o I H
O O O
M aro o
^ r H o W W o 5
H `C `reC o p rn G
O.we ^fin Ci A
�m� a$ 7 o p,t0n'
O 5 N F C a,
-0 p m
a
y N m N
�
K
� [i �j° rn. co
p'�• bona Cp
.1 Cs .n
b fa N m g-V O 5 ti
go, i0
'd 0 O N r°., uoi ' 0 rJ G.
°
� pn�a:..�HSros,n
x�P^`x0
tr
HMd a0 o�
' h
0.
O m O � '.'y �Oj
o a
lox m� y�a.r�o P �n o
o (A O ry in' O
rD►uE
0 o m �4 ,'o aky
m 7
°Ia�ctMF $,a* 'aooa
l4 W n O rn K < ty
n10 °r'0.4:4 nny
O .r^.. R C O .; rte. is H a
:3 pn't3'N a0L.
tr mmNdK a
t: '' Ky r a' p ry H P• y
0 � re �t
0 o mk p o
W
l �
i
iV
C 1
CT
g�c'c
>
mho
yrn0
In 3.
c
IT.t
Q d c)
n 'a
D. :E
n1 g D
N r- D
N D
D
C;?
�w
f)
r—°o
cn r—oo
on col
�m °moo
NSm
m.°oo
muo
om
mog+'.0.
-y.
cP.W
rD
o 3 N
v f0
C (p
2 N 0 rp
N !n• 1°
°
2,
m 3 °i
ro
o
m C) rn
C-)2
y n
ro
S
N
Er
povi °
,dey
E
O m
v
E
o m
tI9 =
E
y
n
o
5C
orec
p N p
no
C
ne
N�mN
n�
C
~-0
L N G
co
= �
o
a.�
sGg
W
r� rnr� 3. o
m 9'
cx
m � o
w
W
-°
n
� m
n
g) m
p n=
o
= m
ri
c
1 0
�O n
—m
fi
O
m
ti
a
l
N
°wc�
W
d�
1 cOi N p
o
v C O
p
moo»
_
o'n
c n
no
ya�mm
m o
�_'
EL
� ii
rn m
_.°
tO
SL
SL
El
04-
D
"C C
v o o
o
fO o
cs• °. ;°.. y1°
fD
/��
Z
m
o: n �.
w -O
w y
N
inn =.
NM
C
° A�
W
01
N
n
N o m
r° ME
N .m+
o S
m m
o�
(9
o
'° y m
; W
N
or ?
cm°
o
�v
m
mY
o
moD�
v�
a) �
_��
2=
H=
:v
�F°n
MME
m
20. o
rig
CX
m Q °0
mm
3
� no
o,on.,
o,on.
�•
o��
on
N. O
C. c
.. O
°
N m �•
3 C
n N
n N
_2
N
�
m ar'r u
� �
�
d (1 •
3 �
� �
d
� �
nn3o.
C
�v
n�
�re
n
ce
re °•"
`�_
c
iii
Or
c
Ca
D
Ci
�
r0 f9
r° N
� r�_ N I
6
� T. •G
� N
1o,n -,•om �Wa
n
.0 OOrobpp.�vm
° ra N4 U °trio
xp -
P. cr'o o I H
O O O
M aro o
^ r H o W W o 5
H `C `reC o p rn G
O.we ^fin Ci A
�m� a$ 7 o p,t0n'
O 5 N F C a,
-0 p m
a
y N m N
�
K
� [i �j° rn. co
p'�• bona Cp
.1 Cs .n
b fa N m g-V O 5 ti
go, i0
'd 0 O N r°., uoi ' 0 rJ G.
°
� pn�a:..�HSros,n
x�P^`x0
tr
HMd a0 o�
' h
0.
O m O � '.'y �Oj
o a
lox m� y�a.r�o P �n o
o (A O ry in' O
rD►uE
0 o m �4 ,'o aky
m 7
°Ia�ctMF $,a* 'aooa
l4 W n O rn K < ty
n10 °r'0.4:4 nny
O .r^.. R C O .; rte. is H a
:3 pn't3'N a0L.
tr mmNdK a
t: '' Ky r a' p ry H P• y
0 � re �t
0 o mk p o
W
l �
i
iV
C 1
CT